Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Dh has asked me to find a job. I don’t want to

888 replies

moneyunsure · 12/01/2019 16:07

We have quite a lot of debt. Dh thinks that if I work we can clear the debt quicker. I think we just need to budget more.

I think that I’m better off at home looking after the dc (3 school age and a baby). Dh thinks I could manage working school hours but this would then mean we would have to pay for nursery and also I want to be at home with the baby and have anxiety so I don’t want to work.

I have argued that I can save us as much as I’d potentially earn by cutting out all luxuries and having an even smaller budget and just cutting back. So financially the outcome would be the same ??

OP posts:
ZenNudist · 13/01/2019 02:00

Do the budget and get an evening/ weekend job. Might have to mixfeed formula if you don't want to express. Its not easy on your H either if he works all day and does all of the childcare in the evenings. The more effort you put in now the quicker you will be out of this hole. How the hell do you end up with 4dc if you are in dire financial straits?

Frequency · 13/01/2019 02:02

It's ok to set limits like you are only prepared to work one day over the weekend, and the money must go towards the debt, not spent elsewhere, and your husband must help pick up the slack, if you work Saturdays and come home to a trashed house you get to spend Sunday cleaning will result in you no longer working

Holy shit, don't do the above OP. Your husband has supported you your entire adult life. Don't start laying down the law now he has asked you to start working. He'll be liable to walk out if he has any sense.

snitzelvoncrumb · 13/01/2019 02:15

Yes it's much better to be a door mat. It's ok for him to ask you to go back to work, but he needs to understand you need to take it slowly and it will mean him stepping up at home. He needs to know this before you get a job, not after.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

snoutandab0ut · 13/01/2019 02:16

Genuine question, and I think someone else has said it earlier on this thread, why do so many people hold the view that work is optional for women but obligatory for men? Obviously logistics need to be worked out around children but it’s really quite depressing to see so many people who don’t seem to think financial contributions should EVER be their responsibility (obviously people on mat leave are not included in that)

Frequency · 13/01/2019 02:22

Yes it's much better to be a door mat

The OP's Dh has supported her financially, practically and emotionally her entire adult life and only now after twenty years has asked her to find part-time work. I think it's fairly safe to assume he is a good man who doesn't treat her like a doormat.

Birdie6 · 13/01/2019 02:39

If you're that much in debt, it would seem that your "extreme budgeting" isn't something you are able to stick to.

If you pick up a couple of night shifts in a care home , you'd be contributing to the household and hardly missing any time with your kids.

MyOtherProfile · 13/01/2019 05:51

£30 on face cream. Seven whole pounds & fifty pence per week! Even worse £40every 8 weeks for a haircut - that’s a whopping £5 a week

But of course that works out at £100 every two months which is pretty significant in the light of their debt.

OP it's great to see tour change if heart about working. Don't take too long to think about it though. 3 hours cleaning on a Sat morning would give you at least 30 quid, most of a weekend still with your family and a husband who feels you're doing at least something to contributdid you ever tell us how old your older 3 are?

jessstan2 · 13/01/2019 05:57

Why not agree to go back to work when the baby is older? A compromise. It's not fair to expect him to shoulder all expenses, we're not living in the 1950s. Also - can be fun to go to work! I had some of my best times at work where I was not just someone's wife or mum.

I do sympathise with your anxiety btw (being an anxious person I would), which is why I suggested waiting a bit, but sometimes getting out in the world helps anxiety.

Work out what it would cost you for childcare (not just you, both of you), and how much money you would make. Then discuss in detail.

Instamom · 13/01/2019 06:06

Yes I think plan something to get some extra money in for the short term but also plan for the long term.

Study/retrain and plan to share the load with him financially once the childcare costs ease as the children get older. I honestly think that if you plan and prepare for this the anxiety will lessen. And it will help relieve the pressure.

ivykaty44 · 13/01/2019 06:23

I would use entitledto benefits calculator to ensure you are getting what you should be. Are you also entitled to council tax relief? Check this out as it’s possible

There have been some great suggestions of how to earn money without using childcare. Op registering as a child minder would seem one of the most convenient for your situation- could you offer early starts for school runs. 6am starts and then take to school so just a couple of hours each morning- just advertise for the school your dc go to

Budgeting is a good way of reducing debt but it’s nit the only way

Graphista · 13/01/2019 06:48

JESUS WEPT! The attitudes on this thread!

"Fuck me some people are being really really unpleasant." Thank god I'm not the only one that thinks so - though we seem very much in the minority.

MrDarcyWillbemine - I've reported your post at 1649. Genuine serious anxiety CAN be bad enough to stop someone working. To say otherwise is disablist & inaccurate

And they're not the only one with a shitty narrow minded attitude! (And yes I reported others too though tbh I reached a point I just asked mnhq to review the whole thread!)

"A lot of us "halfwits" have lived and do lobe with anxiety. A lot of us have to deal with it because we dont have the luxury of sitting at home and swanning about to baby groups and hairdressers which with v bad anxiety u would not wanna do anyway"

Wtf!!!!

If everyone had exactly the same response to illnesses especially mental illness they'd be a damn sight easier to treat!

If you're able to still work then I'm sorry you don't have the worst level of anxiety, Jesus even this shitty, callous govt recognises that!!!

"It would serve you right OP if DP had a bit of a ‘break down’ and you had to support your families lifestyle for a while!" What on earth! Why is breakdown in quotes? Do you think they're fucking fictional?

"Millions of us have anxiety/depression and have medication and still work"

Yes - And there are also millions who's anxiety/depression is too severe for them to work!

I've done both but when I was working I was more well than when I was at my worst.

"Well I can do it" is a ridiculous argument! You're not the op and you don't know exactly or how badly HER illness affects HER!

"Factory / supermarket / care / pub - I live in a very small town but all of this sort of work is available as evening shifts." I'd love to know if YOU know how many applicants per vacancy in your area? Some online job sites show a counter, where I live when I was looking the number of applicants PER VACANCY on even one site (and the same jobs were usually advertised on multiple sites, plus with Job centre, local paper & Facebook pages) was well H to several HUNDRED - and no I don't mean that's how many had just looked at the job but applied via the site. If anything the lower skilled/poorer paid jobs had the most applicants.

"She’s only been on meds for 2.5 years." that's NOT what she said! She said she's been on a particular med that long. I've only been on my current prescription for 8 months but I've been on meds of some kind for the last 13 years and prior to that on others at different points. Patients can change meds for a huge variety of reasons. In my case a combination of their losing effectiveness or my becoming allergic/side effects/reactions, they might be discontinued or op might be needing to take another med for an unrelated physical condition that contraindicates the AD she was on, hell I've heard of people ending up having their AD changed because they've changed GP and new GP for the most bizarre of reasons sometimes won't prescribe the ones the patient was on!! I've even heard of GP's who are reluctant to prescribe them at all!

Graphista · 13/01/2019 06:49

Wow! Ok op didn't help the way the thread went with the lack of info at the beginning. I was sort of nodding along and agreeing with a lot of posts as the true situation wasn't clear.

BUT the SHITTY posts SINCE that ESPECIALLY Where it's clear that the poster HAS read the post by op quoted below about her work background are completely out of order and quite a few are plain disablist! Mental health issues ARE a recognised disability when severe. I sincerely hope none of you ever experience them because I suspect you're also surrounded by people with similar views. And yet I've had a few times on Mn where people have tried to tell me there's no longer a stigma to being mentally ill. I'm saving a link to this thread for the next time a poster elsewhere claims this, especially if they say it doesn't happen on mn!!!

You should be ashamed of yourselves!

As for the "poor husband" bollocks - she didn't make them 4 kids alone! And it sounds like he's also been contributing to overspending!

"I'll tell you why you've had some harsh responses, it's because given a choice, most of us wouldn't work" I strongly suspect you're right - no excuse for some of the truly disgusting attacks on op!

"I think (some) men think it’s an easy option to stay at home looking after the children" clearly not just men based on this thread!

"The last time I worked was a very long time ago. About 20 years. I had a total breakdown in my late teens/early twenties and that was it as far as work went I have basic qualifications and no specific skills." Wow! MASSIVE dripfeed there!! By basic qualifications do you have 5 GCSEs inc English & maths? Tbh most nmw part time jobs aren't going to be expecting huge qualifications but the lack of experience of ANY work for so long IS going to be an issue.

Do you have a cpn? Support worker? They're getting harder to find due to the cuts but there are people who specialise in helping people who have been off work long term due to illness/disability to access education/training/jobs with sympathetic employers. I was working with one in 2017, unfortunately I then took very ill again. But others in the group I was part of are now back in work and a couple hadn't worked for nearly 30 years. Where in the country (just roughly) are you? Maybe we can help you access support groups and services like this?

I'm agoraphobic to the point of housebound. There's a huge range or levels of "anxiety". If you suffer but are still able to work great, it's not true for everyone and frankly I'm shocked that even other sufferers are being so very judgmental and lacking compassion.

The reality is she is unlikely to get a job with in real terms no experience, few qualifications & serious health issues.

I was working with a support worker in 2017 when I (mistakenly as it turned out) thought I was well enough to return to work after almost 10 years not working myself. For the benefit of those who I HOPE are merely unaware of how hard it is to get back into work in this situation:

I have 2 degrees, lots of experience in various industries mainly admin & healthcare, good references. I applied for over 200 jobs and only got 3 replies - and one of those was an auto response email!

A big gap on your cv alone makes it VERY hard to get back into work. And I wasn't being fussy! I was applying for everything from shelf stacking, online shopping picker to medium level admin roles and roles more suited to my most recent degree. All hours because my dd is now old enough not to need childcare, was also happy to travel up to 2 hours commuting (providing the cost v wage wasn't leaving me much worse off). I also had the support worker advocating for me and asking employers they had "contacts" with if there was anything and giving them my cv. There just aren't the jobs out there. Especially if it's a deprived area. I've also several friends and family who are already working but hate their jobs/employers and are/have been looking for alternative roles and they're saying it's pretty dire too!

However,
"but things like haircuts are not what I would class as luxuries." £40 ones bloody well are!

Ditto £30 on skincare!

Sorry op but I think you do need a dose of reality with regard to spending (and those that know me on here or if they want to can go look at my posting history will know I am not one to be tough on non working mums of young DC, I also have a lot of sympathy with those dealing with MH issues as I suffer badly myself)

You and your dh were BOTH irresponsible because it sounds like you PLANNED to have 4 children when you clearly couldn't really afford it! Then you compounded your mistake by living outside your means and running up debt! Actually just read your post at 1652 and the debt was incurred BEFORE DC 4 was even conceived! That was a poor decision.

Money saving expert site is an excellent suggestion, though I've found the forums aren't as busy as they once were, there's lots of useful info on there. He's also very vocal and supportive of the fact that mh can and does affect finances & people's handling of debt quite seriously.

With 4 of your own there's a reasonable assumption you like and are good with kids. It's not easy (I've done it) there's a lot of planning and organisation to get set up and then to do the job but it would let you be home with your own DC AND be earning AND still have a certain amount of control over how you work, which might help with the anxiety side of things.

That's why I did it. (Plus I love kids). It certainly wouldn't hurt to look into it. It takes time to get to the point where you are actually taking families on but in that time you can be applying your ideas on budgeting too. It would also lead to your gaining certain qualifications.

However

"Since you're collecting your dc from school anyway, can you mind one or two more kids from the same school for money?" If the op has the other children for more than 2 hours per day then she is required by law to be a registered childminder. The requirements for this vary around the uk, generally speaking a child care qualification, first aid qualification are minimum plus the home has to be safe & clean (to a far higher standard than most normal homes), a selection of toys, books and equipment must be provided and the op would need official registration with the appropriate body (ofsted in England & Wales) & have permission to operate a business in the property (not all landlords or mortgage companies agree) and public liability insurance. Some councils or clients like childminders to have food safety qualifications too. It is NOT a job you can just decide to do overnight. Takes about 6 months to set up.

If I didn't also have a physical disability I'd consider doing it again myself (I've certainly been asked).

Another option is being a nanny/mothers help, this isn't as tightly regulated as childminding (though for other reasons I think it should be) and there are families who (providing it didn't interfere with you doing the job) would be OK with you taking your own baby along.

You could also do "normal" babysitting on evenings when dh is home.

There's also possibly some jobs that can be done from home. Try and avoid the mlm scams obviously but some admin roles (could you do this?), taking in ironing, basic sewing, maybe if you're crafty there's something you can make to sell?

On that note as well as budgeting are you selling things you & your family no longer need that are in good condition?

Calling the op lazy when they've 4 kids including a 10 month old baby is ridiculous though! That's going too far!

"Care work can offer huge flexibility and doesn't require qualifications" not strictly true. While there's no legal requirement any decent employer will require a basic qualification and/or experience with the applicant willing to work towards a qualification. Employers who don't are usually dreadful employers (as well as pretty shit care providers). I worked for a good while in elderly care and that's been my experience.

DeadCertain - I'm really curious about your job now!

"A bit off topic, but I am really shocked that you felt you had to go private for your gall bladder"

I'm not! - op's experience with her health issue is FAR fil unusual. On a number of threads on here there's a lot of women who've had a similar experience. Some of the posts on the subject aren't by the patient but loved ones and the patient did die! So please don't be flippant about this, it's a major issue especially for women. Frankly I'm shocked this & the HUGE denial of the extent of thyroid disease in women aren't national scandals!

IN SUMMARY

1 CONTACT A DEBT CHARITY: Christians against poverty, stepchange, national debtline are the big ones. If possible get the debt transferred to 0% provider, if not then reduced apr% at least or interest frozen. They should also be able to tell you quite accurately what if any benefits you're eligible for.

2 CUT COSTS - money saving expert AND Mn are excellent for helping with this. Off the top of my head:

Hair - use local college or find an "old lady" hairdressers (which is what I use. Very good at her job and cheap £10 for a trim and blow dry), or mobile hairdressers can be cheaper.

Skin - you've already said you can significantly reduce this

Food - I'm veggie so the comments on forcing dh to eat veggie food have been erm interesting, but dd isn't, so even with meat in the diet there's loads of ways to cut down here. Reduce your brand level by at least one tier (most people won't notice much if any difference) then in a few months do it again. You & dh may find there are certain things you're really not willing to compromise on (for me it's fairy liquid and shower creme. Shower creme due to sensitive skin/allergies, fairy cos frankly all others are so crap I end up using more anyway so it's a false economy. Dd will only drink actual Diet Coke when she fancies a fizzy drink BUT what I do - and luckily these all have long shelf lives - is only buy them when they're on offer and then I sort of stock up a bit. As a result they don't actually cost me more than 1 tier brand difference). Also consider using different shops, even bulk buying some items from Costco or Amazon type places?

Shop around - energy, water (if in England and Wales), any insurance, Internet, phones (I'd bet good money you're paying way over the odds for your mobiles!), any tv packages (largely unnecessary imo, we have Netflix but that's it. Otherwise free provisions are plenty especially with so much available on free catch up services), transport costs (do you both have cars? If so could you downgrade the car, reduce insurance? Money saving expert has advice on driving efficiently to save money and there's apps to let you know which local petrol station is cheapest that day), if public transport look at seasonal tickets, discounted options (if you get pip or dla you can get disabled railcard if you qualify on mobility grounds. I do) or family tickets (had a family railcard when I was working), buses vary greatly on location depends on your local company. Mine do various seasonal passes which depending how much you use them can work out cheaper than paying each journey.

Everything look for vouchers and discounts before paying full price for anything. Get loyalty cards for EVERY shop you use - the points acquired can come in very useful for school holidays and Christmas!

3 LOOK INTO GETTING QUALIFICATIONS/GOING BACK TO WORK

speak to your cpn if you have one, or depending where you are various mh charities can advise what's available locally including funding (which can sometimes include childcare), look at local jobs ads to get an idea of requirements and what's available so you can plan in a targeted way.

"Look into support the job centre can offer" erm when were you last in a job centre?!

Citalopram isn't preferred for bf mothers but if it's op's usual antidepressant, depending how bad her mh is it may have been decided that the benefits of her staying on it outweighed the risks. If anything that suggests to me her mh is quite poor if her DOCTORS won't even consider a change of meds.

Graphista · 13/01/2019 06:49
  • I, as has been suggested by PP, have my suspicions that OP might be a little more behind the number of children that her husband. If you catch my drift

1 it takes 2 to tango ALWAYS

2 that is a VERY nasty accusation to make especially with no foundation for such thoughts.

Wtf is with the posters on this thread?!?!

"Why is everyone assuming this man is an idiot?" Maybe because he's also been overspending, and thinks a woman with minimal qualifications, poor mh, who hasn't worked in 20 years & 4 DC inc a bf baby can just "get" a term time school hours only job that pays well enough to cover childcare costs for the baby AND make a significant difference to their income?! Hardly the brightest!

"What about a working from home job? Like sales etc my friend does this and they pay her broadband, phone bill and heating" with minimal qualifications & no experience? Aye right! I'm also wondering if your friend is doing mlm - which isn't really a job it's a scam!

Raspberry88 · 13/01/2019 06:50

£30 on face cream. Seven whole pounds & fifty pence per week! Even worse £40every 8 weeks for a haircut - that’s a whopping £5 a week
Completely unnecessary though, most people manage with a rare haircut and some Nivea. I second pps suggestion of something like delivering for Hermes if you do drive. The woman who delivers for them around here really loves it as she can work it around school hours and it's really not bad money if you work hard at it.

Fontofnoknowledge · 13/01/2019 07:18

Being a SAHP has to be a mutually AGREED decision between both parents.

In this case it is NOT mutually agreed. Therefore OP needs to get a job. Just like all of us who have given birth have HAD to do.
I returned when they were 9 months, 6 months and 1 yr. All breastfed.

Everybody lived.
I have been on citalipram since youngest was born.

Ethel36 · 13/01/2019 07:31

I agree with you, try cutting back first. In the past my husband told me I had to get a job to help with the bills. We have two little ones. I looked for jobs and childcare. I worked it all out and would be losing money, as the childcare was higher than the salary after tax. I found a weekend job, but he didnt want to look after the children on his days off. So instead I heavily cut back on food, heating and hair cuts. This helped alot.

ThatsNotNiceRoger · 13/01/2019 07:48

£30 on face cream. Seven whole pounds & fifty pence per week! Even worse £40every 8 weeks for a haircut - that’s a whopping £5 a week

It’s also £650 per year.

Ethel36 · 13/01/2019 07:59

Forgot to say, cutting back on meat saved us alot of money. We have vegetarian meals mostly, with meat just twice a week.

Xenia · 13/01/2019 08:00

It does seem a bit much. I trim the ends of my hair so don't buy any hair cuts and I work full time.

picklemepopcorn · 13/01/2019 08:04

OP im amazed you have stuck with this thread- some posters have been really nasty! I think people are making assumptions based on their own experiences. Looking after the home and four children, with major health issues, is no holiday.

Well done for talking it through with DH and being ready to make changes.

You'll feel much better for taking on some of the responsibility- it brings a sense of control with it.

Dolceandgabbana14 · 13/01/2019 08:07

Priorities for OP:

  1. Ensure contraception is failsafe
  1. Get life and critical illness cover in place - what would happen if, God forbid, anything happened to OP's husband that meant he was unable to work? This would provide peace of mind that there would still be an income.
snowie01 · 13/01/2019 08:15

Def try evening cleaning OP. I did it for a long time due to bad anxiety and other health issues. Really suited me as was alone with the offices and my cleaning tools. Locked up and went gone. Couple of hours a night.

elliesm98 · 13/01/2019 08:27

Yabu. There is no reason you can’t get a job selling Avon, or cleaning in the early morning whilst everyone’s asleep. You haven’t worked for 20 years out of laziness, racked up debt for your family and continued to buy unnecessary luxuries at your husbands expense. What if he decided he didn’t wanna work anymore ?

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 13/01/2019 09:05

OP, in all your posts I haven't seen an iota of concern for your DH. The guy has been supporting you for your whole adult life and yet ALL your concern is for yourself and how much YOU don't want to work.

Thousands and thousands of people every day who have kids, who have anxiety, who have homes to look after, get off their backsides and go out to work every day because they know that that is what adults do to pay the bills, put food on the table, support the family.

And yet you are on here holding some kind of pity party because after TWENTY years, your husband has asked if you could possibly take some of the burden off his shoulders and oh no, it's all too much.

I dont know what will happen or if I’ll be able to but I’m going to think about it properly which is a big thing for me

Oh, how gracious of you. How lucky he is to have you. Angry

ZigZagZombie · 13/01/2019 09:05

OP - I truly sympathise and think you're on a bit of a sticky wicket.

I am educated, have work experience blah di blah. I've also had two major breakdowns when working FT pre-kids and the third post-kids led to me being dragged off in an ambulance. I'd hope I'd come across as relatively normal... but I'm quite heavily medicated and have to control my life quite carefully else I go bonkers. Some of us are walking a tight-rope already.

OP - have you looked in to claiming PIP at all? There seems no rhyme nor reason who gets awarded what. I get lower rate daily living - although others with my (severe) MH diagnosis get enhanced for both bits. Nonetheless every little 'elps as Tesco would say.

On that note - this thread has inspired me and I feel quite excited about getting a PT job in Tesco doing something at dawn. My mental and physical strength is at its highest at 5am so that would suit me down to the ground. Sadly I fear those who'd tell me to get a job are also those who'd tell social services if I were to leave my kids at home on their own. (Single parent, no family, no friends ishoos).

OP - I would look at getting PIP and also some of those lovely dawn hours jobs in a supermarket which sound bliss.