How to choose the right collagen supplement for you
Purity and quality
Some low-grade collagen supplements may contain contaminants, such as mould or heavy metals like mercury, pesticides and other toxic substances. It’s always vital you check the label.
When choosing collagen supplements, consider the farming methods: for bovine sources, look for natural farming certifications like the Soil Association that limit pesticides and hormones, while for marine sources, opt for wild-caught fish over farmed varieties, as they typically have better nutrient profiles due to their natural diet and active lifestyle - unlike farmed fish which may face health issues from confined spaces and grain-based diets.
Source quality
Most collagen supplements are either bovine or marine-sourced, so it’s important to check whether these work with your dietary requirements. You may also want to consider the benefits of each collagen too. Type 1 like bovine and marine offer whole-body benefits to your skin, hair, nails, bones, gut and joints. Whereas Type 2 is designed for targeted joint support.
“You should always buy collagen, or any supplements, from a trusted source," shares Dr Daniel. "This could be your local pharmacy or supermarket even, but always avoid buying supplements from companies you’re not sure about, especially online.”
Dosage and form
Collagen supplements may come in powder, liquid or capsule form, so which one will work best for your daily life? Powdered supplements are popular as often it can be difficult to get the required amount of Type 1 collagen into a single capsule. Powders are easy to add to your morning smoothie or a bowl of porridge, too. That said, capsules are great for on the go.
“As for actual collagen supplements, aim for those labelled as ‘hydrolysed’ as they’re usually more easily digested," explains Dr Daniel, "and avoid any with any artificial sweeteners or anything else you’re not sure about. But before you start taking collagen, it might be worth checking that it’s safe to do so with your GP.”
What Mumsnet users say
"I've just started taking marine collagen last week. Big decision for me as I'm a vegan but while I can live with my perimeno thinning hair the joint pain was really affecting my life." henlake7
"I use Vital Proteins. Don't bother with the capsules, the difference in the amount of collagen in a capsule compared to a powder is massive!!!! I think I worked out I would need 20 capsules to match one scoop of the powder 🤣. I've read it can take 3 months of constantly taking it to notice a difference. I'm on month 2 and my skin feels clearer." xyz111
"I've suffered from significant hair loss for a few years and started taking both bovine collagen (powered) and marine collagen (capsules) around 4 months ago. My hairdresser commented last month that my hair was thicker, I'd not told her anything about the collagen so I guess it must be true that it's helped with some regrowth as opposed to wishful thinking on my part!" ShakeNvacStevens
"I take bovine collagen every morning (in a small fruit juice) and have been doing so for around a year. I'll be taking it for the rest of my life. My skin is in glowing. My hair is thick. And I put my body through a lot of abuse with my exercise regime, and don't have a single ache." PoppyBaxter
"I started taking the capsules a couple of years ago for fibromyalgia pain. It definitely helped. I didn’t notice it until I stopped and realised the pain was getting worse again. it definitely helped my face too, I’ve always been told I look young for my age but my flares were making me look so tired and worn out. I found the marine collagen helps me look less tired than I’m feeling at times." AliceMcK