Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
WolfingtonBear · 04/10/2025 14:04

cardibach · 04/10/2025 13:51

Lots of people have already suggested links.
He might have been at university in a different town if he hadn’t gone t9 jail in Dubai
He might have mental health issues as a result of his experiences which lead him to make worse decisions than he other wise would have
His life was derailed and he might be angry which might have led him down a wrong path
Thats just with a couple of minutes of thought and a reading of the thread.

He wasn’t driving, so no, he bears no responsibility.

Might, might, might, might. Suggested links, suggestions, perhaps, could have, maybe.

So all completely surmised from the exact same info that everyone else has.

The mother bears no responsibility for his death, it emotive fiction to suggest that were it not for her Marcus wouldn’t have been in that car doing what he was doing. We’ve all overreacted, we’ve all done things we regret. Is it sensible to suggest that even a year or two later we should be blamed and hated for them because of a potential negative outcome for another person involved that had absolutely nothing to do with the original issue. Pure emotive foolishness - reacting to romanticised, preferred versions of events, but this is what seems to be preferred now. Facts and grubby reality is just so dreary isn’t it?

GeneralPeter · 04/10/2025 14:06

TwistyTales · 04/10/2025 13:43

The callousness of this takes my breath away. Two kids being chased by police for 60 seconds is not on a par with the Manchester terrorists' crimes.

MN has been an absolute seething cauldron of hate this week.

Well exactly. Was it two kids being chased for 60 seconds by police? That's the gloss you put on it, becuase you recognise that circumstances matter.

The poster I replied to had jumped on an earlier one for saying she reserved judgment. Reserving judgment when we don't know the facts is the sensible thing to do. I'm not going to drop my belief that culpability matters to how tragic someone's death is, so I'd better not rush to judgment about what happened here. You think that's wrong?

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2025 14:06

flyingsquirrelsagogo · 04/10/2025 13:16

I this country the police would not investigate a sexual relationship between an almost-16yo and a 16yo that is consensual unless there were other factors such as abuse, capacity etc. Surely you know this?

But as you well know, this country is NOT Dubai. Which is a country I would never voluntarily step foot in because of their many other draconian laws. But that’s not the point. They broke the law of the land. Sadly, he found out that Dubai isn’t quite the utopia many visitors would believe.
i think the law there is wrong, I don’t believe he should have been jailed. I also don’t believe for one second that the mother of the girl involved should be castigated and seemingly held responsible for his death!

OneBadKitty · 04/10/2025 14:07

Don't know why so many here are painting him as an innocent victim. He broke the law in Dubai, for which he claimed ignorance of but that's not likely, the strict laws about sex and alcohol are well publicised, and he was accompanying a friend who has broken the law here too. He had no driving licence, no insurance, was driving dangerously and failed to stop for the police. It's not likely he was just an innocent passenger and not privy to his friend's illegal driving. He sounds reckless at best.

He didn't deserve to die and it's sad for his family. It is however very lucky that no innocent members of the public were killed in the smash because we'd be looking at a whole different ball game then.

The driver deserves no sympathy whatsoever!

soupyspoon · 04/10/2025 14:08

flyingsquirrelsagogo · 04/10/2025 13:16

I this country the police would not investigate a sexual relationship between an almost-16yo and a 16yo that is consensual unless there were other factors such as abuse, capacity etc. Surely you know this?

They quite rightly wouldnt

But Ive lost count of the number of posters on this site over many many years who are obsessive about a girl of 15 (because its always that way round here) NOT being able to consent, its ILLEGAL, its NOT CONSENSUAL.

Over and over again, citing red flags, grooming, exploitation, the list is endless about how a boy is nearly always some perpetrator, because the girl is 15 and therefore technically underage.

Perhaps the mum is one of those posters.

Soontobe60 · 04/10/2025 14:08

flyingsquirrelsagogo · 04/10/2025 13:52

This.
I hope the mother lives with the guilt for the rest of her life.
What about her poor daughter too? Not only will she feel guilt for feeling she was partly responsible for him going to prison, likely her relationship with her mum wit is have been damaged beyond repair, and now Marcus has been killed.
So many lives changed forever.

Your faux rage is pretty pathetic. What “guilt” should she be expected to live with? Nothing she did caused the man to die.

Nameychangington · 04/10/2025 14:11

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 13:10

Anybody in a police pursuit in my experience has got something to hide.
I don’t care what colour he is and you can believe that or not.

The mother wanted her daughter away from him.
The real truth as to why will never be revealed now we’ll all be hearing about how he was studying hard to be an engineer Doctor rocket scientist and is a great loss to the world.

I posted up thread that I was stopped by the police 7 times in 18 months as a teenager, while doing nothing wrong. One of those times I didn't initially stop as I assumed the police car behind me with blue lights on just wanted to get past me. What with me just pootling along taking a friend home and not speeding or drink driving or doing anything illegal at all.

It was only when the police officer flashed me and gestured at me that I realised he was pulling me over and I stopped. So technically I was in a police pursuit for a short amount of time, as these boys were. I had nothing to hide, and I'd done nothing wrong. Anyone who thinks the police actually police neutrally lives a very innocent life. Plenty of people have been stopped by police who had nothing to hide - and how many of them had something about them they couldn't hide, i.e. their skin colour? More than a few.

And mothers who wants boys away from their daughter is no justification for what that mother did to this boy's life, whether he'd have ended up a rocket scientist or a bin man.

Meadowfinch · 04/10/2025 14:11

Soonenough · 04/10/2025 09:55

Foolish young men will be risk takers. I feel horrible for his family.

This. So sad for his family.

Wilfulignoranceabounds · 04/10/2025 14:11

OneBadKitty · 04/10/2025 14:07

Don't know why so many here are painting him as an innocent victim. He broke the law in Dubai, for which he claimed ignorance of but that's not likely, the strict laws about sex and alcohol are well publicised, and he was accompanying a friend who has broken the law here too. He had no driving licence, no insurance, was driving dangerously and failed to stop for the police. It's not likely he was just an innocent passenger and not privy to his friend's illegal driving. He sounds reckless at best.

He didn't deserve to die and it's sad for his family. It is however very lucky that no innocent members of the public were killed in the smash because we'd be looking at a whole different ball game then.

The driver deserves no sympathy whatsoever!

Yes teenagers, and adults alike, are renowned for making sure they have brought themselves up to speed with the laws of whatever land they are off to for a quick holiday.

PropertyD · 04/10/2025 14:12

Chiseltip · 04/10/2025 13:55

Yeah, that's a very naive attitude.

The reason the police have to get involved in pursuits is that we/you would blame them if the people in the car went on to commit serious offences and the police didn't stop them.

Not stopping for police means only one thing. That you have something to hide.

Your last sentence is just astonishing. So criminals are not to be held accountable because they are criminals, we should lay the blame at the police instead?

The "easiest" one as you put it, would be to do nothing, it would be very easy for the police to just let them drive off. If they went on to break into your parents home, attack them, perhaps even murder them to steal their car, would you accept the police saying "well, someone might have got hurt if we tried to stop them?"

Agree with this.

The driver has been arrested for no insurance, no license etc. shame on them.

Clearly the police cannot let them get away. If they ran over your relative would the PP be so keen for the police not to chase. Let’s just let them do what they like?

My DS was working in retail this summer. The shop lifting is rife. He saw some some scrout stealing wine. He reported it to his manager. The man just walked out and gave my son a little wave once he was out of the store and then the usual two finger gesture.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:15

Chiseltip · 04/10/2025 13:55

Yeah, that's a very naive attitude.

The reason the police have to get involved in pursuits is that we/you would blame them if the people in the car went on to commit serious offences and the police didn't stop them.

Not stopping for police means only one thing. That you have something to hide.

Your last sentence is just astonishing. So criminals are not to be held accountable because they are criminals, we should lay the blame at the police instead?

The "easiest" one as you put it, would be to do nothing, it would be very easy for the police to just let them drive off. If they went on to break into your parents home, attack them, perhaps even murder them to steal their car, would you accept the police saying "well, someone might have got hurt if we tried to stop them?"

You believe that?

People of colour have to actively teach their children the police can't always be trusted. You've only got to watch that MET documentary to see that.

Nice to be able to live in a little white safety bubble enclave and not worry that your children might be not just at risk on the streets but also from the law enforcement.

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 14:15

Nameychangington · 04/10/2025 14:11

I posted up thread that I was stopped by the police 7 times in 18 months as a teenager, while doing nothing wrong. One of those times I didn't initially stop as I assumed the police car behind me with blue lights on just wanted to get past me. What with me just pootling along taking a friend home and not speeding or drink driving or doing anything illegal at all.

It was only when the police officer flashed me and gestured at me that I realised he was pulling me over and I stopped. So technically I was in a police pursuit for a short amount of time, as these boys were. I had nothing to hide, and I'd done nothing wrong. Anyone who thinks the police actually police neutrally lives a very innocent life. Plenty of people have been stopped by police who had nothing to hide - and how many of them had something about them they couldn't hide, i.e. their skin colour? More than a few.

And mothers who wants boys away from their daughter is no justification for what that mother did to this boy's life, whether he'd have ended up a rocket scientist or a bin man.

Were you driving without no insurance which would’ve flagged up on the MIB ?
Were you driving like a lunatic?
If not, there’s no comparison here.
If you were, I hope they’ve threw the book at you.
From the day I started driving lessons I was reminded by family that the car is as dangerous as a loaded gun in the wrong hands
As we saw earlier in the week

GeneralPeter · 04/10/2025 14:16

cardibach · 04/10/2025 13:51

Lots of people have already suggested links.
He might have been at university in a different town if he hadn’t gone t9 jail in Dubai
He might have mental health issues as a result of his experiences which lead him to make worse decisions than he other wise would have
His life was derailed and he might be angry which might have led him down a wrong path
Thats just with a couple of minutes of thought and a reading of the thread.

He wasn’t driving, so no, he bears no responsibility.

He wasn’t driving, so no, he bears no responsibility.

I don't think this is sufficient.

If my friend pulls out a gun and shoots me, totally out of character and without warning, I clearly bear no responsibilty at all for my own death.

If I've been playing drunken russian roulette with him for months in the local pub, mucking around and risking my, his and others' lives, and he pulls the trigger one day and it kills me, I clearly have a lot of responsibility for my own death.

I don't claim any knowledge about which of these two cases this death is closest to, but the idea that it couldn't have been either one is untenable.

Hysterectomynext · 04/10/2025 14:17

DancingNotDrowning · 04/10/2025 10:44

I suspect a young man who has been held in a high security prison in the UAE has more cause than most to be afraid of the police.

So true. This is a really good point

)disgraceful and shameful to read the racist posts on here)

WrongFredSaid · 04/10/2025 14:17

Horserider5678 · 04/10/2025 14:00

I feel for his parents! However, this was totally unrelated to his sentence. If you read the driver was charged with multiple offences so no doubt if he hadn’t died he’d be being charged with offences too!

On what factual basis do you conclude that ‘no doubt’ he would have been similarly charged?

Those darned biases, they find their way into soooo many of the posts on here. Shameful yes shameless.

nomas · 04/10/2025 14:17

cardibach · 04/10/2025 13:51

Lots of people have already suggested links.
He might have been at university in a different town if he hadn’t gone t9 jail in Dubai
He might have mental health issues as a result of his experiences which lead him to make worse decisions than he other wise would have
His life was derailed and he might be angry which might have led him down a wrong path
Thats just with a couple of minutes of thought and a reading of the thread.

He wasn’t driving, so no, he bears no responsibility.

The problem is we don’t know the full facts of why the girl’s mum reported him.

It’s possible it was an over-protective helicopter parent unable to deal with her child having sex, and even perhaps a race element to it people here say she was Sikh, but I can’t see a news report which says the girl’s race / religion).

It’s possible that the mother was aware of other behaviour that made her take the drastic step of reporting him to the police.

The problem is we only had Marcus’s side of the story, not the girl’s or the girl’s mum.

So from the mum’s perspective, she might be thinking if she hadn’t taken that drastic step, her daughter could have also been a passenger in that car and so she saved her daughter.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:19

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 14:15

Were you driving without no insurance which would’ve flagged up on the MIB ?
Were you driving like a lunatic?
If not, there’s no comparison here.
If you were, I hope they’ve threw the book at you.
From the day I started driving lessons I was reminded by family that the car is as dangerous as a loaded gun in the wrong hands
As we saw earlier in the week

Edited

It's called driving while black.

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 14:21

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:19

It's called driving while black.

Oh, I see so It’s nothing to do with that computer that the police keep on their dashboard. That’s able to tell them whether or not a car is insured or not 🙄
Which it wasn’t 🙄🙄

Nameychangington · 04/10/2025 14:21

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 14:15

Were you driving without no insurance which would’ve flagged up on the MIB ?
Were you driving like a lunatic?
If not, there’s no comparison here.
If you were, I hope they’ve threw the book at you.
From the day I started driving lessons I was reminded by family that the car is as dangerous as a loaded gun in the wrong hands
As we saw earlier in the week

Edited

I was a teenager in the days before ANPR! I owned the car, had insurance, tax, MOT, wasn't speeding, had my lights on, was driving safely. Wonder what it was about me that made the officer decide to stop me?

My post was in answer to PP saying that anyone involved on a police pursuit has something to hide. Which is not true. Those who think the police only go after wrong 'uns is naive.

Meadowfinch · 04/10/2025 14:21

"He wasn't driving so bears no responsibility"

Really!! I have a ds the same age. He has more sense than to be racing around the streets in an uninsured BMW in the early hours, or spending time with the sort of lad who doesn't stop when requested to by the police.

Choice of friends......!

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:21

nomas · 04/10/2025 14:17

The problem is we don’t know the full facts of why the girl’s mum reported him.

It’s possible it was an over-protective helicopter parent unable to deal with her child having sex, and even perhaps a race element to it people here say she was Sikh, but I can’t see a news report which says the girl’s race / religion).

It’s possible that the mother was aware of other behaviour that made her take the drastic step of reporting him to the police.

The problem is we only had Marcus’s side of the story, not the girl’s or the girl’s mum.

So from the mum’s perspective, she might be thinking if she hadn’t taken that drastic step, her daughter could have also been a passenger in that car and so she saved her daughter.

At the time it was in the media the girl and her mum where named and there were photographs floating around online.

Her name will be known. So much for her mum protecting her for marriage. Everyone who knows the daughter/the family will know now. In her community, she'll be unmarriageable.

cardibach · 04/10/2025 14:22

Horserider5678 · 04/10/2025 14:00

I feel for his parents! However, this was totally unrelated to his sentence. If you read the driver was charged with multiple offences so no doubt if he hadn’t died he’d be being charged with offences too!

Would he? For being in the same car? There’s no reason to think he was committing any offences.

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:22

Meadowfinch · 04/10/2025 14:21

"He wasn't driving so bears no responsibility"

Really!! I have a ds the same age. He has more sense than to be racing around the streets in an uninsured BMW in the early hours, or spending time with the sort of lad who doesn't stop when requested to by the police.

Choice of friends......!

Has your son just done a stint in a middle eastern jail?

HRchatter · 04/10/2025 14:22

Nameychangington · 04/10/2025 14:21

I was a teenager in the days before ANPR! I owned the car, had insurance, tax, MOT, wasn't speeding, had my lights on, was driving safely. Wonder what it was about me that made the officer decide to stop me?

My post was in answer to PP saying that anyone involved on a police pursuit has something to hide. Which is not true. Those who think the police only go after wrong 'uns is naive.

But actually, in the olden days, they had to have more cause to stop you so you must’ve been doing something.
Faulty brake light ? Speeding ? Driving without due course and attention ?
It’s far easier for them to stop you in 2025

nomas · 04/10/2025 14:24

Slightyamusedandsilly · 04/10/2025 14:21

At the time it was in the media the girl and her mum where named and there were photographs floating around online.

Her name will be known. So much for her mum protecting her for marriage. Everyone who knows the daughter/the family will know now. In her community, she'll be unmarriageable.

This in itself is racist.

Do you even know any Sikh people in real life? Intermarriage is common. You’re dismissing an entire group of people as having backwards views.