GBBO

[willothewispa]

Who do you think will replace Sandi Toksvig ?

Joe lyset

Hugh Dennis

Liza Tarbuck would be brilliant

I hope it's not Rylan. He's everywhere atm and when he's on something I'm watching I can only focus on what his pampering regime must be, I'm not a fan of his look at all.

Would love VCM or Liza Tarbuck!

Liza Tarbuck would be fantastic - she's not on TV anywhere near enough!

Generally folks that do things on BBC don't do things on channel 4 so that would rule out quite a few like Claudia Victoria Coren Mitchell etc
And Sara Cox, I guess; I assume she doesn't do Pottery any more because it's now on C4. More's the pity.

I think Joe Lycett is shite and tries too hard. Really don't like him on the Sewing Bee.

Ooh ooh ooh – Katie Puckrik!
Funny, warm, original, slightly naughty, and not on telly or radio NEARLY enough.

Aisling Bea? Shes not British though. I think she's just quirky enough to work well with Noel.

Rylan would be as bad as Richard Ayoade - he is utterly gormless and comes across as dimmer than a 10 watt bulb.

GBBO needs someone intelligent and worry, who likes people and is good with them. Not some male barbie doll.

Good suggestion Katie Puckrick Parps!

Generally folks that do things on BBC don't do things on channel 4 so that would rule out quite a few like Claudia Victoria Coren Mitchell etc

It didn't rule out Sandi

I think Gary Barlow, because Gary Barlow and Sandi Toksvik are basically the same only one is Male and one is female!

I think it needs to be a woman or it will end up too testosterone heavy

The loud lady from nailed it?,......perhaps not but I think I would love her in an english show

Thanks SoftBlocks I might write to them

It didn't rule out Sandi
No, but she wasn't migrating from a similar BBC show like VCM or Claudia would, and like Sara C didn't.

Yes to Liza Tarbuck and Susan Calman.

Emma Willis? Zoe Ball ..... but personally I'm thinking Susan Calman would be great.

No to Zoe Ball, she always sounds on the verge of hysteria.

What about Dawn French? I reckon she would be a good laugh - and more than a match for Noel.

Jenny Eclair has the right name for it!

Ooh yes, Dawn French or Jennie Eclair, both would be great.

Jenni Eclair is another great shout!

I really dislike Jenny Eclair. It's not very rational but I don't like her manner. I think she comes over as pleased with herself.

Zoe Ball is a bit hyper, I think. Having said that, being on something where she has to stand and encourage people while they do methodical work might calm her down?

So - just seen it announced - Sandi's replacement is Matt Lucas.

What do we think?

I've just seen this too. I hadn't thought of him at all. It would have been good to have had a woman but he'll add to the comedy.

I just don't like him!