Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think regifting is actually just plain cruel and heartless, let alone tight-wadding?

313 replies

dogsdieinhotcars · 23/10/2016 23:36

I mean, if someone has bought you a gift, and you rewrap it for someone else...how bloody rude and tight-fisted! I'm all for recycling, up cycling and all that shit, but honestly, how is this not just f***g rude?!

OP posts:
stopfuckingshoutingatme · 24/10/2016 11:44

YABU

I think buying pointless cack for people is rude TBH, well maybe not rude bit its waste of time and money

shovetheholly · 24/10/2016 11:48

Why are people assuming that the gift that is re-given is going to be crap?

Not everyone has the same tastes. You could think a cushion was lovely, and I could think it was hideous. You could enjoy beer, while I think it's absolutely horrible stuff that tastes of burnt rubber. Etc. etc. etc.

If a shop does one, I always give people a gift receipt with the item, so that they can take it back and exchange it if they don't like it for precisely this reason. I don't think my taste is universal, and if someone likes something in there better, I'd much rather they changed my present for a gift they enjoy.

RhiWrites · 24/10/2016 12:13

Well of people would get over themselves and give the money or vouchers that were originally suggested none of this would be an issue would it hmm

To me, money and vouchers are a crap impersonal gift and it's quite grabby to ask for them. Says, no rubbish you've pick, just the ££.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/10/2016 12:18

I think buying pointless cack for people is rude TBH, well maybe not rude bit its waste of time and money

Exactly. I would say that 80/90% of the gifts I have received as an adult I have not used, not liked, not wanted, so have just been wasteful clutter that cause me stress and guilt because I then have to store and eventually give away an item that I did not ask to be given.

Adults with their own money do not need gifts. Just buy what you want or need when you want it. If you must exchange Christmas or Birthday gifts just buy token wine/chocs etc and I would even say that isn't necessary, because you are unlikely to get what you would choose yourself.

For example, I saw the 3 for £10 chocolate selection in Asda the other day - there were about 10 different boxes of chocolates and I would only really like or want 3 of them - so I just bought them for myself because it is very unlikely that anyone buying one of these for me would pick the ones I wanted.

My idea for Christmas is that all adults buy themselves a present. You still get to talk about it and show it off to visitors during the 'what did you get for Christmas' conversation, but you get to set the budget and get exactly what you want and no-one stresses about finding the perfect present for other people that they probably don't want anyway. And it's not a whole lot different to those people who say to their DH etc - buy me X item from Y shop for Christmas.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/10/2016 12:21

Are we all that short of something to do that we need to spend time going out buying something to give to someone along with a gift receipt so they can also spend time going to exchange that item for something they actually want and they probably do the same for you?

Why bother? Honestly, what is the point? Haven't RTFT so I don't know if anyone has posted MSEs No Unnecessary Presents Pact yet?

SoupDragon · 24/10/2016 12:21

I donate a large proportion of my Christmas gifts to the school fair. I am happy that someone has bothered to buy me a gift but, if it's not to my taste, it's better off going somewhere it will be used.

MrsHathaway · 24/10/2016 12:27

Unwanted smellies and chocolates are usually welcome at food banks. Unwanted unused toys are good for the Rotary/Lions/etc collections as well.

We sometimes do a big "regift" of all the stuff that's just not quite you (eg toiletries, scarf) to the local women's refuges via a contact. You don't get that weird snobbery about giving away an expensive thing if you can feel it's going to someone who really, really deserves a treat. Last year, for instance, we included all the things I knew I wouldn't use from the expensive cosmetic advent calendar.

TirednessIsComing · 24/10/2016 12:29

Gileswithachainsaw I feel your pain and want no presents too. I have no need because I buy want I need when I need it. I don't want to have to wait if I need it and I hate having to think for ideas.

I live that people want you to know they are thinking of you but I'd rather chat to them or see them.

I'm slowly weaning my parents onto the idea of spending time and doing things and took them both out for dinner and drinks last year instead. But a lot of my relatives love giving gifts which means then struggling to buy something they'd want for them. I've managed to stop doing it with all my close friends, we do a day and night together instead- usually late lunch movie and drinks. Lots of time for catch ups.

YuckYuckEwwww · 24/10/2016 12:33

Just because something comes from a gift drawer doesn't mean it's thoughtless. Sometimes stuff goes in there if I see something a particular person would like but it's nowhere near their birthday, other times I'll look in there first, but if there's nothing that stands out as nice for that individual I'll go and buy something else

TBH the gift drawer is mostly for kids gifts in our house, and they can be generic and don't have to be massively personal, especially if they're for school friends parties.

Temporaryname137 · 24/10/2016 12:34

I think it's v cheap to regift to a friend or relative. Unwanted gifts should go to charity shop/old folks' home etc. Occasionally in the bin!

starfishmummy · 24/10/2016 12:35

I have no problem with regiftin or giving to a charity but I just make sure it goes well away from the person who gave it me!!

Gileswithachainsaw · 24/10/2016 12:37

I don't think money or vouchers are rude at all. Surely you want your gift to be of use?

What's rude is to make it all about you and insisting on buying stuff people dont want nor need because of your own opinion of what they want.

RhiWrites · 24/10/2016 12:40

But a gift isn't a financial transaction. It's showing that you've thought of someone and selected or made a present as a token of your love and esteem. Ideally it will be something they like and would never have thought of for themselves.

Giving them £5 to "buy something they really want" reduces the experience to a purely commercial one. And I maintain its rude to tell your friends/relations that they couldn't possibly select you a present you'd like so you'd prefer the cash.

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/10/2016 12:47

I hardly ever get a present from sil/brother. Only if we see them Christmas Day. I'd rather she didn't bother. Generic cheap tat for well under a tenner and not even good enough to regift. Think thinsulate knitted gloves for dh and scratchy, cheap, unlined slipper socks for me. I used to give wonderful gifts and two years on the trot got nothing so I wisened up and gave nothing from then on unless we saw them Christmas Day. Still couldn't bring myself to give such generic rubbish. Gave brother a DVD last time we saw each other at Xmas, don't remember what I got her - a very expensive kimono style 100% silk dressing style gown a few years prior as she liked lounging in nightwear.

MrsHathaway · 24/10/2016 12:51

Cash is for children/teenagers or possibly where there's a huge financial imbalance.

Swapping tenners between adults is just baffling. Furthermore, since vouchers expire and cash doesn't, vouchers are even less meaningful.

Gileswithachainsaw · 24/10/2016 12:55

I just don't see how it's more rude to suggest a voucher than it is to repeatedly accept gifts you can't use.

Makes it all about the giver and not the person the gift was actually fir.

RB68 · 24/10/2016 12:57

I like to get suprises still, but like things I like.... I like vouchers as generally they are generic enough to get things I want or need which is find by me - so M&S, John Lewis are OK although don't often go there, book vouchers are good, starbucks or costa would be good too as DD is always pestering and its expensive! Even with vouchers you have to know your mark - my MIL it has to be M&S she uses them for her food shopping and is as pleased as punch with them. Chocolates and smellies she is still recycling from working in the OAPs home and she is 86...

sparechange · 24/10/2016 12:58

I don't really understand the logic of 'if it isn't good enough for you, it isn't good enough for anyone'. Surely if something isn't to your tastes, but is exactly the sort of thing a friend would like and use, there is nothing wrong with regifting?

And re not buying presents for people you don't know very well... That's well and good for families who live in each other's pockets, but I live in a different country from my SIL. Am I honestly not supposed to buy her a present at all because I don't know if she prefers floral vs musky perfumes, or whether she is short on or good for nice mugs?
And DH's family do secret santa for the adults, so there is a 1 in 10 chance I'll have to buy something for Uncle Bill who I've only met 4 times, 3 of those being funerals. I'm not going to take offence if it turns out he already has that book on fishing and wants to pass it on to a friend on boxing day

stopfuckingshoutingatme · 24/10/2016 13:04

OP, where do you stand on sustainability? just curious....

BarbaraofSeville · 24/10/2016 13:16

Sustainability is a really good point, with regard to a lot of gifts, without even thinking about whether you want or need an item.

Because the only acceptable response when receiving a gift is 'oh how lovely and thoughtful, thank you very much' no one in real life will ever really know the pathalogical hatred you might have for any type of Boots gift set so they will think you like it and continue to buy you one every Christmas.

How on earth do they get away with using all that excess packaging? I thought there were laws against it? A bog standard selection of toiletries (Lynx, Dove etc) sold at three times the retail value but then put on some fake 3 for 2 deal is not a nice present, whether or not it is encased in a crappy cardboard box.

It seems that a lot of time, money, effort and packaging could be saved by just buying a few extra toiletries in the weekly shop and dropping them in the food bank donation box on the way out of the shop.

And I could get to choose my own toiletries for once instead of feeling obliged to use up what I got for Christmas.

Snowgeese · 24/10/2016 13:20

I think we are going to see in times to come a cutback on all the present buying angst . We are waking up to the waste of energy and money spent for a moment of tearing the paper off on Christmas morning .
To be honest a lot of people can now get what they want when they want anyway . For those like myself with little income then the disparity between gifts is excruciating .
Have been talking with family about this because of these issues . I want to put a tenner most on a gift because it is nice to have a gift at Christmas it just is .
Met with horror . You can't get anything for a tenner . But you can . A pot of bulbs , a half bottle of Tia Maria to have with coffee , luxury handcream , an ordinance survey map for walkers ,a cheap basket of seeds for a gardener .
Regifting is fine as long as you carefully match your recipients .

Still got the Hmm face .

LunaLoveg00d · 24/10/2016 13:26

The charity shop I volunteer in will take NEW toiletries - we often get sets handed in unopened and that's fine. We don't resell anything which has been used, and that goes for makeup, perfume and other toiletries. We do not resell food or drink so you can't bring us your boxes of chocolate or bottles of wine.

BarbaraofSeville · 24/10/2016 13:27

Snowgeese You need to show your relatives MSEs no unnecessary presents pact

'It mis-prioritises our finances. Christmas gifts are often a ‘zero-sum’ game, where often people just give gifts of similar values to each other. It’s worth examining what this means in a dispassionate practical sense:

    Sharon gives a £20 necklace to Violet.
    Violet gives £20 earrings to Sharon.

If we examine the net result then, in fact….

    Sharon has spent £20 to get earrings.
    Violet has spent £20 to get a necklace.

Yet the problem here is Sharon’s loaded and Violet’s skint. Without the gift-giving obligation, would Violet have really chosen to spend her hard-earned £20 for a necklace?

Instead, perhaps she’d have bought food for her children, paid some bills, or put the money towards replacing worn out shoes.

In other words, Violet’s financial priorities have been skewed because of gift-swapping. She would’ve been better off if they had agreed not to give in the first place'  

It sounds like you are like Violet in this example. A tenner is more than fine - I would have a bottle of cava and a box of Lindt chocolates please - no one can say that's not a nice gift, can they?

But really, I don't want family or friends with little disposable income buying me things I can easily buy myself. I really like Border chocolate ginger biscuits - cost between £1 and £1.60 depending on whther or not on offer and I'd be more pleased to receive something like that than some over priced over packaged gift set.

By the way, if you're buying OS maps, they're just over a fiver at www.dash4it.co.uk, no need to spend a tenner on them Smile.

CanadianJohn · 24/10/2016 13:41

I have no problem with re-gifting stuff... I've been telling everyone for years I don't want gifts - I'm trying to simplify and de-clutter. I really don't want stuff, honestly.

I give my children and grandchildren, all adults, money for Christmas and birthdays. They might privately complain about the size, but they never refuse the gift, or return it.

Gileswithachainsaw · 24/10/2016 13:45

So if money is rude
Re gifting is rude
Throwing away is rude

Just what is acceptable? Are people supposed to move into garden sheds just to house all the stuff they don't want just to avoid Pissing people off the one time they go round and the 45 bottles of perfume aren't on display?

Swipe left for the next trending thread