Caligula The Canadian shooter threads weren't nice and I didn't participate in them. They were also all deleted IIRC so obviously MNHQ agreed with us. I fail to see the problem there. The transphobia as as spotted, challenged, reported and dealt with so HQ obviously did their jobs.
The organ donor one was about hypothetical womb transplants. A lot of women didn't feel comfortable about their womb going to someone who was male bodied when they would prefer them to go to someone female bodied. I don't agree with them but they are entitled to their own feelings on it. And this was all hypothetical anyway because we aren't transplanting wombs (yet). I doubt anyone would care if their heart or kidney for instance were to go to a transgender person because the sex of the of the person receiving it is irrelevant.
The posts about Lily Madigan are valid. That person clearly isn't in the right frame of mind to be any officer for Labour let alone a woman's one. Quite frankly Labour should be ashamed of taking advantage of someone who is clearly vulnerable. The piss taking of her on here can be a bit harsh sometimes but she does bring a lot of it on herself with the idiotic things she says (like claiming she can get pregnant). I don't think the fact LM is trans should give her a get out clause from criticism. If it was anyone else saying the same things she is, hell even if a woman was going on like her, then they would be under the same amount of scrutiny, criticism and piss taking. The fact she is trans should not stop people from calling her out on her BS.
I didn't see the phalloplasty post so I can't comment on that.
Nobody on here thinks transwomen and transgirls are all perverts, sex offenders and rapists. I've seen people claim that's what is being said but I'm yet to actually see anyone claim that.
What people are saying however is that sex offenders and perverts will take advantage of self ID policies and laws in order to male offending easier. That is not the same thing as saying that transwomen and transgirls are all doing it just to perve on us. Remember that trans women have shared spaces with us for years without issue.
Think about it now. If you're a sex offender or simply just a creep who likes to intimidate women then why wouldn't you jump at the chance of simply having to say "I identify as a woman and then boom you're allowed in female changing rooms at the gym. If any woman challenges them then they just have to say they are doing nothing wrong and claim transphobia.
Tbh I find it baffling that people hear the words 'predatory men will use self ID in order to get easier access to victims' and somehow come to the conclusion that we are saying all trans women are predatory or only doing it to be predatory.
In fact if you can show me any post which claims that all trans women are perverts or sex offenders then I will donate a tenner to a charity of your choice.