@WheelieBinPrincess
Vegetables included 100%!
No paying £4.50 for a plate of steamed broccoli to accompany your main.
This is one of the things that drives me up the wall. About 20 years ago I ordered a £20+ steak in what was then called the Russell Hotel, and they brought out... a steak. Nothing else. They hadn't even suggested ordering sides.
My fantasy restaurant would be clear about the customers it wanted, and very clear about the customers it didn't want. It would offer a simple menu, have no delusions of grandeur at all, and aim to leave people feeling full and that they had a bargain.
Jug of water, bread and olives go straight on the table as soon as you arrive. There would be a "cover charge" of about £2 per person for this if you don't go for the set menu.
Starter would be soup, which would always be made up from the left over vegetables and stuff from the previous day.
Small menu of two or three dishes of the day, and up to half a dozen à la carte choices. The pricing, and reputation, would point you very much towards a dish of the day, although the à la carte options would only be big sellers. I would not want to be defrosting anything in the microwave just to be able to say it was on the menu for the one person who ordered it every six months.
One of the dishes of the day would be something cooked in bulk that day and ready to serve fairly quickly, so a pork and bean stew with rice or that sort of thing. You would be able to order a portion or a half portion, with a meaningful price differential.
Others would be fresh and quality but relatively simple to prepare and things with no leeway for customers to alter what the chef does: grilled pork or chicken or fish, for example. Grilled meat would come with fries and salad, fish with boiled potatoes and veg. If you want a choice of six different sides with every menu option, tough. If you want steak rare, or well done - tough because we won't serve anything where the customer can claim they didn't get what they asked for.
At least two of the à la carte options would come in half portions. There would be no children's menu (children very welcome though), no vegetarian/vegan option (draw your own conclusion on that), and lots of warnings that nuts are prepared in the kitchen for use in desserts although the main courses will be nut free.
There would be a wine list with outrageous normal markups for anyone who thought they might impress someone by choosing from it, but this restaurant would stake its reputation on a decent house red and white bought in bulk and served in carafes with minimal mark up. If Aldi and Lidl can sell perfectly drinkable wine for £5 a bottle, it cannot be beyond the wit of man to source a wine in 20l bag-in-boxes which I'd sell for £3 for a 250ml carafe.
Desserts would be either branded frozen things such as ice cream bought in and marked up enormously, fruit, or made-on-premises cake, tart, mousse etc in a display cabinet so you could go up and choose it.
I'd offer a Mon-Sat lunch time set menu of bread/olives, dish of the day, and dessert (branded stuff excluded) plus 250ml wine or soft drink or water, and espresso, priced to pack the place out every day with at least two sittings. Ideally about £12 a head.
Evenings and Sunday lunch wouldn't offer the set menu, but would still be priced to sell.
And we'd offer doggy bags if the waiter spots a lot left on a plate.