Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Thread gallery
47
timenowplease · 07/10/2024 20:45

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 20:08

And then?
A paradox for me personally is the concerns about "capture" are the most strongly expressed today, whereas the threat from capture (Stonewall influence, self ID legislation etc) was greater in the past. Stonewall are a lame duck. Self ID is dead in the water. The Cass review has reduced the risk to teenagers.
Yet people like Truss are calling for the BBC to be defended and claiming the civil service is captured.

For me fact and fiction don't fully line up at the moment. What I observe in the arena of women's sex based rights is far less scary than it was. Yet the discourse has got more uncompromising and more insistent that there is some kind of emerging catastrophe.

When facts and rhetoric don't meet, that's when I start perceiving there to be a "culture war", where unfriendly actors (I.e. not people concerned about women and children) are using concerns for their own ends.

Unfortunately for me this trial looks like that. It's going to destroy the current incarnation of the Liberal party from what I can see. Who benefits from that? I doubt its going to be women and children in Australia - but it might be certain political factions and groups.

Unfortunately for me this trial looks like that. It's going to destroy the current incarnation of the Liberal party from what I can see.

Only those currently at the helm.

Are you forgetting about Moria Deeming? She'd make a fantastic leader of the Liberal party.

Snowypeaks · 07/10/2024 20:51

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 20:45

Unfortunately for me this trial looks like that. It's going to destroy the current incarnation of the Liberal party from what I can see.

Only those currently at the helm.

Are you forgetting about Moria Deeming? She'd make a fantastic leader of the Liberal party.

This is what I have been rooting for/predicting all along! 😄
She has come through fire and her strong character and fundamental decency has been revealed by it. I hope the Liberals of Victoria can see it.

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 20:53

Snowypeaks · 07/10/2024 20:51

This is what I have been rooting for/predicting all along! 😄
She has come through fire and her strong character and fundamental decency has been revealed by it. I hope the Liberals of Victoria can see it.

Absolutely. Her integrity shines through.

Filomene · 07/10/2024 21:13

Westea · 07/10/2024 09:08

@Filomene

And one is adapted from the other and cemented into the school curriculum. The grooming continues.

Well, no. What is your issue with Respectful Relationships, exactly?

Are you saying that Moira Deeming has no quibble with the current school RR curriculum. this thread isn't about me so don't try to make it about me.

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 21:14

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 20:45

Unfortunately for me this trial looks like that. It's going to destroy the current incarnation of the Liberal party from what I can see.

Only those currently at the helm.

Are you forgetting about Moria Deeming? She'd make a fantastic leader of the Liberal party.

😂
No, no she wouldn't. Single issue politicians can't gain enough support to challenge in elections, neither do politicians with views at either end of the political spectrum.

She's only useful if she's in government and that's not going to happen if her party swing further right.

Look at what happened to the Tories.

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 21:15

Filomene · 07/10/2024 21:13

Are you saying that Moira Deeming has no quibble with the current school RR curriculum. this thread isn't about me so don't try to make it about me.

You said about Respectful Relationships "the grooming continues". I'm also curious what you meant by that?

LongtailedTitmouse · 07/10/2024 21:17

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 21:14

😂
No, no she wouldn't. Single issue politicians can't gain enough support to challenge in elections, neither do politicians with views at either end of the political spectrum.

She's only useful if she's in government and that's not going to happen if her party swing further right.

Look at what happened to the Tories.

Why do you think her party couldn’t end up in government if they swing to the right? Have you not seen what has been happening to numerous countries with left-wing governments in the most recent polls?

And if we look what has happened to the Tories? They have lost votes to Reform on their right, not to Labour

Helleofabore · 07/10/2024 21:30

“Unfortunately for me this trial looks like that. It's going to destroy the current incarnation of the Liberal party from what I can see.”

This is an overly catastrophic statement.

This trial will not ‘destroy’ the current incarnation of the Liberal Party. It will likely force a removal of the leadership team in Victoria.

In Victoria only.

Australian political parties are quite regularly spilling leaders at state and national level. It doesn’t ‘destroy’ them. Because the factions have always been in the parties and they cycle through.

Having a change in leadership now will be wise to allow the new leader to settle in.

Considering one of the contenders this time around was beaten by one vote last time, it seems overly dramatic to suppose that he could not have the same degree of support at least this time around. I doubt any challenger would mount this challenge if they did not have confidence that one of them will beat Pesutto.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2024 21:36

Are you forgetting about Moria Deeming? She'd make a fantastic leader of the Liberal party.

I agree. She's brilliant.

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 21:49

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 21:14

😂
No, no she wouldn't. Single issue politicians can't gain enough support to challenge in elections, neither do politicians with views at either end of the political spectrum.

She's only useful if she's in government and that's not going to happen if her party swing further right.

Look at what happened to the Tories.

Lots of us got stick for being single issue voters in the UK GE. People couldn't understand why Keir Starmer's 'It should NEVER be said that only women have a cervix' and his inability to say what a woman was made him totally unsuitable to run a country. And so it's been proved. Corrupt, lacking integrity, economically backward and devoid of good ideas.

I'd prefer someone with moral fibre, integrity, intelligence and a genuine care for and interest in the welfare of her constituents any day of the week.

GailBlancheViola · 07/10/2024 22:08

LongtailedTitmouse · 07/10/2024 18:37

Enforce impartiality. Ban all lobbyists, charter marks, work place indices, lanyards, badges, flags of other countries, external trainers. Sack anyone who proposes actions that do not comply with the law - like suggesting men can use female spaces if they self ID or recording ‘gender ‘ instead of sex. Ban any civil servant from joining any political, lobbying or campaign organisation for two years after leaving the civil service. Or joining from such an organisation.

Sounds good to me and that should be across all publicly funded institutions - the NHS, the Police, schools, etc.

And the only flags that should be flown on any public owned building should be the flag of the UK and the flags of England, Scotland and Wales.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2024 22:13

Yes in the U.K., maybe not in Australia Grin

GailBlancheViola · 07/10/2024 22:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 07/10/2024 22:13

Yes in the U.K., maybe not in Australia Grin

😂

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 22:29

LongtailedTitmouse · 07/10/2024 21:17

Why do you think her party couldn’t end up in government if they swing to the right? Have you not seen what has been happening to numerous countries with left-wing governments in the most recent polls?

And if we look what has happened to the Tories? They have lost votes to Reform on their right, not to Labour

Edited

Which governments are you thinking of here?
Most of the ones I can think of that have "swung to the right" have then shat their pants and gone back to the centre. Possible exception being Italy.

I really doubt Moira Deeming could win an election. But luckily it will have a very limited impact on me if she does.

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 22:35

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 21:49

Lots of us got stick for being single issue voters in the UK GE. People couldn't understand why Keir Starmer's 'It should NEVER be said that only women have a cervix' and his inability to say what a woman was made him totally unsuitable to run a country. And so it's been proved. Corrupt, lacking integrity, economically backward and devoid of good ideas.

I'd prefer someone with moral fibre, integrity, intelligence and a genuine care for and interest in the welfare of her constituents any day of the week.

Edited

Sure. My point is the "single issue voters" aren't enough to win the election. Look what's happened here. We got Labour despite the stuff about not knowing what a woman is, and the most prominent GC Labour politician has gone independent. All the "single issue" campaigning made very little difference.

I'm sure it will be the same in Oz. Especially if Deeming is leader and is campaigning on "womens rights" whilst being anti-abortion and pro the Christian family set up. Most feminists aren't interested in that approach to "womens rights" (due to the fact it harms women more than it helps them) and most of the general public don't care enough to make it a voting issue.

In general the public don't vote for a divided party either so I doubt she'd do well. But we'll see. Maybe I'll be proved wrong.

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2024 22:49

CassieMaddox · 07/10/2024 22:35

Sure. My point is the "single issue voters" aren't enough to win the election. Look what's happened here. We got Labour despite the stuff about not knowing what a woman is, and the most prominent GC Labour politician has gone independent. All the "single issue" campaigning made very little difference.

I'm sure it will be the same in Oz. Especially if Deeming is leader and is campaigning on "womens rights" whilst being anti-abortion and pro the Christian family set up. Most feminists aren't interested in that approach to "womens rights" (due to the fact it harms women more than it helps them) and most of the general public don't care enough to make it a voting issue.

In general the public don't vote for a divided party either so I doubt she'd do well. But we'll see. Maybe I'll be proved wrong.

Moira Deeming has explicitly stated she would not campaign to change legislation on abortion. What do you mean by the Christian family set up?
Are you saying religious people have no place in politics?

Snowypeaks · 07/10/2024 22:54

I love the idea of MD as an opposition leader.
Basically everything that brought her to the attention of the now discredited liberal party leadership is what makes her a good candidate. I looked on her page on the parliament website and she has a clear political vision concerning the balance of government and individual rights and responsibilities which sits very naturally in a centre-right political space. She is socially liberal.
She has 4 kids and a SAHD as a husband.
She has a history of engagement with social issues.
Her campaigning for women's rights and child safeguarding would show the electorate that she passionately cares about something, without being an ideologue. As well as integrity, people look for humanity in their leaders.
Working class girl made good.
Extremely personable. Expresses herself well.
Young.
Has life experience extending beyond politics.

Star in the making.

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 23:22

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2024 22:49

Moira Deeming has explicitly stated she would not campaign to change legislation on abortion. What do you mean by the Christian family set up?
Are you saying religious people have no place in politics?

Moira Deeming has explicitly stated she would not campaign to change legislation on abortion.

Cassie's been told that a thousand times already. It doesn't seem to have landed yet.

Datun · 07/10/2024 23:30

Snowypeaks · 07/10/2024 22:54

I love the idea of MD as an opposition leader.
Basically everything that brought her to the attention of the now discredited liberal party leadership is what makes her a good candidate. I looked on her page on the parliament website and she has a clear political vision concerning the balance of government and individual rights and responsibilities which sits very naturally in a centre-right political space. She is socially liberal.
She has 4 kids and a SAHD as a husband.
She has a history of engagement with social issues.
Her campaigning for women's rights and child safeguarding would show the electorate that she passionately cares about something, without being an ideologue. As well as integrity, people look for humanity in their leaders.
Working class girl made good.
Extremely personable. Expresses herself well.
Young.
Has life experience extending beyond politics.

Star in the making.

Yeah, but for all those who have a hate fest for KJK, Deeming is forever tainted by her association with her.

And KJK is no doubt tainted by her association with Deeming. See how that works?

Despite everything they do for women (or probably because of it) they can both get written off simultaneously.

Imnobody4 · 07/10/2024 23:33

timenowplease · 07/10/2024 23:22

Moira Deeming has explicitly stated she would not campaign to change legislation on abortion.

Cassie's been told that a thousand times already. It doesn't seem to have landed yet.

Don't think it ever will but I don't like to give up.

Westea · 08/10/2024 00:38

@Filomene

Are you saying that Moira Deeming has no quibble with the current school RR curriculum. this thread isn't about me so don't try to make it about me.

I can't speak for Moira Deeming, but you said "the grooming continues," with regards to Respectful Relationships and I'm curious about that as RR is more about the reduction of violence and abuse, particularly towards women and girls.

Westea · 08/10/2024 00:40

@timenowplease

Are you forgetting about Moria Deeming? She'd make a fantastic leader of the Liberal party.

Perhaps in a few years, she might, but not just yet. In political years, she's still a rookie.

Westea · 08/10/2024 00:48

@Imnobody4

Are you saying religious people have no place in politics?

The previous Liberal Prime Minister of Australia, Scott Morrison, is a Christian evangelical. He didn't often allow his beliefs to seep into his work life, but when they did, it didn't go down well. Religion and politics shouldn't mix.

Filomene · 08/10/2024 01:03

Westea · 08/10/2024 00:38

@Filomene

Are you saying that Moira Deeming has no quibble with the current school RR curriculum. this thread isn't about me so don't try to make it about me.

I can't speak for Moira Deeming, but you said "the grooming continues," with regards to Respectful Relationships and I'm curious about that as RR is more about the reduction of violence and abuse, particularly towards women and girls.

https://stopgendereducation.au/state/victoria/vicrre/

Respectful Relationships (Vic)

https://stopgendereducation.au/state/victoria/vicrre

Filomene · 08/10/2024 02:26

Here's another one. Most parents don't know what is embedded in the fabric of these documents. They present gender identity and trans as if these are settled and widespread cultural norms when at the same time claim they are 'disrupting the cisheteronormative narrative'. The resources here is what cascades from passing on gender activism in schools hence why I call it 'grooming'. this is how grooming works - it hides the intent and proceeds with the unwitting's trust that the person in authority is well-intentioned (and young teachers were groomed into the ideology at university) but there is a parallel motivation in the background where the true damage is being done. These resources show how the grooming happens.
www.leaveourkidzalone.org/resources

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.