Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A quick/instant death

198 replies

Kris02 · 25/05/2022 11:03

Morbid topic I know, but have you ever witnessed (or been told about) an instant, painless death? Most deaths seem to be preceded by lots of suffering and struggling - the death rattle, etc. I watched my grandmother die of a stroke, for example, which terrified me, as it took her 24 hours or more to die. The same was true of the cancer and heart deaths I’ve witnessed.

But I have been told by others that the’ve witnessed very quick deaths, almost instant in fact. My neighbour’s dad, for example, was sat in his chair watching the football. My neighbour went into the kitchen to get them both a beer and when he came back his dad was dead - just slumped there with a slight smile on his face, gone. My neighbour often says what a beautiful death it was and how grateful he is that he never saw his dad suffer.

My friend (a police officer) told me she’s often broken into a house or flat to find an elderly person dead in front of the TV. Once, she found an elderly woman sat at her breakfast table, with a plate of toast in front of her, dead, and yet kind of sitting there as if nothing had happened. That would do for me!

Personally, the thought of a lingering death terrifies me, and I find these stories weirdly comforting. I hope to be around for some time yet, but when I go, I’d really like to be slightly drunk on red wine, sat watching the TV. Do people really die like that? I don’t need to say goodbye to anyone. My loved ones know how much I love them. I tell them every day.

OP posts:
MolkosTeenageAngst · 12/06/2022 13:37

An instant death is terrifying to me. I hate the idea that one minute I could be fine and the next gone - given the option of an instant, painless death or one where I got the terminal diagnosis beforehand but was going to have a drawn out painful death I would absolutely go for the drawn out one. I would rather know it was going to happen than have death come from nowhere and it terrifies me that things like brain haemorrhages, heart attacks, aneurysms etc can happen instantly with no hope of rescue. I think they are my biggest fear.

Stegosaurussock · 12/06/2022 13:41

Certain recreational drugs.
The coroner at DH’s inquest concluded it would have been quick and pain free.

He had always insisted it wasn’t dangerous to take this drug in the way that he did. He was wrong.

BeforeSheKnewIt · 12/06/2022 13:51

My dad (72). He'd been away with DM and aunt for a long weekend. As he was dropping DA home she asked if parents would like to go in for a drink. As DF stepped out of the car (he wanted a glass of water) he dropped to the ground - he'd had a massive (unexpected) heart attack and was dead before he hit the floor. It was horrendous for DM to witness but a pretty good way to go, as GP confirmed, it was instantaneous.
I sometimes wonder, on the drive home, did DF suspect something was wrong but tried to get DM & DA home safely first before succumbing?

1dayatatime · 12/06/2022 13:56

A very long time ago one of my relatives was being rowed across a river by his grandsons. Apparently they weren't going fast enough and he was in a hurry. After criticising them he then took over the rowing.

Apparently he built up quite a speed (putting his grandsons to shame) before dying of a sudden heart attack.

The grandsons felt guilty but his widow remarked that he wouldn't have wanted it any other way - in a boat and still having the strength show his grandsons how it's done.

lollipoplips · 12/06/2022 14:05

I'm a hairdresser and one of my Saturday morning regulars died under the dryer having her set done.
She came in, absolutely fine looking forward to her weekly bingo trip that afternoon, washed and set her hair put her under the hood for 20 minutes and when I went back, she had died.

Another regular client drove to her appointment, parked in the car park and just died in the car before she had chance to get out.

Both were in their 80s, not particularly frail, both very independent and always out and about.

misscockerspaniel · 12/06/2022 14:06

This happened when smoking in offices was still allowed: Someone died sitting at his desk in the open plan office where my father worked. They only noticed he had died because he hadn't finished his cigarette!

Oldraver · 12/06/2022 14:27

My Grandad died of an aneurysm and the doctors said he would of been dead before he hit the floor

There were other not nice issues that upset my Dad though so it's not always what it seems

TommyShelby · 12/06/2022 14:34

My dads grandad had an enormous heart attack halfway up the stairs. Dad was told he would have been dead before he’d hit the bottom.

my FIL died, again of a colossal heart attack just at the final whistle of the FA cup final. My mil had just gone out the kitchen to top up her wine, came back and he was gone. We all said he’d have been pleased that he’d managed to watch the whole game before he went as he loved all sport.

thaegumathteth · 12/06/2022 14:43

trigger child loss

I don't find the idea of it comforting at all but I can understand why people would.
I think I've been really affected by my best friend dying when she was 7. She had a sore head, her mum stood up to get Calpol and she had died of an aneurysm. I'm glad she didn't know but it has horrified me ever since

ArtVandalay · 12/06/2022 14:46

My mum died in her sleep. She went to bed one night as normal and my dad realised she was dead beside him in the small hours. She hadn't made a sound.

What a way to go.

Summerwhereareyou · 12/06/2022 14:48

Op I love mumsent;
I was thinking this today whilst feeling sorry for myself, clutch ing my head in pain, suffering from COVID.
I was at a close family members side whilst they slowly died from heart failure.
It was awful.

I was thinking of when it's my time can I kill myself with paracetamol? Is that painless?
But what if I get dementia and can't do myself in ...

Just go on in oblivion... breaking the heart of my husband and children, putting a strain on or draining allnrhe asset's built up for my children?

Why do we do this as a society?

How can anyone sit by someone and watch them die sndnssy this is sanctity of life?

I think it's cruel and sadistically

Summerwhereareyou · 12/06/2022 14:50

Tommy many a time I thought my dad might go during a footy match!

SkiingIsHeaven · 12/06/2022 14:52

Daenerys77 · 25/05/2022 12:58

I believe it is quite common to have a heart attack on the lavatory after a bowel movement. It's not the way I would choose to be found, but I suppose it would be quick and not too painful.

This happened to my husband's colleague. DH had to pull his pants up for him.

intwrferingma · 12/06/2022 15:14

ninnynonny · 25/05/2022 12:29

Thing is , how do we know for certain, there was no pain? It could have been a tremendous agonising pain for a second. My Mum had a stroke and a brain haemorrhage whilst she was on her own and we didn't find her until the next morning - she was still alive and didn't actually die for a few months, but it had pretty much wiped her memory and cognitive function and she remembered nothing about it. It just tears me up that she must have been in excruciating pain for a short while before collapsing

Exactly what happened to my mum.
I get flashbacks a year on. It was terrible. And terrifies me. She spent the final 6 months of her life incapacitated and in terror. I often wonder what would have happened if I had got to her just after the stroke happened rather than finding her 3 hours later

TommyShelby · 12/06/2022 15:16

@Summerwhereareyou they don’t know what’s good for them some times do they 😂

DumpedByText · 12/06/2022 15:21

My dad found his next door neighbour sat on the loo dead. He used to get her a paper every day and when she'd not called for it, he went round. She didn't answer so he let himself in and she was on the loo. I imagine that was very quick. 999 wanted him to do CPR but he told them she was blue and wasn't coming back.

Sleepingsatellite1 · 12/06/2022 15:28

TigerLilyTail · 25/05/2022 12:21

Well, I didn’t think so. 🤷‍♀️

I thought it would be about a pet or something. I didn’t expect this.

Well really

Sleepingsatellite1 · 12/06/2022 15:35

knittingaddict · 25/05/2022 13:21

My mum died 2 weeks ago, but I felt a strong pull to read this thread, not realising how it would be phrased. Really wish I hadn't now. Trigger warning please.

I’m really sorry for your loss but perhaps now isn’t the time to click on threads that actually say they are about death 💐

Toddlerteaplease · 12/06/2022 15:36

My uncle was in the bathroom one morning and died of a sudden heart attack. My auntie only trailed when his phone was ringing and not answered. Might have been nice for him, but utterly traumatic for my auntie.

daisychain01 · 12/06/2022 15:40

easyday · 25/05/2022 11:35

I'm, yes, but it's when too.
My husband died suddenly of a heart attack which (so the coroner told me) even if I had been there I couldn't have helped. But he was 51, our kids were small, and it was tragic.
My aunt by died at 90 in her sleep. It was expected as she had been deteriorating, but she was in her home and at peace with it. Her affairs were in order, she saw her children, she was in a good place with everyone. That's the way to go.

Sorry about your husband @easyday my DH1 died the same way, and I was at work when it happened. Like you, I was also told that even if I'd been there I wouldn't have been able to do anything quickly enough to save him, which has always been a great source of comfort, rather than agonising over "I wish I'd been there, maybe I could have saved him". No, it was very quick and (I would like to think) painless.

They will always be young Flowers

Daftasabroom · 12/06/2022 15:45

@AlternativePerspective something different but similar effect happened to me. I used to play/compete in various water sports. I went for a free session one day with brother and mates but had forgotten some of my own equipment. I borrowed some of my youngest brothers kit which I had totally grown out of.

I ended up trapped under water. At first I was totally calm, I knew all the drills, but when it became clear that I was trapped by my very poor choice of kit I went into a blind panic to free myself. Eventually, as my blood oxygen levels dropped, I accepted I was going to die. More than anything I remember being really annoyed that I was going to miss a big event the next day. I eventually passed out and presumably relaxed enough to become free and surface, my brother says he saw me come up, out of it but take a reflex breath and he pulled me out.

I've never been afraid of death since. I also felt no pain, I think our bodies produce so many chemicals to protect us when we need it most.

daisychain01 · 12/06/2022 15:48

@Summerwhereareyou I was thinking of when it's my time can I kill myself with paracetamol? Is that painless?

No, no, no, no and no!

Dont even think of it, that would be a really unwise move, and yes it would be an awful way to die.

It's best, if possible, not to dwell on your own ending. Let's face it, it will happen to all of us, some how, some day, but there is no point planning to that extent. Plan your financial affairs, keep your Will up to date, tidy your house and declutter, do all the sensible, practical things that ensure you have left everything in good order for your loved ones.

Meanwhile get on with living life in the fullest way you are able to Flowers

Daftasabroom · 12/06/2022 15:53

I think the point of my post was that the final few moments before death are not necessarily that distressing. But I would really not like that minute of conscious panic to have lasted a moment longer.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 12/06/2022 15:54

@supercalafragalistico no timing and the speed of travel is everything.

I'm a train driver and it's not always quick or clean unfortunately.

Titsywoo · 12/06/2022 16:01

My grandad got up to go to the toilet and as he started walking back to bed just fell down dead. He was 103 and it was a pretty good way to go. Unfortunately for some ridiculous reason he did not have an DNR and the ambulance crew tried to revive him but he was already very much gone so I pray he did not feel any of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread