Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I know how you all love a wedding bar thread. BYO. AIBU?

160 replies

ViviPru · 02/08/2012 13:31

We're having our wedding on a working dairy farm where we've hired a barn and a field. We're bringing everything on site, marquee, toilets generator, the lot.

We're planning to provide a Pimm's/fizzy elderflower drinks reception (2-3 glasses ppn), then red and white wine (just under 1 bottle ppn) to be served with lunch followed by some fizz (2-3 glasses ppn) for the toasts.

We were planning to get an event bar service to come on-site to provide a pay bar for the guests. They've quoted £300 for the staff, supplies and equipment. they would be charging our guests standard bar prices. We decided £300 would be better spent on booze instead, for that we could buy 2 casks of local ales, and a cask of local cider. That works out at about 2-3 pints per person. We'd also buy a selection of large bottles of standard spirits, vodka, gin, rum etc. There would be plenty of mixers and soft drinks, and we'd get some wine on sale or return from Majestics. My BiL is making some homebrew and my bridesmen's nana is giving us this years' batch of elderberry wine. The quantities of these homebrew provisions is anyone's guess.

I don't expect this amount of alcohol to last all night, and my Dad suggested we should just let people know what will be provided and that they can also bring their own if they like. Before we'd even thought about what to do about drinks, When a few of our friends found out about the nature of our wedding, the fact it was a non-standard venue, several said "brilliant, won't have to hide my hip flask" or similar. Our caterers said many weddings they've done have had a similar scenario, and they tend to help organise the collection and service of brought drinks.

I know the idea of BYO to a wedding might be controversial grabby/rude insert MN terminology here and I'm not 100% sure about it. My Dad thinks people would far prefer to spend £10 on 12 bottles of their favourite lager from Tesco beforehand than on two drinks from a pay bar. I don't really think my friends and family would be sneery about it, but our wedding is all about our guests having the best possible time on the budget we have, so I'm trying to work out if this fits in with that philosophy.

I guess we could spend another £300 on more drinks, but that would mean second guessing what people will want to drink, and how much will be drunk. Not to mention spending £300 less on something else, and the majority of the budget is being spent on food and event hire - my dress was 50p from Sue Ryder not really but you know what I mean. We've attended many of our guests weddings before ours and every one has had a standard venue pay bar. Given that we'd originally intended (with no qualms whatsoever - I've read the threads) to provide a standard pay bar for our guests, is providing them with the alcohol options I've outlined reasonable?

:)
Just another thinly veiled excuse to bang on about me' nuptuals really

OP posts:
GreenGoldSilverAndBronzeShadow · 02/08/2012 13:45

I rather like that idea OP.

Never been to one that does it, but as long as people are aware before hand and you do provide some reasonable wine/bubbly for the meal and toast, I think it's great.

QuenelleOJersey2012 · 02/08/2012 13:45

I don't know how I've missed this information Vivi. I am looking forward to seeing your dress. Have you showed it off yet?

valiumredhead · 02/08/2012 13:47

I have strong feelings about pay bars but BYO is a great idea as long as you let everyone know in advance. Congratulations! :)

Trills · 02/08/2012 13:47

Are you going to phrase it as bring your own or bring some to share?

Everyone loves a good stingy drinker at a BBQ thread too :o

blackteaplease · 02/08/2012 13:47

You are providing a lot of alcohol already, most weddings I have been to it's more like 1 or 2 pimms, 1/2 bottle of wine at table and 1 glass of fizz fo rthe speeches then a pay bar. You have almost double that, then booze provided on top of that. It should be plenty for all except the hardcore. So I would put something along the lines of what porca suggested.

I went to a wedding with a free bar recently and wasted loads of drink because everytime I put down my drink for a second (loo stop, or dancing) the overzealous catering staff would clear it away before I got back to it!

squoosh · 02/08/2012 13:47

Sounds like a lovely and unpretentious knees up! My favourite sort of wedding.

Trills · 02/08/2012 13:48

Oh if the caterers are going to look after it then that's much better.

ViviPru · 02/08/2012 13:48

MsV I'm a little bit shudder at that! Grin

We're thinking of using my SiL's dinghy to put it all in...

I guess the reasonableness or lack thereof just comes down to how its communicated then...

OP posts:
nickelbarapasaurus · 02/08/2012 13:49

we ran out of soft drinks.
we had to go to Iceland to buy more lemonade.
we had 2 bottles of Pimm's left at the end!
You've got a lot more booze than we had, but then, we had a shop next door, and also made tea and coffee for people (in the churhc, you see)
but! we also had an evening reception in a club, so people bought drinks there at the bar.
you don't have that luxury, so...

I love Porca's wording - that's perfect.

(especially as people might assume that you won't have much soft drinks)

NarkedRaspberry · 02/08/2012 13:50

You're already doing a lot

'a Pimm's/fizzy elderflower drinks reception (2-3 glasses ppn), then red and white wine (just under 1 bottle ppn) to be served with lunch followed by some fizz (2-3 glasses ppn) for the toasts.'

It's totally up to you. You know your friends/family. Will this start rows because you have a cheapskate uncle who will bring value lager and then drink all the Becks? Where will the alcohol be stored and chilled? Will people bringing their own end up starting it at lunch so you end up with tables covered in cans during your meal and drunk/passed out people by the end of the speeches?

garlicnutter · 02/08/2012 13:51

YY, it sounds great Grin

There's a world of difference between making a personal contribution to the party and being ordered to pay £8 a go for drinks at some overpriced bar. People like feeling they've put something in to the general happiness, not so much feeling like cash cows.

Good idea to collect your offerings on arrival! How about a big table for presents and bottles?

DestinationUnknown · 02/08/2012 13:51

Only issue with BYO is where do people put it if they are keeping it for later and how do they keep it cool. No one wants to be drinking warm white wine or lager. But nor will people want to BYO, stick in a cooler only to see someone else helping themselves later. Why not do sale or return on plenty of wine and beers, keep some back so it doesn't look limitless and get wasted and tell people that there will be lots of booze but do bring a hip flask or some extra supplies if you wish.

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos · 02/08/2012 13:52

Sounds like a great idea to me, just remember that you will have to provide glasses and ice.

Proudnscary · 02/08/2012 13:54

No I wouldn't put that either tbh ViviPru

I just think it sounds a bit wrong on an invite, however you word it and however well intentioned.

Just me own opinion and the amount I'd drink we'd have to bring one of those six bottle carry boxes which would be a huge faff.

ViviPru · 02/08/2012 13:55

Oh 'bring some to share' is a good call trills I don't think people would get grabby or possessive or funny about what they brought, but it would be good to prepare them for a bit of a muck-in situ, and then if they were keen to ensure they got to enjoy the premium beverages they brought, (which they would be absolutely entitled to) they could always leave them in their car or whatever.

blacktea we once went to a Budweiser promo event with free beer all night - it was like - two sips... hmm this is getting warm... ditch it and get a fresh one....

Quenelle, here she is. Dead simple. And a bargain. My mum's knitting me a Kate Middleton shrug.

OP posts:
GrannyRat · 02/08/2012 13:55

I think your wedding sounds ACE! Just the kind of wedding I'd love to be invited to hint hint Grin

I think it would show that your thinking of your guests as, let's face it, paid bars at weddings are often extortionate and now more than ever many people are struggling financially.

I think the wording is great - good luck!

ViviPru · 02/08/2012 13:57

Where will the alcohol be stored and chilled? Will people bringing their own end up starting it at lunch so you end up with tables covered in cans during your meal and drunk/passed out people by the end of the speeches?

Worthy considerations. I think we'll have to think carefully about the logistics and organisation if we go down this route.

OP posts:
oldraver · 02/08/2012 14:00

It sounds brilliant. I would just tell people that if they bring their own in case you ran out that would be ok

Trills · 02/08/2012 14:01

It does sound great, I agree :o

Cokeaholic · 02/08/2012 14:01

Would the budget run to a large ice bucket/tub per table and people can keep their bottles in it so that it is handy and chilled.

Might be able to get some large cheap plastic tubs or something similar and add a bit of a rafia bow or stencil a pattern on them.

Overcooked · 02/08/2012 14:02

I'm not sure I'd want anyone at my wedding that was sneery about BYO. We provided a fair bit of booze and then pay bar but I have been to plenty BYO and I much prefer that to paybar £10 for two bottles of wine is more than enough.

Also I think it creates a much nicer, kind of informal, atmosphere.

Would love to come btw.

Can you give us a link to the venue - I am intrigued...

NarkedRaspberry · 02/08/2012 14:02

It sounds great BTW.

Passmethecrisps · 02/08/2012 14:02

As it is a farm ask the farmer if there are any of those large blue plastic barrels that farms have lying about. Like an oil drum type thing.

Cut the top of these and fill them with ice and water. Any drinks needing cooled can go straight in there.

If your guests are a smallish number of decent people noone will start comparing labels and tutting that someone brought ASDA table wine when they brought Moët.

Asking your bridal party to collect these bottles and place them where necessary will get them out of your guest's hands as well.

Could it be worried like a donation to the bar? As in "we will be supplying x, y and z but should you wish to contribute to a shared bar etc etc". This could be a wedding present if that makes sense.

It's a lovely sounding informal do. If people are offended by BYOB on the invite they probably don't get the sort of tone you are going for.

PicklesThePottyMouthedParrot · 02/08/2012 14:03

I think there is nothing wrong it at all. Id rather BYO than pay a pay bar. I would also be a bit worried about the running dry. Will there be one sober person to do a booze run if so?

Im pg, Ill come and be a booze run person!

sparkle12mar08 · 02/08/2012 14:04

I think it sounds great and you're already providing tonnes imo (all the with meal drinks and the extra £300 worth) but there are a few things you might want to think about -

Is it bring to share or bring & drink your own? People bringing a bottle or two of their favourite wine and their favourite spirit won't want to share.
How are you going to keep stuff cool? This could be a big issue, and will you have ice available for mixer drinks?
Have you enough non-alcoholic stuff? I would get tonnes of OJ, coke and lemonade as well. These are things people always forget Smile

I also like Porca's wording ("we're providing lots with meal and large amount for evening, however not limitless so very welcome to bring your own to drink or share")

Swipe left for the next trending thread