It's taken me a long time to get back to this thread! (like, 2 years...)
I was @ARoomSomewhere back then
What @QOD said on thread p. 1 has been similar to my experience.
I went ahead and had roux en y surgery, June 2018.
I'd gone from 20st to 17st to qualify.
I dropped to 10st in 1st 12m but have bounced to 11st (old habits)
For me, i regret it as I have had a lot of problems with my nutrition.
My follow up was almost non existent. My dietician retired and was not replaced. I just get annual bloods which show I am severely deficient for iron, ferritin, B12 and Vit D still. I was fainting a lot, I lost my job, I feel exhausted every day, despite following all guidelines. My GP said I had lost too much too quickly. The local general surgeon (they sent me out of area for the BS but I cant see that surgeon again) said I should have had a sleeve as I am ,medically malnourished, but will not authorize ££ reversal of the surgery as I have healed correctly.
So, yes, it worked but yes I regret it.
I think I was unlucky though and would not dissuade others.
It is a hard road, but my BMI has dropped from about 42 to 26.
I am much safer re C-19, heart issues, cancer, all sorts of things.
I just feel about 90 now.