Tell me again how JKR is the baddie?

[DumbassHamsterSitterPerson]

Just saw this on threads. How is it ok. To wish someone dead? How is that being on "the right side of history"?
I disagree with lots of people on various things. I've never thought "I'd rather hear s/he is dead"

I don't understand the relevance of this point. JKR didn't write the play. JKR has said absolutely nothing (to my knowledge) about the play.

Are you saying that women should not point out the male body cues that allow us to identify the sex of a human?

Or if we are allowed to discuss those features, that we must limit it a number of people that you are comfortable with at a time? And never if they are doing something they are employed to do!

whether we agree with her or not, JKR has made some very poor decisions on social media and put people in danger. I can agree with some arguments, but i'll never think that this is acceptable

These days, instead of quote-tweeting someone that she’s responding to, she typically screenshots their tweet and removes their name, unless they’re a well-known figure. That means the original tweeter can’t easily be identified, and it’s less likely there will be a pile on.

It’s hardly her fault if thousands of her followers agree with something she’s written and want to make the same point to the original tweeter. She has never encouraged pile-ons, just expressed her opinion. But she actively tries to avoid doing anything that would lead to a pile-on.

I think she said she didn’t do that with the trans football manager because he had been tweeting at her for months; he wasn’t a random person who had tweeted something she wanted to respond to, so it was reasonable to respond to him by name. He’d been harassing her and clearly trying to provoke a response.

I think she writes a few novels now and then, funds a rape crisis centre for women and a charity who helps children all over the world.

Quite.

She's speaking on behalf of all the women punched down on.

And gets double standards of abuse when she points out the injustice.

I’ve read that review and I cannot see any evidence for what you’re claiming.

It contains a description of the trans character in the play and how the actor plays the role. It also contains descriptions of other characters and how they are played. It’s a review of a play, and the whole point is to critique the play, its plot and characters, and how the actors perform it.

In no way is this an attack on “a person at their place of work”.

And it is not “targeting and tarring all transwomen with the same brush”. It comments on one transwoman character, and does not in anyway claim this is representative of all transwomen.

You don’t get why she posted about this man? Link below to his tweets. If some man relentlessly trolled/bullied me on Twitter I’d be inclined to post about him too. So you pour scorn on JKR for calling a middle aged white bloke a middle aged white bloke (which he is) who has bullied JKR and other women, but not him for being the bully? Figures.

https://nitter.poast.org/galluslass/status/1789969437627392114#m

Police investigating JK Rowling death threat after trans activist urged Twitter users to send bomb | Daily Mail Online

It's interesting how people are often claiming on SM that JKR is putting TW at risk. It's DARVO in action right there.

And I’ll ask again @Christinapple like I’ve asked on other threads, can you show me any tweets from her about trans men? Is it trans people she has a problem it’s, or is it MEN?

But JKR is responsible for everything. She is responsible for everything everyone she has ever met has said. She's responsible for all the abuse of people she's never meet. She's responsible for global warming and the war in Gaza.

Cos that's how it works.

“Could you help me understand what was achieved when she kept posting snide nasty remarks about a trans football manager? Who happened to be happily married, supported by the team she manages and the other teams, and isn't a criminal?”

You mean the male person who has harassed JK Rowling for a long time before the tweet pointing out that appointing a male person as a manager for a female football team was no something that should be celebrated as an achievement?

That football manager?

The one who has called JK Rowling bigoted, hateful, transphobic amongst other accusations? The one who has a history of posting snide, nasty remarks aimed at JK Rowling and other women.

https://x.com/galluslass/status/1789969437627392114?s=46&t=HTxp6zC_d4GZ2FFv4a-YeQ

It is remarkable isn’t it? Once a poster has determined that one group is worthy of abuse for using the accurate sex description for a person what they will overlook.

”I saw the football manager got a lot of abuse from JK Rowling's followers”

The football manager, Lucy Clark, has had a long history of abusing women who reject that Clark is a woman. I don’t believe that JK Rowling needed to do anything for women to respond to defend themselves as a group or individually.

But again, we understand you don’t recognise or acknowledge male abuse or violence against female people if it is female people that you disagree with.

Thank you though. Because your posts about Clark keeps pointing out the abusive nature of these male people that you strive to defend.

I picture them frantically clicking their ruby slippers together....

Thank you

look at the language and phrasing used to describe the transwoman in the play.

Which wording, @HereforHealing ? Tall? Balding? Baf actor? Not loud enough to be hard at the back? Hats the stuff of theatre criticosm - I'm sure there's similar and worse being said about plenty of other actors at the Fringe. Balding might be a little mean, but as a sign of maleness it is pertinent in this instance.

As for retweeting someone wrh a small follower count, do you check the follower numbers of everyone you retweet? As a doctor commenting on a public forum about NHS policy he was inviting public discussion, and presumably wanted a wide audience.

Also that language has nothing to do with JKR so why are you holding her responsible?

🫠🫠🫠

Welcome to Australia.

I do wonder if the NHS doctor who received “abuse” may indeed have been Dr HArr0p? If so, I would suggest the poster do a little research into the abuse from a doctor to various women, as considered by the medical board/court.

Yeah? Nah! I hear you. It will get better though (I say with everything crossed).

She'll be taken to the cleaners for her transphobic bile and her victims will be awarded her full works and royalties. Mark my words.

Is this a pisstake 😂

I think it is a pipe dream.

1/10 Must try harder

For what crime?

Being an actual woman?

Shall we duck her or burn her at the stake?

This chap here? Not a nice fellow at all.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10262167/GP-likened-Rowling-Savile-doctor-accused-novelist-not-safe-kids.html

His prejudice seems to be clouding his judgement.