Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AMA

My 2 kids go to boarding school, AMA

812 replies

happylady1982 · 28/07/2026 11:11

My kids are 14 and 16, they both go to boarding school. Weekly boarding. This means they come home every weekend, and during the half terms and the major holidays too (Christmas, easter, summer).

Right now it's the summer holidays so they are home.

I wanted to do an AMA cause I think people still have negative stereotypes about boarding school.

OP posts:
Itsasecretnow · 30/07/2026 15:40

happylady1982 · 29/07/2026 12:15

Thank you for being so respectful!

Yeah I'm not a fan of people who force their kids to go to boarding school. That is an easy way for a child to build resentment. Unless there was a valid and specific reason a child needed to go to boarding school. Because my kids chose to go to boarding school, they really enjoy being there. They know a few students who were forced to go to boarding school and students who only go home during big holidays like christmas, easter and summer. My kids have said those students tend to be the least happy. And I understand, it can't be nice being away from home when you don't want to be away from home.

Every child is a different! In the nicest way possible...I also think it's a bit wild your ex partner suggested boarding school, even as a hypothetical. 😭

Well, tbf it wasn’t anywhere near the wildest or most bizarre of his thoughts and ideas but that’s a whole story by itself 😂

BeasKnee · 30/07/2026 15:51

Oscillating · 30/07/2026 13:15

Not always. There's all sorts of reasons why a child might board or live away from the family home.

What if the parents are abusing the child?

What if the parents are in the military and moving round every few months?

What if the parent has to travel abroad for work for 8 days every month and there's no-one else at home to look after the kid?

What if the child is severely disabled and needs respite care for 6 days and nights a month

Sorry, I missed that reply from the OP about which of these applied to her kids. If not then I'm not sure how abused kids come into this discussion. I seem to remember the reasons being that the structure of the day or something vague like that was similar to their primary school and that why it was picked over the local school. No, I have no idea what that means either. I don't think there was mention of disabilities either, or travelling abroad, or a special skill their children excelled in that could only be encouraged at this particular school.

I know discussion has moved on but there's a massive divide between kids being away from their parents for safety and just choosing this because it's a good school.

Oscillating · 30/07/2026 16:03

BeasKnee · 30/07/2026 15:51

Sorry, I missed that reply from the OP about which of these applied to her kids. If not then I'm not sure how abused kids come into this discussion. I seem to remember the reasons being that the structure of the day or something vague like that was similar to their primary school and that why it was picked over the local school. No, I have no idea what that means either. I don't think there was mention of disabilities either, or travelling abroad, or a special skill their children excelled in that could only be encouraged at this particular school.

I know discussion has moved on but there's a massive divide between kids being away from their parents for safety and just choosing this because it's a good school.

That wasn't an exhaustive list....

The point is that there are all sorts of different families and situations and actually it might be better for the child to boarding 1-7 nights.

Oscillating · 30/07/2026 16:04

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 13:21

Your arguments are very weak indeed.

I won't boast, but many of the students where I taught did achieve a lot- film directors, opera singers, artists, and more.

The point is that some children benefit from boarding. It isn't an automatic conclusion that the children are somehow neglected, unloved, abandoned etc.

Gloriia · 30/07/2026 16:27

'What does come over though is that you have no experience of them at all, either as a professional working in them, or families whose children go there, or any children who are in them and actually like the experience.Why keep arguing the point?'

'Why keep arguing the point'? Stop quoting me then. You do know that's chat forum etiquette, yes? You quote me so I the correct you and so forth.

This might come as a shock to you but I know ex boarders. No, my parents didn't send me away to live with paid staff so I fortunately wasn't ever tucked in by Miss or Sir but I've heard plenty of stories from people who yes had jolly japes but look back and feel sad that their parents palmed them off at such a young age. Those feelings last in a way that the fun of costume making and sailing may not.

Private, fine. Boarding? Nope. They soon go off to uni, not that long for these parents to endure surely.

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 16:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

RancidRuby · 30/07/2026 17:05

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 09:52

Have you met any children in real life who are weekly boarders?

You seem so insistent that there is only one way- your way!
You also seem to imagine that all families are happy families, whereas many are not- parents not getting on, going through separation, being fully stretched with work so they come home late, tired and frazzled, sibling rivalry, etc.

Boarding school suits some families and children very well.

The OP's children are teenagers. They are not 7.

My ex partner boarded from 7 to 19 in single sex schools including one of the top public schools That is partly why he's an ex. He said it damaged him. However, he is fully behind boarding for older children if it works for them.

There is a HUGE difference between children boarding full time from a young age and teens weekly boarding.

OP’s children were 11 when they started boarding though, not teenagers. They are teenagers now and whilst I’m broadly anti boarding I think for older teenagers weekly boarding would be ok if that’s what they really wanted or if a school offered a certain subject or speciality that they excelled at necessitating the need to board. Age 11 is too young IMO, and more so for the frankly weird reason that this school offered a similar schedule to their primary. What does that even mean? I think people are just a bit baffled at the choice to send kids to a school that involved either a very long commute or boarding as opposed to sending to a closer but comparably good private school. OP lives in a city not in the middle of nowhere, there must be a number of private day schools in a workable distance to choose from. I just find it odd that when choosing a school the distance of the school from the family home didn’t seem to be a consideration, I think for most people this would factor quite heavily when the children concerned were only 11.

Gloriia · 30/07/2026 17:21

'11 year old's are far more mature than a lot of people give them credit for'

Oh they aren't they are young kids trying to act big and tough, straight out of primary. They aren't supposed to be on social media such is the recognition of how immature and open to negative influences they are. I've had 11yr olds stay here with our dc and they aren't much more grown up than when they were 8.

Young kids need consistency, they need full time parents not weekend families and extra curricular activities should come way down the list not be a priority

Hildagilda · 30/07/2026 18:58

JoeTheDrummer · 28/07/2026 18:32

Not necessarily jealousy of boarding, but certainly there’s likely to be envy that the OP has a very high income and enough spare cash to have the choice to educate her child as she sees best. Not many of us have that option, most people have just their local state schools, which is fine if they’re good. But when someone’s local state schools aren’t great, or their child is unhappy at school for whatever reason, and somebody on here is talking about spending £90k a year on schooling, then yes there’s going to be jealousy of them having other options available.

I'm not coming from a place of envy, we have the means. I'd never do it because I have seen the affects of it on university students, in their academic success (or there lackof) , in their relationships, in their own vitriol towards their parents for being abondened, in them blaming boarding as number one reason for depression, for wanting to have special needs, and scientific peer reviewed research supports it. I truly can't understand why parents still do it. Bar military personnel, why, just why would anyone send their kids away, when they simply don't need to, even in their teens. Area not having good schools, career etc are, to be perfectly honest, just plain excuses, they can be fixed. Either parents are not doing their research, or wanting to burry their heads in the sand, or are just another sort of ignorant, thinking it'd look posh (just send to private then!!).. Or plainly just thinking wishfully or don't care as their own needs and wants surpass the truth. My teens wanted it is no excuse either. Kids don't know what they are getting into, once they're there they don't know anything else, if they feel boarding is better than home home might be a problem. I think op, you need to do some introspection.

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 19:09

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

cardibach · 30/07/2026 19:17

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

According to the OP. You believe her, but don’t believe anyone saying they are t motivated by envy or giving reasons why they think it’s damaging even if the children feel they were involved in the decision.

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 19:25

cardibach · 30/07/2026 19:17

According to the OP. You believe her, but don’t believe anyone saying they are t motivated by envy or giving reasons why they think it’s damaging even if the children feel they were involved in the decision.

Struggling to understand what you’ve written there, but I’ll have a bash at responding…

I believe the OP as that is what we all have to go on. She’s answered about her family life and how the children enjoy school. I also know a lot of boarders at my child’s school and it all rings true to their experiences.

I can see how determined some are to insist that the OP is the World’s Worst Mother, but it doesn’t convince me in the slightest.

If we were in similar circumstances come senior school and my child asked to board weekly I would absolutely consider it on the proviso, just like OP has stated, that they can stop any time they want to.

cardibach · 30/07/2026 19:35

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 19:25

Struggling to understand what you’ve written there, but I’ll have a bash at responding…

I believe the OP as that is what we all have to go on. She’s answered about her family life and how the children enjoy school. I also know a lot of boarders at my child’s school and it all rings true to their experiences.

I can see how determined some are to insist that the OP is the World’s Worst Mother, but it doesn’t convince me in the slightest.

If we were in similar circumstances come senior school and my child asked to board weekly I would absolutely consider it on the proviso, just like OP has stated, that they can stop any time they want to.

Not sure what was hard to understand. There was one fairly neutral typo 🤷‍♀️
I’m saying - you believe the OP that her children are happy and made an informed decision. Maybe they did. I’m not saying they didn’t. I’m saying it’s odd you believe that, but anyone saying that 11 year olds aren't the best placed to weigh up the pros and cons, or that many boarders maintain they are happy as children but see the damage later, or that boarding is fundamentally wrong, or any other criticism of it, you think are deluded, ignorant or envious, whatever their real world experience. It’s a weird double standard.
Edited for little typos as you seem to find them confusing

PeteKnew · 30/07/2026 19:50

incrediblyincredible · 29/07/2026 12:15

Wow why are you married to this guy? I’m sorry it affected him so badly.

It's difficult for me to be married to him, for sure.
He's gotten a lot worse over the years. The older he's got the more magnified all his problems have got.
He wasn't this bad when we married, although the signs were definately all there. I thought the unity of a happy secure marriage and starting a family of our own would settle him. It's done the opposite. He spends all his days droning on and on about how my parenting and devotion to our DC has made him question why his mother wasn't devoted to him, and when he sees how much emotional input our DC require on a daily basis he gets sad and says he needed daily emotional input as a teenager too but there was noone there to give it. So having DC and him watching me parent them and seeing their daily needs being met has shone a torch on what he didn't have and how his emotional needs weren't met, which has made his mental health worse.

Gloriia · 30/07/2026 20:03

'I can see how determined some are to insist that the OP is the World’s Worst Mother'

Who has said that? It's like a pp saying I though I was perfect. I certainly haven't suggested that.

Kids are minors. They can't do anything until 18 without our permission or supervision. That is for a reason, children are vulnerable and immature. They need the stability of full time parenting. Not on a weekend, not on holidays. Full time.

The pp and her dh are outsourcing these vital developmental years to staff. They are signing over their kid's wellbeing to paid staff. Why choose that? Why choose extra curricular activities over parenting?!

It is delusional to think hockey and sailing are more important than being a fulltime member of a family.

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 20:04

cardibach · 30/07/2026 19:35

Not sure what was hard to understand. There was one fairly neutral typo 🤷‍♀️
I’m saying - you believe the OP that her children are happy and made an informed decision. Maybe they did. I’m not saying they didn’t. I’m saying it’s odd you believe that, but anyone saying that 11 year olds aren't the best placed to weigh up the pros and cons, or that many boarders maintain they are happy as children but see the damage later, or that boarding is fundamentally wrong, or any other criticism of it, you think are deluded, ignorant or envious, whatever their real world experience. It’s a weird double standard.
Edited for little typos as you seem to find them confusing

Edited

I just don’t think you’re very good at expressing yourself.

Why is it odd that I believe the OP’s children are happy if your response is “maybe they did, I’m not saying they didn’t”? I’m basing my thoughts on what the OP has said and also my experience of a having a child at a private school with boarders.

As for 11 being young- yes it is. Thankfully the OP made it clear they didn’t have to board and can stop any time they want. Seems like it’s been a success so far.

Gloriia · 30/07/2026 20:10

'My teens wanted it is no excuse either. Kids don't know what they are getting into, once they're there they don't know anything else, if they feel boarding is better than home home might be a problem'

Exactly. They 'chose' it, well they don't know all the implications do they! They just don't want to be the odd one out going home when others are living there.

I'd have been so disappointed if my dc had chosen to live elsewhere at aged 11 and just come home for weekends. All very sad.

Craftycariad · 30/07/2026 20:19

FallenNight · 30/07/2026 13:51

All these people who think that everyone should either choose career or children. If we all did that, and chose children, who the hell would be doing all the jobs.

Full time boarding school from age 7 is a very different thing to 4 nights a week from age 11.

11 year old's are far more mature than a lot of people give them credit for. The trend of infantizing older children is pretty damaging in itself.

Totally agree the trend of infantizing kids is awful and does intense damage to them in my opinion. They need to learn how to think for themselves , deal with issues and generally grow. However when doing that they need the support of their parents, when they need a hug they should be able to have one from their parents not from some stranger. Keeping your children with you, being the one to talk about their day , being the one that is there for them is an absolute part of being a parent. Packing them off to someone else to look after them isn't the best for them. It is really unbelievable that you think any job requires children to be sent away from home to do it properly and is absolutely disrespectful to parents who look after their children and work. I will never understand why anyone thinks packing them off is an acceptable option.

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 20:49

Craftycariad · 30/07/2026 20:19

Totally agree the trend of infantizing kids is awful and does intense damage to them in my opinion. They need to learn how to think for themselves , deal with issues and generally grow. However when doing that they need the support of their parents, when they need a hug they should be able to have one from their parents not from some stranger. Keeping your children with you, being the one to talk about their day , being the one that is there for them is an absolute part of being a parent. Packing them off to someone else to look after them isn't the best for them. It is really unbelievable that you think any job requires children to be sent away from home to do it properly and is absolutely disrespectful to parents who look after their children and work. I will never understand why anyone thinks packing them off is an acceptable option.

Can we stop this nonsense of 'packing them off'?
It's 4 nights a week, when they can be in contact with their parents.

Boarding schools exist and always will as they cater for all kinds of parental circumstances and children's needs.

@Craftycariad Like many posters here you appear to not be aware of why some families choose a boarding school. They may be in the Forces- moving every year, across the world, so the school offers stability. They may have frequent trips overseas for any reason. They may be widowers and prefer the input of female staff.

Their child may even - shock horror- enjoy boarding!

These teens have a few hours a day at school after prep and before bedtime.

They are simply sleeping in the school rather than having a long journey home and back the next day. They can call and message their family.

Many schools now offer flexi boarding- anything from a night to several.
This caters for the students who do sport or other events after lessons and avoids along journey home.

I'm really shocked , being honest, having spent a career in education and across all sectors that some posters think flexi or weekly boarding is so terrible.

cardibach · 30/07/2026 20:52

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 20:04

I just don’t think you’re very good at expressing yourself.

Why is it odd that I believe the OP’s children are happy if your response is “maybe they did, I’m not saying they didn’t”? I’m basing my thoughts on what the OP has said and also my experience of a having a child at a private school with boarders.

As for 11 being young- yes it is. Thankfully the OP made it clear they didn’t have to board and can stop any time they want. Seems like it’s been a success so far.

My expression is perfectly clear, and you know it is. My point is about your attitude. You refuse to accept any but the most positive views of boarding. And I was making a more general point than the OP’s children, so it is irrelevant to the point whether those specific children are happy.

cardibach · 30/07/2026 20:56

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 20:49

Can we stop this nonsense of 'packing them off'?
It's 4 nights a week, when they can be in contact with their parents.

Boarding schools exist and always will as they cater for all kinds of parental circumstances and children's needs.

@Craftycariad Like many posters here you appear to not be aware of why some families choose a boarding school. They may be in the Forces- moving every year, across the world, so the school offers stability. They may have frequent trips overseas for any reason. They may be widowers and prefer the input of female staff.

Their child may even - shock horror- enjoy boarding!

These teens have a few hours a day at school after prep and before bedtime.

They are simply sleeping in the school rather than having a long journey home and back the next day. They can call and message their family.

Many schools now offer flexi boarding- anything from a night to several.
This caters for the students who do sport or other events after lessons and avoids along journey home.

I'm really shocked , being honest, having spent a career in education and across all sectors that some posters think flexi or weekly boarding is so terrible.

None of those thing apply to the OP’s children though. Or, 8n my experience, the vast majority of boarders. I also have experience of work8ng in the board8ng sector. As I’ve said before, it’s advantageous for a tiny, tiny number of children. For most it is a terrible choice below, at the earliest, age 14. I’d be hesitant until 16 (and even the. For most).

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 21:13

GingerPopp · 30/07/2026 20:49

Can we stop this nonsense of 'packing them off'?
It's 4 nights a week, when they can be in contact with their parents.

Boarding schools exist and always will as they cater for all kinds of parental circumstances and children's needs.

@Craftycariad Like many posters here you appear to not be aware of why some families choose a boarding school. They may be in the Forces- moving every year, across the world, so the school offers stability. They may have frequent trips overseas for any reason. They may be widowers and prefer the input of female staff.

Their child may even - shock horror- enjoy boarding!

These teens have a few hours a day at school after prep and before bedtime.

They are simply sleeping in the school rather than having a long journey home and back the next day. They can call and message their family.

Many schools now offer flexi boarding- anything from a night to several.
This caters for the students who do sport or other events after lessons and avoids along journey home.

I'm really shocked , being honest, having spent a career in education and across all sectors that some posters think flexi or weekly boarding is so terrible.

It’s pathetic and they are stubbornly refusing to see otherwise because they have an agenda to bash the OP. Our child’s school does flexi boarding too and it’s a fantastic resource. The kids love it.

It’s the usual nonsense from posters with no experience of private education who simply don’t want to listen.

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 21:15

cardibach · 30/07/2026 20:56

None of those thing apply to the OP’s children though. Or, 8n my experience, the vast majority of boarders. I also have experience of work8ng in the board8ng sector. As I’ve said before, it’s advantageous for a tiny, tiny number of children. For most it is a terrible choice below, at the earliest, age 14. I’d be hesitant until 16 (and even the. For most).

Where is your source for this tiny, tiny number of children?

Surely, logically, they must be having a horrendous time of it too surrounded by all the other miserable neglected boarders. Very odd for it to be advantageous for them in such terrible conditions that everyone else suffers 🤔

Prrrprrrprrr · 30/07/2026 21:18

cardibach · 30/07/2026 20:52

My expression is perfectly clear, and you know it is. My point is about your attitude. You refuse to accept any but the most positive views of boarding. And I was making a more general point than the OP’s children, so it is irrelevant to the point whether those specific children are happy.

So are these specific children happy or not? Because you are saying the OP is in the wrong in allowing her children the choice to board. Your other general points don’t correlate with the OP’s experience.

I accept the reality of boarding as I know it, which is similar to the OP’s. Your experience of working in a boarding house must have been awful- I’m glad my child doesn’t attend the school you worked in.

Gloriia · 30/07/2026 21:29

'They are simply sleeping in the school'

Grin

Exactly! And if saying that doesn't strike you as so very weird I can't help you.