"a genuine person who is committed to full physical transition and who respects the women they identify with."
Do such people exist? How can such people exist?
In my experience of reading the words of and asking questions of TW online I see no evidence that any TW have a genuine sense of what it is to be a woman and a genuine feeling of affinity with "other" women. It seems to be a very much more personal thing "this is my perception of womanhood and I want to be a woman according to the terms of this personal perception. I am not saying I have anything in common with other women. Other women have nothing to do with my womanhood".
But even aside from the point that I don't believe (m)any respect women based on observaation, there is the more important question of whether it is even possible to respect women whilst identifying as one.
I see a disabled person in a wheelchair. I can vote for a party that is more committed to supporting disabled people to living full lives. I can try to treat that person exactly like I would anyone else, apart from making reasonable adjustments such as holding a door open when I might not do so for someone able-bodied, or getting them a special desk if I am their boss. I find it incredibly hard to see how I could show my respect whilst claiming to be disabled or whilst riding round in a wheelchair I don't need. I'm not sure that amputating my legs so that the wheelchair became necessary would prove my respect, in fact I can safely say it would be 100% disrespectful to do so.
I am increasingly coming to the view that for a trans woman to genuinely, 100% respect women, they need to accept that they are LARPing, accept that they have no right to female spaces and no right to forced language from others, and, finally, no right to share their desire to dress up as a parody of a woman in any place other than the privacy of their own home or in other private places with consenting adults.