Singing the problem isn't the HRA in itself being poorly drafted.
Where it fails is in enforcement - and this has been compounded by the justice system being decimated financially, particularly with regard to legal aid.
Legal aid is only available to a select few cases. But this excludes a huge percentage of the country who are unable to uphold their rights.
It means the cases that can be bought tend to be only 'pet causes' of lobby groups who fund, high profile cases where someone can make a professional name for themselves or donate legal skills or richer middle classes who can fund cases themselves. It doesn't therefore serve the most vulnerable adequately.
This is true of the entire criminal justice system - look at the report about enforcement of the Equality Act.
Human Rights enforcement is also not helped by a decline in the number of criminal lawyers available to defendants - with some areas now having none at all and others at risk of having none in a few years as they are aging and no one new coming into the field as its near impossible to make ends meet.
It explains the growing hostility to human rights in some communities as the law just isn't serving them. They don't have human rights because they can be exploited as they can't enforce them.
Talk of rewriting the human rights act alarms me, because it doesn't identify where the problem actually lies. It could do more harm.
It's the financing of the system that needs a good hard look at. It's notable we've had something like 7 Justice Ministers in 7 years. (I forget exactly what it is but the turnover and leadership is very much a problem).
We have what is now essentially a two tier justice system in the UK now.
Human Rights are about the vulnerable in society and unless they are aware that a) their rights gave been breeches b) have someone willing to serve their interests c) have the funding for their case, they are always going to lose out.
It requires understanding of this to protect our rights, but I think this is where the 'woke' really have missed the crucial point in younger age groups and this has been compounded with a middle class support for austerity in older groups.
I imagine there are probably similar issues elsewhere in the world.