Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send MIL a passive aggressive text

248 replies

Ruperta · 31/12/2014 09:47

Ok so bit of a back story and posted a few times previously. PILS are very involved in SIL family, essentially amazing GPs, provide childcare 2 days a week, often have them over night and take their son swimming every Saturday. They live 30 mins drive away which obviously is a reason for them being closer but there is a loooooonnnggg history of obvious favouritism to SIL family and children. SIL is lovely by the way and fair play I would gratefully take all help offered in the same way as she does.

In comparison we live further away (london) 2hrs on train, 4 hrs drive and we have a two children (1&3), the youngest the same age as SIL youngest. There has been lots of little episodes of things that have gradually grated me & my DH re:favouritism and lack of effort from MIL, many many many which are too petty to go into but last episode left a bit of a frosty atmosphere.

E.g they visited us twice last year, the second time we asked as a favour as we needed someone to look after children as I was a bridesmaid at the wedding. It was the first time me and DH had been out and DS2 was 10 months. They came down and basically used our house as a base, went out to meet old friends, arranged for family to come round on the day we were out at the wedding - I put my foot down and said that they agreed to look after children and they weren't to have friends round (they didn't ask us by the way, we found out the day before that 4 additional adults were coming round). Mil went sulky and didn't speak to me in my own house all weekend. So obviously things are quite frosty anyway. I was just annoyed as I thought they may want to spend a bit if time with GC.

Anyhoo so Xmas comes along, it was our 'turn' to spend Xmas with them (which I was slightly dreading) but when we asked them what their plans were they said 'we are going to SILs, what are you doing?' Absolutely no thought of spending time with us. Eventually a couple of weeks later SIL invited us but by then I arranged for my family to come round and there wouldn't 't have been any room at SILs for us anyway and we all seemed quite happy with plan.

Anyway (I hope your still with me) on Xmas day we facetime'd SIL (PILL had forgotten their ipad) and chatted to everyone but MIL didn't come to screen and say hello, benefit of the doubt she was probably busy I know. Then we tried face timing again over the next few days, they never rang us back. Eventually facetime'd again on Sunday but MIL had been out the night before and was unable to speak to us. So we haven't even spoken to her over Xmas.

I am so tempted to send her a passive aggressive text with pictures of the children over Xmas saying 'hope she had a lovely Xmas, we had a great time, it's a shame we weren't able to catch up properly over the Xmas period but thank you so much for the toys the children loved them. Hope you have a great new year'.

I just really want to highlight it to her and make it clear it's not really acceptable. They are such wonderful GPs to SILS children (they are having them overnight tonight) but she can't even be arsed to say merry Xmas to my kids. Relations are quite strained anyway, maybe I'll regret it but I'm really at the stage of thinking it is her loss if she can't be bothered to put the effort in.

FIL is lovely by the way but (as with the whole of the ILs family) he does exactly what she demands to get the easy life - I think that is why she doesn't get on so well with us as we don't do this and my DH (her son) apparently never has.

Sorry very long.

OP posts:
Boomtownsurprise · 31/12/2014 17:50

Based purely on your op you were as wrong as she was.

Stop building a fake reality of perfectionism and start building a real one

PhaedraIsMyName · 31/12/2014 18:06

I gave up reading opening post at the point OP put her foot down. They were doing her a favour which allowed her to go to the wedding. Why should they not kill 2 birds with one stone and catch up with friends at the same time.

ILovePud · 31/12/2014 18:08

Because you don't just invite other people to someone else's house without checking with the owners first.

HoggleHoggle · 31/12/2014 18:09

Agreed tiggy

Mintyy · 31/12/2014 18:11

Yes tiggy, you are absolutely right.

ILovePud · 31/12/2014 18:12

I'll third that Tiggy you are spot on.

ApocalypseThen · 31/12/2014 18:14

In nobody's world can you invite 4 adults to someone's house when they won't be there without even asking them first - that is just outrageously rude let alone if it is at the same time as you're supposed to be looking after two very young children who aren't familiar with grandparents and nervous of others.

Well, you are making a universal statement there when several people have said that they would think the opposite so I'm not sure what you're basing your definite rule on there.

Toughasoldboots · 31/12/2014 18:16

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PhaedraIsMyName · 31/12/2014 18:21

In nobody's world can you invite 4 adults to someone's house when they won't be there without even asking them first

If the persons doing the inviting had been doing me an enormous favour and the house wasn't trashed I couldn't have cared less.

slithytove · 31/12/2014 18:35

Another in resounding agreement with tiggy

tiggytape · 31/12/2014 18:43

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sonjadog · 31/12/2014 18:59

My guess is that the MiL doesn't like her DiL very much and that is why she goes out all the time when she is there and doesn't visit often. She feels comfortable and relaxed around the SiL and family and that is why she spends so much time there. A shame for the kids, but when kids are small and you don't like their mother, it's limited how much time you can spend with them happily. When they get older and can have their own relationship maybe they will be closer.

JumpRope · 31/12/2014 19:26

That sort of text really pisses me off. Because to me it doesn't seem aggressive at all. It makes me very uneasy to think that people maybe saying things which have a subtext. Just say what you mean say nothing.

clam · 31/12/2014 19:28

The OP wasn't particularly fussed about the permission bit - that came later when she was looking for evidence to boost her argument.

And tiggy said earlier that "everyone" she knew would think it awful for the ILs to have people over. I'm curious as to how she's found this out. Straw poll? Or made up fact?

Anyway, Happy New Year, all! Wine

Snappynewyear · 31/12/2014 19:31

You come across as a bit of a control freak OP and seem to not share the same parenting style as your SIL and MIL
Maybe I've not been a push over & maybe both me & my husband stood up and said no in the past when others would have taken a different route but I was just looking out for my kids

Would imply differences in approach to children and you are maybe over protective, over anxious and a bit of a helicopter mum?

I think you made your PILS feel uncomfortable, (not welcome to visit friends, or have family over to visit and maybe have a bit of fun with the DCs) NOT as others have suggested a bunch of strangers having a party and keeping the DCs awake!

Sadly you have to accept that your MIL and SIL are more accepting of one another and have a better relationship with her DCs because of it. And it's not OK to blame the MiL for the lack of a relationship with the DCs unless the OP share as equal blame for being so high handed.

Ruperta · 31/12/2014 19:43

Gosh this is still going!

I think MIL & SIL have a better relationship probably because they are mother & daughter and they live much closer to each other.

Maybe MIL doesn't like me, maybe I'm a cow. Maybe she doesn't like her son either. Still I think she could have found time to say happy Xmas. They brought my sons lovely presents and I just want to reiterate they are wonderful, amazing dream grandparents to SILs children which i think is why the comparison is so much starker.

We have tried to FaceTime them this evening to say happy new year but again no answer and they've not rung us back. We know they are at home with SIL kids, so they probably have their hands full.

Anyhoo new resolution - to rise above, to not compare and up enjoy my family. (& definitely no passive agressive texts) Smile Happy new year xxx

OP posts:
Mintyy · 31/12/2014 19:51

Ruperta - Happy New Year to you Wine.

I think it is good not to send the text.

I am sorry that you and yours feel second best to sil and her family, unfortunately that's the way it goes in a huge number of families. Horrible to be on the wrong end of it, all you can do is stop bashing your head against a brick wall and leave dh and his mum to arrange visits etc. Hopefully your children have more frequent contact with your parents.

diddl · 31/12/2014 19:56

It's a double whammy really isn't it?

MIL gets on better with her own daughter-no, really??

Coupled with you being further away.

However, you're not the only one in the marriage, so it could be said that mother/son aren't bothered about seeing each other that much!

ConfusedInBath · 31/12/2014 19:58

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheFourthLobster · 31/12/2014 20:00

I think it's a circle - they live near to your SIL and so they know their son in law better and those grandchildren better. As you are further away they don't get to know you as well and it makes it awkward when you are together. I live a few minutes away from my parents and hundreds of miles away from the rest of the family and the DCs are much closer to the local ones and are much more remote with the others when they do see them as the basic relationship isn't there.

minionmadness · 31/12/2014 20:00

You see Ruperta I'm still with you on this one. Regardless of what your MIL feels about you or your DH (her son) it still doesn't excuse her despicable actions towards your dc.

Truly awful feeling when your dc are treated less favourably by their own gp's but I think all you can do is to rise above it.

Happy new year...

HoggleHoggle · 31/12/2014 21:22

Happy new year ruperta. That sounds a good resolution and I have a similar one myself Smile

vanessalightyear · 31/12/2014 21:46

Op don't know if you are still reading but just had to say, you are sooooo NBU re the wedding etc. There is no way I would put a clingy/shy 10 month old in the position of having a houseful of strangers while mummy and daddy are suddenly gone for the first time. You would have been anxious enough leaving them without worrying about their reactions to that. I would have gone further actually and would have been happier if the GPs had spent the Friday with you and your kids as a family, as a sort of 'warm up', to then be able to smoothly take over childcare and routine while you went to the wedding. Totally rude of your MIL to think it was somehow ok to invite a load of strangers (to your DC) over to your house without even mentioning it.
I think you may as well give up with initiating contact, it sounds like they really aren't interested for whatever reason, and must be sad for you and your DH.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page