Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu regarding Fleetwood Mac

331 replies

Lifeasweknow · 27/04/2020 23:50

This is terribly trivial, I am aware.
I was watching Peter Kay's Car Share and there was a part where Peter Kay's character said that the Fleetwood Mac version of Dreams was better than The Coors version. This is one of my all time favourite songs and personally think The Coors butchered it, however my sister said The Coors version is better.
AIBU to say Fleetwood Mac's original is far better than The Coors version.

OP posts:
DetroitTheTourist · 29/04/2020 18:52

Canterbury whales, I like Stevie. Was always most impressed at the ingenious coke administration stories. I am worried about your preference for anyone over Led Zeppelin.
Patti Smith's changing of the guard is far better than Dylan's . Thanks for the distraction, I'm trying to put off going shopping.

Lifeasweknow · 29/04/2020 18:59

I'm so pleased so many agree! I have found my people. I'm glad people agree with me on the Tracey Chapman / Boyzone front too. I agree that no one should cover TC and I hate all versions of Fast Car

OP posts:
DetroitTheTourist · 29/04/2020 19:01

I learnt the riff from fast car, it's genius. Tracey is my girl crush. Beautiful song, beautiful woman!

Lifeasweknow · 29/04/2020 19:05

@DetroitTheTourist she is a beautiful, wonderful woman. Her voice is something else

OP posts:
DetroitTheTourist · 29/04/2020 19:17

So glad to see someone else who appreciates Tracey! I wish I had got to see her play live. In my dreams I'm her back up guitarist. Tracey kept me going through some tough times.

I've been listening to Big Thief recently, have you heard them?Adrienne Lenker did a lovely John prine cover.

CillianMurphyfanclub · 29/04/2020 20:20

I was just arguing about this with myDP the other day haha.
I absolutely love Fleetwood Mac but in this instance I prefer the Corrs version - I think It’s beautiful.

kierenthecommunity · 29/04/2020 20:47

My DS has just introduced me to the Go Jetters take on ‘Rocking All Over The World.’

I actually prefer it 😂

MadameBee · 29/04/2020 20:49

Nothing can top a Stevie Nicks led Fleetwood Mac over anything in this world.

Saw them at Wembley last year, they were absolutely fantastic.

Pigwig10 · 29/04/2020 20:59

I think in the majority of cases the original is the best. Fleetwood Mac all the way Grin

LaureBerthaud · 29/04/2020 22:04

I'm still going to be Stevie Nicks when I grow up. But with frizz-ease and less sex

Grin and fewer drugs?

Silver Springs is the Mac's best song- it's a crime it was left off Rumours. Here's Stevie singing it aged 49 and utterly ravishing. She really sticks it to Lindsay.

LaureBerthaud · 29/04/2020 22:08

Rhiannon 1976

DetroitTheTourist · 29/04/2020 22:11

The best Fleetwood Mac.

rachaelclaire1 · 30/04/2020 01:04

Oh my god, fucking mental that anyone would compare Fleetwood Mac v Corrs 🤭🤭

Brefugee · 30/04/2020 08:14

PP was comparing the old and the later FM? I see it as two different bands, as i do with the Fish and post-Fish Marillion.

I quite like Patti Smith's version of Beds are Burning but Midnight Oil are just so... amazingly brilliant, it really shouldn't be allowed to cover that at all.

Funkyslippers · 30/04/2020 08:55

Reminds me of when DD said "God I hate the Bee Gees. They totally ruined that 'Tragedy' song"!!!! Grin

Funkyslippers · 30/04/2020 09:00

Oh, and Dreams wasn't originally on The Corrs album but they did a cover of it a released it as a single as their other singles hadn't troubled the charts. Because it was a well known song and Chris Evans promoted it so heavily, they became popular and famous for a few years, mainly due to that one song, then re-released the album with Dreams added. I'm embarrassed to say I bought the album and thought it was shit!

Sorry if anyone else has mentioned this

Fencer90 · 30/04/2020 09:05

This is of course not the real Fleetwood Mac ,this is the one with all the Americans in it with also the talentless Christine McVie.The PROPER Fleetweed Mac consisted of Peter Green, John McVie ,Jeremy Spencer,Danny Kirwin, Mick Fleetwood and Bob Welch. All of whom played at one time for John Mayall.They can be heard on the 1971 Album "Fleetwood Mac"

MockersxxxxxxxSocialDistancing · 30/04/2020 09:43

This is of course not the real Fleetwood Mac

Plastic Mac?

CaroleFuckinBaskin · 30/04/2020 09:52

Oh, and Dreams wasn't originally on The Corrs album but they did a cover of it a released it as a single as their other singles hadn't troubled the charts. Because it was a well known song and Chris Evans promoted it so heavily, they became popular and famous for a few years, mainly due to that one song, then re-released the album with Dreams added. I'm embarrassed to say I bought the album and thought it was shit!

I thought their first album 'Forgiven Not Forgotten' was quite good - they did some. really good trad instrumental arrangements on there and I quite liked some of the songs. But yes, it was the cover of Dreams and the subsequent 'remix' version of Talk on Corners (which also originally had some quite good stuff on it) that ruined everything!

DGRossetti · 30/04/2020 10:25

This is of course not the real Fleetwood Mac ,this is the one with all the Americans in it

It could be said Fleetwood Mac are one of those bands with more members than hits ...

The PROPER Fleetweed Mac consisted of Peter Green, John McVie ,Jeremy Spencer,Danny Kirwin, Mick Fleetwood and Bob Welch.

Peter Green is probably the best blues guitarist Britain has ever produced. If he'd stayed off the drugs, Eric Clapton would have been a pub singer (with a drug habit).

All of whom played at one time for John Mayall.They can be heard on the 1971 Album "Fleetwood Mac"

One of the great "what ifs" of rock history.

MockersxxxxxxxSocialDistancing · 30/04/2020 12:52

I mentioned my favourite cover of all time upthread, and think it bears scrutiny:

The change from male to female vocal can transform a song, and never more than this. The Candlewick Green original which I adored as a kid because I loved the tune, had no idea about the lyric, is all about a sensitive soul who's "just a guy who only wants what's good," but is increasingly concerned by his histrionic, self-harming girlfriend who, despite all his efforts, is finally pushing him a bit too far.

Now compare and contrast with Saint Etienne. With just one rhyme-destroying change of pronoun in the opening line, we hear a different side of the story. She is just a girl who only wants what's right, but has fallen for an abuser, and when every day brings another scar, it is at his hand and not self-inflicted.

Which leads me to wonder if the guy in the original doth protest too much?

And the high point is when the unutterably wonderful Sarah Cracknell delivers her sarcastic "The lights are changing, Baby!" and we know the worm has turned.

Compare and Contrast:

Fencer90 · 30/04/2020 13:16

I heard in an interview with John McVie that Peter Green was spiked with LSD and had a very bad experience and never has recovered........

Triggahippy · 30/04/2020 13:23

Your sister is not ok.
My fave cover ever is Hurt when covered by Johnny Cash

user1493379562 · 30/04/2020 13:27

Fleetwood Mac definitely !!!

glennamy · 30/04/2020 14:18

Just be grateful she hasn't heard the other 73 recordings by different artistes, (75 in total) including the FM original (the best) & the Coors copy! YANBU