I have felt that I have been dragged back to about 2020 with the discussions I have been part of or seen in recent days. We have been told by many posters that their male friends with transgender identities fully respect female people and never use female single sex provisions. We have also heard from some of those male people with transgender identities where they have assured us of this.
Since about 2020, we have been told over and over again by transgender people, their support groups, their allies that not one of them believes they have changed sex and that no one is saying that they have. We were told this because women pointed out that there were some people who used that as a tool to prevent any discussion from moving forward.
Because how can solutions be found if a group simply ignored any law or guidance that used scientifically established language because they believed it applied to them when it materially did not.
That is what we have seen over the past few days. A resurgence of male people refusing to have any discussion about finding a solution that allows female people to have strong safeguarding and political recognition for their unique needs, by their use of female language for themselves.
Maybe this is a sign of the re-establishment of this purist style of extremism as the dominant discussion. It will not work as a movement though. Far too much has happened and publicly so.
Whereas pre-2020/21 there was still this erroneous belief that there were no issues at all, nothing to see here, no one who has read widely and seen the polling, court cases and the statistics can claim there are no issues. Women en masse are pointing out the issues now across numerous countries.
Perhaps these last few days have been the vanguard of the extremist group’s attempt to take over the discussion again?