PLL - Who do you think A is?

[SuperBeagle]

I've been re-watching PLL, and I want to know your A theories.

Alternatively, who do you want to be A?

I know the person I suspect of being A is not the person I hope it will be.

Go, go, go!

from* Bloody hell I need to proof-read haha.

Hi everyone! I love PLL hence my username! If Emison and Spoby aren't endgame then I will never forgive I.M.K.

I think it's Lucas. Either him or some random characters we only met once 3 years ago. I've always wondered about creepy Andrew. I thought he was going to turn out to be the adopted sibling.

I'm going to need to rewatch I think. There is so much I've forgotten or blanked out due to complete ridiculousness.

I love Lucas but he certainly could be playing the long game. He has the money behind him and the way Alison treated him in HS was very cruel

Morning!

I'm up for a rewatch-and-pull-apart-each-episode. For the purpose of sisterhood of course!

Fab to wake up this morning and find I'm not the only one who thinks VH is suspicious...

VH wanted Alex and Spencer to split because Alex knew that Veronica had been for tests- she got wankered and spilled.

I had a thought yesterday (Stoke to London on the train, needed a distraction 😂). It was mentioned earlier in the thread that the latest season is so much darker than the earlier ones. I wonder- and feel free to take the piss, as I havea habit of overthinking things- whether MK has done a JK (Rowling) and the seasons have sort of "aged with the audience). The 14 year old who started watching season 1 will be 20 now, and is going to want to see more than four silly girls getting random texts and binging on cupcakes? And they're old enough for a few scares now. Would MK really be that sophisticated though?

One thing I like about pll, that I hated about gg, is that I can usually plug any plothole chucked at me with an answer.

Oh, and updated suspect list (thanks to some valid points made on this thread)

Veronica
Ezra
Spencer's twin- hereby renamed Waldo 😀
Lucas

Now it has been pointed out that the one who kidnapped Jenna may not be AD, the only people it COULDN'T be is

Jenna
Toby
Yvonne

I bet it ends up being someone like Caleb even though it would create a thousand plot holes. I hope not. I love Caleb.

Pop don't forget Melissa and/or Wren. She's the meanest.
Though she did bury a girl, who she thought was Ali, in trying to protect Spencer...

Ooh I'm in two minds about Emison. I do want them to be endgame but Ali has always manipulated Emily. The balance of power would have to change tremendously and Emily would really need to trust Ali. The baby storyline makes Ali vulnerable though so could facilitate that change.

I also read a rumour that there might be a musical episode given that all of them are real life singers (particularly Aria, Alison and Caleb). The noir episode was just brill so I hope they do do it.

Travelling I have a few of Lucy Hale's songs on my phone, and a few of Janel Parish's.

Oops...forgot about Melissa/Ween. With VH as an accomplice (still convinced).

Anyone up for a last rerun before April?

Oh, and if you want similar crappy tv, ai suggest "scream", which is just as dire but strangely addictive...

I'm going to rewatch pop. I feel like I've forgotten 90% of it.

Wren is definitely something to do with it. He's back in 7b, isn't he? Or am I imagining that?

All yeah there was a preview photo with Spencer, Ezra and Wren in a secret meeting in 7B...

AllTheBabies woohoo! When do we start?

I really don't trust Lucas. He always looked really shifty, suddenly became rich, then disappeared. I think there is more to his story

I really hope it's not Melissa. I like the idea that she acts the way she does to protect Spencer, even if it ruins their relationship and buggers up her life

I hate to give away spoilers, and ruin all your detective work, but I did that quiz....

I am starting to find Mike suspicious. It would answer why A started when Aria got back to Rosewood. I think I am just clutching at straws now!

I really hope it's not Melissa. I like the idea that she acts the way she does to protect Spencer, even if it ruins their relationship and buggers up her life

I think it'll either go one way or the other with Melissa. She certainly has the means and the intelligence to be A, but she's a conflicting character. I want to believe she's primarily protecting Spencer, but... I don't know.

Plus, she played a psycho in OTH and I can't move on from that haha!

Pineapple

Yeah my opinion of Melissa is still slightly influenced by 'Nurse' Carrie

She does evil so well.

S1 E3: Why is Toby hanging out in the locker room (when he punches Ben)?