Ok, I will admit right now that I haven't RTFT (and usually that is something that really bugs me) but I think this is one of those rare times when it doesn't necessarily matter.
Sadly, I have RL experience of two male friends disclosing horrific sexual abuse to me that took place when they were children/teenagers. They are two of the most harrowing experiences of my life.
But I learned a lot from them (and the help they'd sought over the years) and while obviously it's now a case of "They said this... but MJ isn't here to reply..." sadly I recognise a lot of the denial/pretending it didn't happen/only hit me later in life that it did" language in Wade and James as I've listened to in my friends.
All the signs (including the initial denials made under oath where they were made) are exactly in line with how young (especially male at the hands of another male) victims of abuse try to deal with things.
My instincts is to believe them. It's not always about evidence provable in a court of law. Hearing their wives talk about how they are having to live with the abuse by default echoes so clearly with my own experiences (and I was not romantically involved, only a friend). The breakdown in the normal family relationships isn't something anyone admits to for fun or publicity unless they're complete sociapathic narcissists... ok, one might be - but all of them? What are the odds?
Broken people don't fit a profile. They don't all act the same way. Many of successful in later life, outwardly at least. But inside? They're broken. And it shows, even when they don't mean it to.
Added to that, I have a family member who has been involved in investigating childhood abuse. They know their stuff. There is no one 'right way' of reacting. But abuse is abuse no matter how the victim reacts.