Everything you have written in the last couple pages I totally agree with, and I am at a loss as to why Casper is getting it in the neck.
Adam is a totally different ballgame as his attitude stinks, and has the moral compass of a gnat ( and that’s probably an insult on gnats) but Casper doesn’t fancy Emma for 2 main ( but major) reasons, and he is allowed to feel that, he is being upfront and not using her like shit lid did with Polly so I really don’t know what more he can do.
I am chubby but I go gym 5 days a week and I lift. God knows I love a gym rat but I do not find big bulky men attractive, I also would be put off by a man with a big gut ( and I say this as woman that doesn’t have a flat tummy)
Rather than a bulky man, I would actually prefer a man the same height as me and with a slight build ( I’m only 5ft3) but most women would be a bit put off dating a man that short/not find that attractive whereas that would not bother me in the slightest.
It is what it is, we can’t force ourselves to like what we don’t like, it doesn’t matter if he is a 4/10 or a 1/10, you like what you like and if that’s a petite woman ( or not curvy) then it is what it is. I don’t recall him saying she needs to be a 10/10 knockout stunner, he simply said attractive and his definition of attractive may be average looking to us, I personally don’t think any of the women on this year are particularly attractive with the exception of Richelle, but that’s just my opinion and many will disagree.
Casper shouldn’t force himself into being physically attracted to someone because he is average looking. Yes in the spirit of the “experiment” you should be open to getting out of your comfort zone but with Caspar maybe if she was Curvy but brunette and not essentially a double of his twin sister it may have worked but with I think there’s just too much for him to overlook.