Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I've had it with my MIL. I think we need to cut her out....

206 replies

MaryPoppinsPenguins · 25/12/2016 21:11

Such a long backstory. DH & I are completely not contact with his brother and his wife, over things that happened a few years ago. My DD2 has some serious medical issues and without going into it too much, we feel they are at least partly to blame and they've treated us very very badly. Ive had threads about it years ago and it was unanimously in our favour. We haven't seen or spoken to them for more than three years, avoiding FIL's 70th party, Christmas meals etc... and as they live in another country it's not hard to avoid them day to day. My oldest DD found it very hard to suddenly lose her cousin she was very close to, but has all but forgotten about him now and our youngest children have never met the other family that they would remember.

So yesterday we had a big lunch for DH, his parents were there and we all had a great time. MIL feels it's my doing that her family has been 'torn apart' and no matter how much my DH tells her it's actually his decision, she refused to believe it and makes digs all the time. But she was so nice at the lunch, it was bizarre.

This morning we got straight out of bed, packed up the kids and presents and drove there in pjs, total states, to have Christmas morning with DH's parents.

I was helping DD2 up the steps and DD1 ran ahead and I heard her shout out that her cousin was there.

MIL came to the door and said 'Surprise... we've got some special guests!'

They've been there since yesterday. She knew and could've warned us, but instead she pushed her own agenda against all of our feelings and it was like a car crash. We were all so scruffy and unprepared for one thing.. B&SIL were completely dressed up. I mean, we don't want to see them at anytime, let alone when we're at our worst. There's a horrible vulnerability about standing there facing someone who has really hurt you in old pyjamas and with bedhair!

The idea of them being in the same room as my DD2 makes me feel sick. There's so much history and it's been such a long time. It actually made my heart jump. We argued, turned and left and MIL text and said I was wrong.

I felt shocked and shaky all day, after this morning, actually our Christmas was ruined. DD1 was so upset, they didn't get to go in and have their presents, it was a shock to them to just turn around and leave, and also DH & I have been upset all day.

Shes not sorry, she doesn't care. She constantly thinks I'm in the wrong. She refuses to think it's anything other than my fault despite the fact that I tried to sort things with B & SIL about a dozen times in the early days.

I want to cut MIL out, but obviously she's DH's mum and I don't want him to resent me for the rest of our lives. But today I think he'd agree.

I text her and said 'why would you do this to us? It's Christmas Day! What did you think would happen?'

She has zero remorse.

OP posts:
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 27/12/2016 01:08

You missed out:

It is not unreasonable for the OP and her DH to have gone NC with the poisonous toads (B and SIL) who mocked them at their wedding, who then orchestrated a smear campaign against them and blatantly lied about them, to try and cause bad feeling about them among the wider family.

Or did that bit just pass you by?

CinnamonSteve · 27/12/2016 01:26

Research is also ongoing concerning the release of Cortisol over a prolonged traumatic period of childhood. Research also shows these people are significantly inclined to develop autoimmune conditions in adult life.

Donna .Jackson Nakazawa's excellent Childhood Disrupted book goes into great detail.

I'm really sorry OP, definitely NC is a very reasonable path to take.

quirkychick · 27/12/2016 08:27

What thumbwitches said. We had something similar with a family member we are nc with, it might have been remedied had said family member not set up a smear campaign, fake emails etc. It is the mark of someone toxic, who following a disagreement escalates their behaviour and lies to try to silence you. I think some pps maybe have not experienced this and are thinking it's a straightforward misunderstanding.

If the mil had wanted family harmony, she should have stepped in at the time of the wedding, not forced a reconciliation and hoped they would all pretend it had gone away!

Brewdolf · 27/12/2016 08:35

That's interesting cinnamon. My maternal family caused my DM a lot of unnecessary strife whilst she was pregnant with me, but by the time sister was born she'd gone Nc with them for a while at least

I'm busy collecting autoimmune disorders. Sister is fine Envy

Always thought it was bad luck on my part. Anything remotely genetically linked I seem to get too.

Same seems to be happening with dc1 (picking up the 'family' illnesses) when I was stuck with boss from hell whilst pregnant, where dc2 seems unscathed from anything.

stopfuckingshoutingatme · 27/12/2016 08:59

Awful story so sorry about your ruined christmas too . Yanbu - have some peaceful family time and stop communicating for a while - really a temporary NC period will help you decide what you want to do

And if in doubt - do nowt Flowers

toptoe · 27/12/2016 09:26

You were ambushed. It's a ridiculous thing to do and would obviously have ended in a row with you looking like the bad guy. Your mil sounds naive at best. Is it your bil or sil in the driving seat behind it though? With the weirdness of sending false text messages they sound sociopathic and might have convinced someone that they couldn't possibly be that bad.

Does mil often put one son before the other?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page