If we're talking about intellectual heavyweights in politics, we're just about coming up to the 50th anniversary of the 1976 Labour Party leadership election. The candidates were:
- Jim Callaghan
- Michael Foot
- Roy Jenkins
- Tony Benn
- Denis Healey
- Tony Crosland
Compare that with the present day. Starmer is the most unpopular PM since polling began, and Labour can't shift him because they don't have a credible alternative. We just don't have a high quality of people in politics.
Now Rupert Lowe has a big following on X. I suspect much of his X following is American, and gained because Elon Musk likes the cut of his jib and retweets him.
(I don't know for sure if this is true, but there is a story that when Farage met Musk, Musk wanted guarantees for what a future Reform government would do for Musk's business, and Farage told him to do one.)
Rupert would not be the first politician to mistake popularity on X for popularity with voters. He seems to be locally popular in Great Yarmouth on the basis of being a good constituency MP. But, during his spat with Farage a year ago, when he was in the media every day, polling still showed that only 14% of voters, and only 29% of Reform voters, knew who he was when shown a picture of him. I'd say the idea that he is a lion of English nationalism with millions of voters just waiting to rally to his leadership is unproven.
Also, to the limited extent that there's a Connor Tomlinson demographic out there, appealing to those people is going to put off waaay more people than you attract.
You may not like Farage, but he's trying to appeal to normie voters. Look at this Matt Goodwin tweet - actually look at the comments beneath it - and it's very obvious that Lowe's online fanbase contains a very large number of open racists and antisemites. Lowe, under his own steam, is not really far right, but the Zoomerwaffen lads who have clustered around him want him to be the figurehead for something quite smelly.
It's the same problem you get with Corbyn, Sultana, Polanski - any political leader who sets themselves up as anti-system will attract the nutjobs. Farage, for all his faults, has been doing this for a long time and recognises the problem, and knows he has to gatekeep the nutjobs. Corbyn's people may also have learned that lesson to some extent. I'm not confident that Sultana or Polanski or Lowe will ever learn that lesson.