Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To send MIL a passive aggressive text

248 replies

Ruperta · 31/12/2014 09:47

Ok so bit of a back story and posted a few times previously. PILS are very involved in SIL family, essentially amazing GPs, provide childcare 2 days a week, often have them over night and take their son swimming every Saturday. They live 30 mins drive away which obviously is a reason for them being closer but there is a loooooonnnggg history of obvious favouritism to SIL family and children. SIL is lovely by the way and fair play I would gratefully take all help offered in the same way as she does.

In comparison we live further away (london) 2hrs on train, 4 hrs drive and we have a two children (1&3), the youngest the same age as SIL youngest. There has been lots of little episodes of things that have gradually grated me & my DH re:favouritism and lack of effort from MIL, many many many which are too petty to go into but last episode left a bit of a frosty atmosphere.

E.g they visited us twice last year, the second time we asked as a favour as we needed someone to look after children as I was a bridesmaid at the wedding. It was the first time me and DH had been out and DS2 was 10 months. They came down and basically used our house as a base, went out to meet old friends, arranged for family to come round on the day we were out at the wedding - I put my foot down and said that they agreed to look after children and they weren't to have friends round (they didn't ask us by the way, we found out the day before that 4 additional adults were coming round). Mil went sulky and didn't speak to me in my own house all weekend. So obviously things are quite frosty anyway. I was just annoyed as I thought they may want to spend a bit if time with GC.

Anyhoo so Xmas comes along, it was our 'turn' to spend Xmas with them (which I was slightly dreading) but when we asked them what their plans were they said 'we are going to SILs, what are you doing?' Absolutely no thought of spending time with us. Eventually a couple of weeks later SIL invited us but by then I arranged for my family to come round and there wouldn't 't have been any room at SILs for us anyway and we all seemed quite happy with plan.

Anyway (I hope your still with me) on Xmas day we facetime'd SIL (PILL had forgotten their ipad) and chatted to everyone but MIL didn't come to screen and say hello, benefit of the doubt she was probably busy I know. Then we tried face timing again over the next few days, they never rang us back. Eventually facetime'd again on Sunday but MIL had been out the night before and was unable to speak to us. So we haven't even spoken to her over Xmas.

I am so tempted to send her a passive aggressive text with pictures of the children over Xmas saying 'hope she had a lovely Xmas, we had a great time, it's a shame we weren't able to catch up properly over the Xmas period but thank you so much for the toys the children loved them. Hope you have a great new year'.

I just really want to highlight it to her and make it clear it's not really acceptable. They are such wonderful GPs to SILS children (they are having them overnight tonight) but she can't even be arsed to say merry Xmas to my kids. Relations are quite strained anyway, maybe I'll regret it but I'm really at the stage of thinking it is her loss if she can't be bothered to put the effort in.

FIL is lovely by the way but (as with the whole of the ILs family) he does exactly what she demands to get the easy life - I think that is why she doesn't get on so well with us as we don't do this and my DH (her son) apparently never has.

Sorry very long.

OP posts:
LadyLuck10 · 31/12/2014 10:05

I agree with euro too. You seem very hard work when they actually do visit, it's probably why they try to limit their time with you. Your SIL probably doesn't mind them inviting people over to her house and maybe less relaxed, so they probably would feel more comfortable there. I would too.

ihatethecold · 31/12/2014 10:05

Nothing wrong with face timing.
We do it with relatives at Xmas.

Ruperta · 31/12/2014 10:06

Yes you are right I will not text, writing the thread has been therapeutic in itself.

It really is her loss at the end of the day.

For those of you who think I was out of order during their last visit - would you really like for your babysitter to arrange for 4 other adults to come round whilst you are out and whilst they are meant to be looking after your children? (Without asking) This was their first visit to spend time with their GC in 6 months. Also I find it highly rude for someone to not speak to me in my own house.

We do try and visit them as often as possible, but it all just feels very one sided - they never even ring us. Their loss and I will rise above it (again)

OP posts:
gamerchick · 31/12/2014 10:06

Just back away completely. She obviously doesn't want the relationship with you what you want with her.

Let your husband do the keeping in touch, she obviously irritates you and maybe she can sense that.

TendonQueen · 31/12/2014 10:07

Agree with greeneggs - if I were looking after grandkids for a day when I didn't see them that often I'd want to focus on them. How would they get much chance toxic to their friends anyway? Sounds like they wanted to make sure they got something out of the arrangement rather than seeing it as family time. That said, I wouldn't send the text. Leave it to them to make a move or to your DP. The less said the better unless you actively want to stir things up even more.

TendonQueen · 31/12/2014 10:08

That should have been 'much chance TO TALK'.

Blu · 31/12/2014 10:08

You make a couple of references to 'in my own house' in your OP. Did you actually cause her to call her friends and tell them they couldn't come?
It sounds as if you are driven by jealously over the fact that they live closer and do provide more childcare. But you don't sound as if you like her, you say your DH has always had a more spiky relationship with her, you have continued that, what do you expect?

Pico2 · 31/12/2014 10:08

I don't think that text is particularly PA. At face value it seems like a fairly pleasant message. If you don't want to give the pleasant version of the text then don't send it.

Pagwatch · 31/12/2014 10:09

What are you doing?
You clearly don't like her but spend a ridiculous amount of time keeping track of all the ways in which you feel snubbed. Now you want to send a text to be fucking snide.

Just leave it. It's not a competition. Stop trying to score points and pretending it's because of your children. You don't like her.

I hate face timing. I just do. I wave and chat with my son but it feels weird and I don't like it. You sound positively gleeful that you've got another reason to have a go. Get a hobby.

MinnieM1 · 31/12/2014 10:10

I don't think that text is passive aggressive, it's actually very nice and she probably won't get it
I'd be more clear that I wasn't happy, I know you've been advised not to and probably won't bit I'm jut not one of these people who is nice to people who aren't nice to me or my kids just to "keep the peace" why should you?!
My text would read more like "yes mil my children had a lovely Christmas thanks for asking!"

LadyLuck10 · 31/12/2014 10:10

Your dislike for her really comes through. The laying down of rules at your house was very rude and seems like she needs to be on eggshells with you. Would you want to be around someone like that? Mil are not the ones always to blame.

ApocalypseThen · 31/12/2014 10:11

would you really like for your babysitter to arrange for 4 other adults to come round whilst you are out and whilst they are meant to be looking after your children? (Without asking)

If it was a teenager having a party I probably wouldn't like it. Other adults having tea and a chat wouldn't bother me in the least.

This was their first visit to spend time with their GC in 6 months.

Right, and?

Also I find it highly rude for someone to not speak to me in my own house.

Yeah, they probably didn't enjoy getting given out to for doing you a favour either, so it's 6 of one there.

CleanLinesSharpEdges · 31/12/2014 10:12

You sound like a nightmare DIL, I'd love to hear the MIL's side of this.

You obviously can't stand her so leave the upkeep of the relationship with his parents to your DH.

ChippingInLovesChristmasLights · 31/12/2014 10:13

I put my foot down and said that they agreed to look after children and they weren't to have friends around

Really?

How incredibly rude.

Blu · 31/12/2014 10:13

Actually if my Mum and Dad were staying at my house to look after kids I would want them to feel at home / treat it as their home. And catching up with a few old friends, who they may have wanted to show grandchildren off to, will not have taken up the whole weekend.

It would have been better to have discussed it (perhaps that's how you 'found out' ?) but once you made them cancel (if you did) I am not sure how you thought the relationship would proceed with sweetness and light.

SunnyBaudelaire · 31/12/2014 10:14

'they were not to have friends round' - really?

MinnieM1 · 31/12/2014 10:15

I can't believe people think the OP was rude about MIL's visitors!
It's rude to invite people to someone's house without the home owners knowledge or permission! Do people really do this?! That's without even taking into account that the people were meant to be seeing the kids they hadn't seen for half a year!!

53Dragon · 31/12/2014 10:15

Ruperta they live a 4-hour drive away and you objected to them inviting a few friends round for a chat & to admire the grandchildren when you were out... Really?! OMG woman you're a control freak - get a grip...

Nomama · 31/12/2014 10:16

On the face of it your MIL is probably wondering what the fuck she has ever done to deserve you as a DIL.

From the info you gave, I have nothing else to go on, you really don't like her, want to micromanage her time when she is 'within your sphere', compare poorly with other SIL - you really do sound resentful there.

Have a rethink... what do you really want from her? What do you really resent? And why?

You might be able to do a quick bit of CBT for yourself and manage to see her in a different light. If you could it would make your life easier...

Backtobedlam · 31/12/2014 10:16

You talk about a babysitter inviting 4 adults-she's the childs grandmother, helping you out as a favour, not a random babysitter. These friends live 4 hrs away so presumably gets to see them very rarely, she probably just thought it was a nice way of killing 2 birds with one stone. Staying in on your own with a 10 month old (even your grandchild) can be hard work, and a bit boring if your not a 'baby' person, so probably thought this wasn't a problem. My mil often has her friends to my house, I think it's nice as they are a bit older so it gives mil chance for a 5min cup of tea/rest while friends play with the children.

Pagwatch · 31/12/2014 10:17

MinnieM1 Wed 31-Dec-14 10:15:47
I can't believe people think the OP was rude about MIL's visitors!

Try.

53Dragon · 31/12/2014 10:18

It's their son's and dil's house and they wanted to catch up with some old friends whilst doing a favour for the op. Of course they should feel comfortable with that - it's not like they're teenagers and had a party whilst being paid for babysitting.

Blu · 31/12/2014 10:19

Oh, and I see it was family they asked round while you were at the wedding. Other members of DH's family! And you 'put your foot down'.

Your MIL. should have risen above all of that and made contact with her grandchildren over Christmas, yes, but perhaps any thawing in frostiness might be helped with an apology from you.

MinnieM1 · 31/12/2014 10:20

Pagwatch wow you're rude! And I have tried, and still think MIL was 100% in the wrong

Pagwatch · 31/12/2014 10:20

If my DH ever lectured my mother about who she invited here while babysitting for her grandchildren I would hand him his arse in a sling.

What appalling manners.