Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it tight and weird to only buy for dcs at Xmas?

185 replies

Cakeyhead · 07/11/2019 12:08

We have three teenage dcs. Christmas is going to be tight this year. Oldest dc is at uni and we've had to supplement his loan, youngest dc has moved to private school (SEN). Just had to pay a huge car breakdown bill. So we aren't on the breadline which makes this decision harder, but for the next few years money is going to be really really tight.

Every year I put 10 in a card for my brothers who are both over 30, unmarried, no kids. Give my dsis a gift card (25) and buy my parents things from m and s with a gift receipt so they can return. My mum is really fussy and used to make a huge drama if people bought her things that she thought were 'weird', hence the reciept. Ususally spend about 50 or 60 on parents.I have one niece who I like to spend about 30 on.

One year I suggested buying for kids only, but my siblings got arsey because they have one dc between them (my niece) and I have 3. My parents also thought I was mean for not putting the 10 in the card for my brothers.

My mum always buys me something like a cheap toilertry set that i don't want or need, and gives the dds £10 each, which I do think is a bit tight but they dont have much money either.

I had an awful childhood although ive moved on from that now but i barely see my parents so the whole thing seems hollow. They refuse to travel to see us (we're near Birmingham they are just east of London).

My dsis is an alcoholic which she's trying to cope with but this year she's sent me some really quite nasty texts which have upset me so my contact with her is minimal. I'd love to spend a bit more on her dd, my niece. Last year dsis was so drunk and skint she didnt get my dds anything which was fine, she was in a bad place. However she did say to them she'd get them something in the new year and just never did despite getting herself botox.

Sorry this is long and rambling.

Dh says just be firm and say kids only.

Wwyd and aibu?

OP posts:
TiffanyAtBreakfast · 07/11/2019 12:54

Also with your family background I can understand why you don't want to buy for these people. As I said, don't feel forced into giving a tenner. Give them what you want to, only!

constantlyseekinghappiness · 07/11/2019 12:54

Dh meant that they dont have kids, so have lots more disposable income than us. So financially its not unfair.

Charming!

Why don’t you just say you’re not doing presents for anyone and tell them not to get you or your DC anything. None of this ‘kids only’ thing. Your DC are teenagers. Hardly of ‘Santa’ age!

Sorted.

museumum · 07/11/2019 12:54

If I were you I’d buy everyone something around the £15 mark that fits their likes or interests. Definitely not 50-60 on something your mum will exchange!!!! And why does your sis get 25 spent but your brothers only ten each?

SingaporeSlinky · 07/11/2019 12:54

I think YABU to say only buy for kids to the 2 DBs who don’t have kids, as you’re basically saying you’re not going to give them gifts anymore. If they are buying your 3 dcs, it’s fine for them to not buy for you anymore, but you should still buy for them. Then if they do have children, stop buying adults and just do kids.
If your DSis buys for your 3, it’s probably fair to spend a little more on her one DC to even it out.
Having said that, £10 in a card for an adult is a bit odd as it’ll just go in their wallet, so a little more thought into their gifts would be best.

Kanga83 · 07/11/2019 12:54

I only buy for my kids, then token gifts for two nieces and two nephews, nothing for my other BIL's kids as never met them and never will. I buy token (The Works) sticker books for one friends kids as she's godmother to one of mine and I buy for my godson. Told DH siblings and couple of my friends years ago we wouldn't buy for adults anymore and we've stuck to it. First year was a hassle as they bought for us, but they soon realised we were quite serious. I don't buy for PIL- husband is very low contact, and I'm NC so it's up to him if he wants to do something there. My parents always say not to get anything , maybe some chocolate and their Christmas cards that the kids can choose and give them .

TonTonMacoute · 07/11/2019 12:55

My DB and I don't exchange presents, although he has always been happy to give DS presents, in fact as he hasn't got kids I think he quite likes it.

Butterymuffin · 07/11/2019 12:55

I would get a gift for your niece and say to all the others that this year you're not doing gifts with the exception of your niece, and therefore you don't expect any from them either - for adults OR for your kids. That way there is no unfairness. I would scale down for niece and get just a small thing but that you know she'll like. Your sister can whistle as she's been crap. Same for your mum.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 07/11/2019 12:55

One of my sisters does "kids only". I didn't mind so much when the kids were younger. Now they're older (early - mid teens) I am not going to spend a fortune on them. I do reciprocated presents only.

My other sister and I exchange presents. For her children and for each other.

Novemberblu3s · 07/11/2019 12:56

we only ever buy for the kids. We could afford presents for adults but one usually ends up buying only stuff nobody really needs (if I would really need it, I'd get it myself and not wait for Xmas). I also hate the whole commercial side of Xmas. all this shopping just for its own sake.

We just buy for the kids and don't go overboard. we spend less than £100 each (DC are 9 and 12).

DH and I are grown ups. We really have outgrown the need for Xmas pressies.

GoodGriefSunshine · 07/11/2019 12:56

BeanBag7, the OP has said that...Last year my dsis and db1 didn't get me anything. Db2 always gets me a cheap fun nerdy present that i quite look forward to.

So it is hardly unfair to say dc only as they don't even get the OP anything. So currently it appears that the only person giving anything of any use/value is the OP. Why should she continue?

OP, just get some sass. Why do you care when anyone tells you off for being tight - throw back that they only buy you cheap tat or nothing at all so you aren't the tight one.

Cakeyhead · 07/11/2019 12:57

My dbs didnt buy anything for my dcs last year.

I have heard from dsis and shes absolutely fine with it. I have aksed her for some ideas for dniece, she wants vouchers so i will probably end up giving her 50 of vouchers. All good.

OP posts:
Cakeyhead · 07/11/2019 12:58

OP, just get some sass Grin yes you are right.sad to say i am still a bit scared of my mum and our odd family dynamic

Sometimes if you've had a chaotic childhood its hard to know how to behave as an adult!

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 07/11/2019 12:59

We texted family a few years ago announcing that we're only buying christmas presents for the children. It's been great. We are so glad we did it.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 07/11/2019 13:00

We (all adults in family) stopped buying each other presents a few years ago.

Saves money and means we don't end up with loads of crap we don't want or need.

Kids only. Makes life so much simpler!

inwood · 07/11/2019 13:03

Kids in our family only. I don't see the point in getting my sister for example a £50 voucher for her to get me the same. We do do a £10 secret Santa for anyone who is together on the day.

Greyhound22 · 07/11/2019 13:03

I would give something cheap to your Mum and Dad, DB2 and Neice. Your DSister can't really expect anything - tell her you thought she wasn't bothering anymore.

I do think kids only can work out unfair - DSIL is only young and doesn't have kids and since we had our DC two sets of relatives have stopped buying for her 😑 as it's 'kids only' now. I then feel I have to make it up to up so buy her extra.

Cakeyhead · 07/11/2019 13:04

Even dh and I aren't getting eachother anything! Honestly, a lovely walk on boxing day a bottle of wine, a lovely meal and a film, just to celebrate that its all over, is what i want!

OP posts:
kaldefotter · 07/11/2019 13:04

I don’t have kids, but DH and I are both from big families. A few years ago, we suggested it was time for everyone to buy only for the kids. Everyone was relieved and said yes. So we don’t get gifts (except from our parents), but our families aren’t going broke buying for all the adults as well as kids. It works well.

Gift giving shouldn’t be tit for tat. Why do your 30-something brothers need cash in a card? They’re not 12.

hellswelshy · 07/11/2019 13:04

I don't think yabu at all. In fact quite amazed at some of the responses here regarding 'your choice to have children' etc!!! Do those posters remember we were all children once and we were the recipients of these gifts!?
I had a similar conversation recently with my mil as I reached a point last year where she she got me something that I didn't want again, not a cheap gift by any means but just not one I wanted or had an interest in. So a waste of her money and also effort as she loathes gift shopping! Plus she tells us what to get her EVERY YEAR.
So this year I proposed she not buy for dh and I, just our dd's. She didn't seem to like the idea, and actually said 'but that means I won't get a present!' ??
As a compromise we are all doing secret Santa, it will be much more fun in my opinion.

Potnoodledoo · 07/11/2019 13:06

@Batqueen Thats bollix,by the sounds of the the op spends more on them than they get in return.

Just buy for your kids.Let them have a strop.

Telesto · 07/11/2019 13:06

Do your DBs usually give you a present? I think YNBU to stop giving adults £10 in card. I was going to suggest a secret Santa amongst the adults, so all
Buying one gift around £10, but if not so close I wouldn’t even do that. I think gifts for kids only is fine. You could maybe put in some chocolates or a small family gift since you have more children to buy for.

DaisyTulip · 07/11/2019 13:08

I don't think it's fair to say kids only if your DBs don't have kids. You could say that people buy for each other as normal/as they see fit, but you and Dsis could have an arrangement not to buy for each other, just for kids (and set a limit of say £30 so that would mean your DCs get something of £10 each and you would spend £30 on your DN alone but then you said you wanted to treat DN a bit more due to Dsis's issues).

Or you could suggest a Secret Santa amongst everyone but buy your DN an extra gift anyway?

Paddingtonthebear · 07/11/2019 13:10

We only buy for kids in our family. We have one child and there are 4 nieces and nephews that we buy for so yes technically we spend more than they do but it’s easier and more cost efficient than buying random stuff for adults. We did all agree on it years ago though.

Lunafortheloveogod · 07/11/2019 13:10

£2 lynx set for the moaners? There’s probably a cheap ladies one too? That’s what £10 all in for all of them Grin. You had to cut back and they didn’t want to do dc’s only... they’d maybe rather not have crap they don’t want next year Grin

MitchellMummy · 07/11/2019 13:12

I don't have kids. I buy for sibling's kids - happily - without expecting anything in return. It got to the stage where we were buying for the sake of it, and once people are adult (or at least earning their own money!) it's time to stop. Much less stress all round.