My experience of Internet dating was this:
Both friend and I set up accounts on Guardian Soulmates - ie. a certain kind of 'professional' :) We're attractive enough, witty, well-educated, nice, mid-30s...
My friend shot to the top of the 'most popular' woman board. I did not get a snifter/nudge/wink whatever it was.
I feel - although I can't verify this obvs - that the difference was that she was child-free, and I was PT with a young child.
Maybe if the guys met me 'naturally', it would have been ok, but in the world of OD, men felt they could do better.
Fair enough.
The good news is, I went on Match.com - slightly less professional/po-faced and I was inundated with fellas! And ended up with a very nice one too. :)
Keep your mind open, OP, and value yourself. 