Amy Hamm - Canadian Nurse being disciplined for being GC

[IcakethereforeIam]

I've not seen a thread on Amy on MN and the search didn't show up anything. She seems to be being put through the wringer by tras and by her nursing college.

I thought if she saw this thread it might be cheering , she's on twitter. I found her thanks to Bette.

quillette.com/2022/04/08/im-being-investigated-by-the-british-columbia-college-of-nurses-because-i-believe-biological-sex-is-real/

She's really going over and over this, desperate to get Any to say something that can be picked out as a quote for an 'Amy hamm is transphobic' headline.

Yes.

AH comparing a person who believes they have a GI to a person who believes they have a sole. Perfect analogy.

I wonder if the college are regretting using BF?

Crikey, so clutching at straws. Bf super loud today... but confused...so we are having another break. For goodness sake this is ridiculous.

'If someone else was to write an article about something that hasn't happened saying it provided something, would you change your mind?'

What answer could any reasonable person give other than, I don't know I'd need to read it and see what evidence and who had reviewed it.

This is great. bf has clearly never argued these points beyond her echo chamber before and thought it would be easy having it out with a hateful-bigot-TERF.

It is heartening to know that even in woke Canada, the legal system (in this case anyway) is not allowing a transbulldozing.

Maybe they struggled to find someone who would take the case on.

OK, in honour of your post, this is my new username 😂

BF seems to be fishing for a gotcha, but I'm not sure what that gotcha would be. Maybe BF doesn't know either.

And if someone says x is y, and b is zero...would you change your mind then? Amy saying she'd have to read the evidence and come to her own conclusion based on the evidence. But couldn't comment on a hypothetical..chefs kiss. Well done Amy.

I was desperate for religious comparator. So i was pleased she drew comparison here. I do not have religious faith and yet I am interested in, and supportive of, other people's religious beliefs.

Or even this

Impossible 'So i was pleased she drew comparison here. I do not have religious faith and yet I am interested in, and supportive of, other people's religious beliefs.'

Yes, me too.

Ooo - mention of Pritzker family.

Go Amy! You are doing well here.

BF - you will agree with me....

No, I wouldn't.

bf demanding that AH use trans women rather than trans identified male.

AH refusing to use the term trans woman rather than trans identified male.

She's trying to get Amy to state on record whether or not Transwomen are at risk in male spaces.

Amy is not an expert on criminal statistics for crimes against Trans women and not wanting to keep repeating myself but..........

ITS GOT FUCK ALL TO DO WITH THE CASE! The case is about whether or not Amy bought the college into dispute by posting on social media and linking it to her career.

bf asking for a ruling that AH has to use trans woman rather than as men/male

So, BF stop using 'cis' women then.

LB objects to compelling of language.

Good objection.

This will be outrageous if they compel her language.