A lot of people seem to have misunderstood what I said. I didn’t say all women were like that, I said it was a very dominant strain of female socialisation but not the only one. What a lot of people aren’t getting when they say ‘Well I’m not like that.’ Is that I know there are women who aren’t as I’m friends with them!
I can understand that some women manage to mainly avoid women like this, particularly if they start work highly qualified and don’t come through the ranks of lower skilled staff, plus if they’re in industries with fewer women like science or engineering.
However many women who are like that would never, ever admit it. I do think this thread is a perfect example of that type though. I mean, what sort of woman over the age of 23 sits around thinking about who likes who and what their opinion on someone else’s friendship circle is and how that’s going to affect how they treat them? This sort of shit holds women back, you don’t get men in board meetings talking about who they like and don’t like. It’s this sort of crap that labels women as emotional rather than pragmatic decision makers.
And I disagree with this quote because I didn’t say all women followed the stereotype for one thing, and for another there are plenty of women over 25 who ARE like this.
I'd say it's the people who think the things you've posted and base the assumption that they have nothing in common with ither women who have swallowed stereotypes whole! I don't think "women" as a class are like that at all! Some are, some aren't - most aren't once you're over 25...
None of my friends are super close to their mothers either - just normally close
This quote is a perfect example of what I talked about earlier. The type of woman who is so convinced she’s got womanhood right she won’t countenance there are different ways of doing it. Who are you to say what is normal and what is not? Just because it’s what you and your circle of friends do? It’s normal for you and your circle of friends, but for other people different amounts of closeness are normal and there’s nothing wrong with that. There is no uniform ‘normal’ for women and we shouldn’t be made to feel like there is.
I think women who conform to these stereotypes frequently don’t see themselves as these women anyway. Because they know the ‘rules’ for this type and follow them, the nastiness of transgressing is never aimed at them and they like to see themselves as mutually supportive and caring. Their attitude towards the nastiness to people who transgress is also on display in this thread, because they don’t see it as being nasty either. They see it as justified anger towards somebody who has slighted them by not doing womaning properly.
I had a brief look at that ‘Text me when you get home’ book. I could be wrong, but from the synopsis it seems like almost a handbook for this sort of womanhood and a justification of it being the right way to woman. It seems to be written and quoted mainly from this sort of woman from the inside of this sort of group and is concerned with saying how wonderful it is. It doesn’t seem to have much in there about what it’s like to be women outside these groups or what it feels like when these groups decide you’ve offended them and personally slighted them by not conforming to their idea of ‘normal’, ‘decent’ or ‘correct’ womaning is.