Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH, SIL and the football match

174 replies

Namechanger20183110 · 31/10/2018 23:18

Sorry this is long

Without being too outing, today a big football match was taking place for a team that I support, that was being televised live. I used to be a season ticket holder but can’t find the time after having DD to go to matches. Therefore I like to watch their big games on tv if they are on.

I told DH several weeks ago that he would need to put DD in bed on this day (always me that does it) as I would like to watch the build up to the game for a change. As it happens I ended up putting her to bed as she fell asleep very quickly

When we got home from work/nursery, DH said he’d spoken to his sister earlier, and that he’d asked her if she wanted to come over for dinner this evening.

I reminded him that I’d be watching the match, in the main living room (that’s the only room Sky works in) and that I was not going to be hosting/cooking. He laughed it off and said that he would cook and then sit with SIL in another room to let me watch the match in peace, as he is not into football anyway and neither is she. Fine I thought, I do like SIL and we have a good relationship. We see each other twice weekly at least as she doesn’t live far, so I don’t feel like I have to necessarily have a ‘catch up’ with her everytime she visits, and so I know she wouldn’t have a problem with this either.

Anyway, I put DD to bed, the match starts. DH and SIL are in the kitchen talking and making dinner happily. I have told them I don’t want dinner as I had a late heavy lunch so i’ll just have something light at half time.

They finish making dinner and then eat in the room I am watching tv (where we have a dining table). No problem with this, we are chatting as they eat and I watch tv, I’m not ignoring them and I’m keeping an eye on the match too, so it’s all fine.

After dinner, rather than go to the other room as planned, SIL and DH sit on the next sofa to me, and SiL starts talking about deep issues going on in her life. She starts telling us about a close family friend who has been beaten up. I am talking to her about it and being involved in the conversation, when my team score a few minutes later. As I’m half watching the screen, my instant reaction is to cheer as my SIL is in the middle of talking about this serious situation . I instantly apologised, to which she laughed and said it’s fine, I put the volume up slightly to hear the commentary to the goal, then after 20 seconds when I had seen/heard it properly, turned it back down and carried on talking to SIL and DH about the friend.

Unbeknown to me, DH has text me when I did this with “you just came across as a bellend”. I didn’t see his text until 10 minutes later, and I didn’t reply, I carried on speaking to SIL while trying to watch the match at the same time.

50 mins later (so at half time), SIL gets up to leave. We say our goodbyes. I return to the tv, DH walks in with a look of thunder on his face and says “ignoring my text then?”

I replied that the text was sent almost an hour ago and that I didn’t think it would still be bothering him, and I defended myself by saying tht I apologised to SIL for interrupting her.

He then completely dismissed what I said and called me rude, how I should care more about speaking to my SIL rather than a football team and that he will disrupt my conversations all week for me to see how it feels Confused. He made it sound like I shut her down when all I did was cheer and turn the volume up for 20 seconds.

By this point, I admit I was pretty annoyed as he was blatantly exaggerating, and snapped back that I had explicitly told him I would be occupying the tv for this match today (I rarely watch tv in the evenings) and that he had no business to invite SIL over for dinner without asking me, and then expect me to watch my match while listening to SiL telling us her life stories.

He then flipped and left the room, and we’ve not spoken since.

Who is BU?

OP posts:
Laureline · 01/11/2018 06:06

Does your DH regularly disrupt any “me time” you organize for yourself?

CallMeOnMyCell · 01/11/2018 06:22

Hmm sorry OP I think YABU. I could understand you cheering and turning up the TV if your SIL wasn’t talking about something serious but she was. She hasn’t done anything wrong here, your DH has, so I don’t think she deserved to be treated that way.

chillipophey · 01/11/2018 06:33

Hmmm I think cheering a goal in the middle of a serious conversation is a bit rude tbh.

Havaina · 01/11/2018 06:34

YANBU. He doesn't see your interests and down time as important. As pp said, reinstate that season ticket or watch more games at home and he puts dc to bed. I'm guessing he gets more free time?

Havaina · 01/11/2018 06:36

And if he invited her, then there's a chance he wanted to sabotage your plans for the evenings.

strawberrisc · 01/11/2018 06:47

Your SIL should clearly have picked up on the fact you were watching your team in your own house. She’s a bellend too.

OliviaBenson · 01/11/2018 06:48

I hate football with a passion. But I'm with you here, your evening watching the game was preplanned and he sabotaged it.

He owes you an apology for this. Also, texting you is really passive aggressive.

Is he usually like this?

NicePieceOfPlaid · 01/11/2018 06:59

It was only football. You were very, very rude to your SiL. No wonder your DH is angry. It's just a game, she was talking about real life worries. Can you not see how heartless that was? Turning the sound up. Good grief.

Iloveacurry · 01/11/2018 07:02

He was being unreasonable. He knew you wanted to watch the game and should of gone to the other room.

lastqueenofscotland · 01/11/2018 07:07

I’m a huge football fan OP I get it.
While cheering while your SIL was talking is a bit cringe your DH has agreed to let you be. It’s not fair on you, you are allowed “me time.”

BoneyBackJefferson · 01/11/2018 07:13

NicePieceOfPlaid

But if the DH had stuck to his side of the deal non of this would have happened.

Why should the OP have to put her plans on hold because he doesn't do what he says he is going to do?

sonandhelpneeded · 01/11/2018 07:13

YANBU

Kintan · 01/11/2018 07:27

Sorry OP I think you were being unreasonable. Your DH didn’t know his sister would be talking about deep issues, so the situation had changed and you didn’t adapt to it. If you were half joining in the conversation but then still cheered even though your SiL was pouring her heart out about her abused friend then you were being crassly insensitive. I will admit I can’t comprehend how people are so passionate about football, so perhaps you were caught up in some kind of fervour I don’t understand!

CantWaitToRetire · 01/11/2018 07:30

Cheering after the goal - instinct and acceptable. Turning the volume up after apologising for cheering invalidates the apology a bit. However, your DH texting you for cheering - surely that’s rude in its own right? If I was having a somewhat serious conversation with my brother and he started texting, I’d find that impolite.

I agree with PP that DH should not have sabotaged your evening by inviting his DS round and then sitting in the TV room to chat.

If he follows through on his threat to disrupt your conversations for the next week, remember to text him each time saying “who’s the bellend now?”

RhiWrites · 01/11/2018 07:33

Really @kintan ? You can’t understand wanting to watch a looked forward to programme? Try to imagine it’s something you were looking forward to, like the final of Bake Off, and don’t be snarky about someone else’s interests.

ilovesooty · 01/11/2018 07:34

The only thing you did wrong was to put up with them rudely interrupting your planned watching of the match.

BelindasRedPlasticHandcuffs · 01/11/2018 07:35

It doesn't matter that it was football.

Op had plans. She made her plans clear well in advance. DH unilaterally decided to make his own plans that infringed on OP's established plan and expected OP to join in. Op made it clear that her plans would continue when SIL arrived. SIL arrived and started a deep conversation in a room where it was presumably clear Op was focussed on the match even if she was chatting. DH got pissy with Op because Op wasn't giving SIL full attention. After explicitly being told she wouldn't. Dh threw a stop like a small child.

DH is a bellend for making plans and infringing on Ops night and acting like a dick after. I say that as someone that bloody hates football because i have so many memories of having to shut up for my dad to watch it.

FWIW though, I do think that you should have cut the conversation off earlier Op. You were sending mixed messages by engaging in conversation with them over the match, and if someone had been talking to me about one of my friends that was the victim of DV and then started cheering I'd be monumentally fucked off and hurt, so despite the fact that SIL laughed it off that was insensitive.

With the benefit of hindsight, asking DH to help with drinks and telling him to take SIL into another room so they could talk properly would have been better once it became clear the conversation was taking a deeper turn, although I appreciate the fact that you can't do that without missing a bit of the match (and shouldn't really have to given you made your plans clear). Realistically DH should have suggested it because it's his sister and he was the one infringing on your night. But he was being a knob.

BelindasRedPlasticHandcuffs · 01/11/2018 07:36

Sorry for the essay Blush

lastqueenofscotland · 01/11/2018 07:41

I think OP you should have just said “I’m sorry I’m watching the match” and ignored them completely.
I also suspect I know which team you support and if so a) they aren’t on sky a lot and only were as they were playing a premiership side b) great game Grin

Kintan · 01/11/2018 07:43

@RhiWrites I wasn’t being snarky, I admitted I didn’t understand! The OP asked for opinions and it’s not for you to chide someone for giving theirs. But I have to say if someone was in need of talking (and clearly the SiL wanted the OP involved or wouldn’t have started the conversation in their presence) I can’t think of any TV show it would be so important for me to watch live that I would put that first. But again as I said I don’t understand the appeal of football and I know it can cause passions to run high!

LotsToThinkOf · 01/11/2018 07:49

OP you are absolutely NOT the one being UR in this situation. You mad early plans and your DH decided you were doing something else, then he's having a go at you because you didn't skip along and change your plans like he wanted.

SIL was rude too, she could see you were preoccupied and instead of leaving you to it and speaking to her brother, she decided to harp on about her life issues to you. She was also insistent that your attention was on her, what was you ur DH doing whilst she was recounting her life story to you? Apart from being able to text you which obviously isn't rude when someone is speaking is it?

Do not apologise. Is DH usually this controlling? Or does he dislike that you watch football? I hate football but DH loves it so I try and stay out of the way when he's watching. It's not fair to intrude on someone's time like that.

IncomingCannonFire · 01/11/2018 07:50

Well you should have told dh to go visit his sister rather than have her round yours. But it sounds like he deliberately wanted to sabotage and have an argument over the football issue.
Also he needs to man up and start putting your dd to bed.
Does he do this often or is it only over the footie?
But at the same time it was rude to have a half convoy and cheer over your sil.
You should have reminded them both of your plans when they came in.

HiHoToffee · 01/11/2018 07:58

YANBU
They knew the plan, they should have left you to watch the match.
Why would anyone start a serious conversation with someone who is otherwise occupied?

Next time watch it in the pub.

Hope your team won.

RhiWrites · 01/11/2018 07:59

@kintan Now it sounds as though you’re being snarky about television in general. Is there really no plan you’d make for yourself that you’d rather not have disrupted?

Bear in mind SIL wasn’t having an emergency, even if she was talking about something ‘important’.

If you don’t mean it as snark, I’m sorry. But I do see a lot of condemning football and TV (and computer games) as worthless pursuits, as well as the suggestion that women should be endlessly at the beck and call of their family.

So it seems to be to suffer from a failure of imagination to not be able to conceive of something long planned and looked forward to being spoilt by a guest who seems to have deliberately been invited to stop you enjoying yourself.

SalemBlackCat4 · 01/11/2018 08:01

Your husband is a spiteful, immature arsehole. In response to him saying he will interrupt you, you should say well then, next time you plan something important to you that you arranged in advance, e.g a boys night out, I will go along with you and talk incessantly at you and your mates about women's stuff so you cannot enjoy your night that you planned in advance, and told me about in advance.

Or, alternatively, you could just ask him to read this thread and hopefully it will get through to his head what a self-absorbed, spiteful and insensitive arsehole he is, and he can make you breakfast in bed for an entire week to apologise for him ruining your night that he knew about in advance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread