India Willoughby, Question Time Thu 2 Feb 2240

[Consufed]

India Willoughby is going to be on Question Time tonight. BBC1 10.40pm.

QT audiences are very carefully chosen to be representative of the population as a whole.

I wonder if anyone at the BBC will notice that there was a deafening silence after India's pronouncements and warm applause when others spoke against India's points...

I wonder if anyone else will notice, too.

It's always the terra nullis thing.

Women are things to a misogynist. Blank, empty little cyphers, and anything they think is obviously all about men (or babies), because what else is there for them to think about? And any space they have or resource they have is just wasted brownfield of no importance or relevance, much better taken over to be useful to men.

One of the rules of misogyny: if it isn't useful to men it's pointless (and men taking it over and doing something useful with it is a positive.)

This is what has always confused women about the ideology: how can men insist they are women and joining womenhood when there is no joining involved, no sisterhood or wish to be connected in any way. It isn't joining. It's commandeering and repurposing. Hence W's demonstration that they are a much better sort of woman than an actual one. By being a man inside a woman's appearance.

200 years and in essence we still have idiot males debating whether women have souls.

We need to stop calling men "she".

I agree Elsie.

Men being called she happens on mumsnet all the time. Initials or names are respectful of people without needing to use incorrect pronouns.

India could have an argument with themselves in an empty room and still be unable to put forward a convincing and coherent point of view.

Or witch.

Willoughby’s attempts to bring some reason into the debate were met with mocking shouts across the panel from Whelan and rapturous applause and hoots from a number of audience members. Bruce opened up the subject to the audience where Whelan’s supporters were represented in one particularly odious exchange between Willoughby and an older woman who had the contempt to look her directly in the eye and effectively state "you are still a man".

I couldn’t believe that this woman could morally justify such disdain to another human being, or that the panel chair simply allowed it to go unchallenged. All this happened among the continuous backing from particular gammon-coloured audience members.

interesting?? Article

Breaking 2323 News .

Archaelogists today uncovered the final resting place of an early 21st centuryperson called India Willoughby. To their surprise, since contemporary records indicate that India Willoughby declared themselves a woman complete with a cervix, the skeletal remains were clearly those of a man.

And even if women do have souls they should keep them to themselves and not show them to anyone outside of the home, nor discuss them in the workplace or on the internet.

Women definitely aren’t allowed to talk about having soul-based rights (or any other Women’s Rights) in the public square because that would be Unworthy Of Respect In A Democratic Society (UORIADS).

Right, Josh?

@NicolaSturgeonsSOGIbottom that gnatter side quest was fascinating. If it wouldn't be a complete derail I'd be going on about 'scuttle' for days.

I do have some pity for IW and some other high profile tw. Not much, because I know little about them. My pity is also tempered because some stuff they've done has been pretty vile and they seem as self centred as gyroscopes.

Earth to Nicola come in Nicola

Very funny though

It's like shifting sand . . .

Transvestite -> transwoman -> trans woman -> trans female.

Nope. Not having it!

I think Willoughby meant that women's prisons are not full of lovely ladies, rather they are full of rough types so a violent man would not be out of place.

Willoughby really is poisonous - tweeting Glasgow police about Posie’s forthcoming event.
twitter.com/IndiaWilloughby/status/1621435923132043271?cxt=HHwWjsC-hbTYv4AtAAAA

Sugarfree23 · Today 10:46

I thought she sounded American and him English but I'm not always the best at guessing accents.

I'm 99% sure that Mxx. Wokerthan-Woke is Canadian.

“I know the smell of bigotry”

**

@zen1 they (TRAs in general) do this constantly. Women's events attract masked "observers" who sidle up to the police and start trying to persuade them to arrest the speakers.

We need to focus on the trans part.
IW says they are a Trans person.
Transitioning meaning going from one to the other.
Therefore that person is actually acknowledging that they know the truth.
They are the original sex. In this case male trying to become a female.
So no matter how much surgery they have, clothing they wear, they know the truth.

Wee Josh might well know 'the smell of bigotry' but I can't help wondering how he fares when required to detect the aroma of bullshit.

I've never heard IW challenge anyone who describes them as trans. Yet IW also says 'I am a biological woman/female' - I heard this when IW was out of shot last night. I know I really shouldn't be surprised at this stage by such a lack of logic but I still am.

IW is a walking example of giving an inch and taking a mile.

I think Willoughby meant that women's prisons are not full of lovely ladies, rather they are full of rough types so a violent man would not be out of place.

Yes I think you're right, but why would Willoughby assume that people would think prisons were full of polite ladies, unless that was how they themselves picture the default woman? It's not a surprise to the rest of us that women also come in alternatives to the soft pink simpering variety that is Willoughby's standard, and are actual fully realised human beings, shaped by their own personalities, genes and experiences.

If it's women KJK is threatening to annihilate surely India's got nothing to worry about.