PLL - Who do you think A is?

[SuperBeagle]

I've been re-watching PLL, and I want to know your A theories.

Alternatively, who do you want to be A?

I know the person I suspect of being A is not the person I hope it will be.

Go, go, go!

Tbh at this point it could be Nigel Farage and it wouldn't shock me. The producers are clearly making it up as they go along.

Agreed. And how did he find out so quickly who A (Shana) was? If the clues were there, either Spencer or Mona would have picked them up a long time ago.

The fact that he was shot sort of threw them/us off the Ezra trail.

Does anyone know where Nixole has actually been?

And I've spotted the real Sara Shepherd twice now, in two different roles...any I've missed?

It's killing me! I binged the whole lot on Netflix now I have to wait!!

Can I ask what age would you say this show is suitable for? DD keeps telling me EVERYBODY else watches it.

Interesting about Tanner!

Sara gets on my tits. I want to know what her deal is, and it makes me wonder whether it'll all lead back to Ali.

I'm actually watxhing Ezra yell at the girls over the accusations about Charlotte's death...looking at him in a whole new light now.

Who do we think killed Cece? My money is on Melissa, as a sort of double-double bluff (ie, she looks suspicious, so we think "nah, too obvious" then it turns out to be her)

The more I think about it the more I need it to be Ezra, like who goes out of their way to date highschool girls? A creep and clearly a psychopath murder.

No I dont think Sara Shepherd has been it in much, omg what if she is A?!

I say it's a show for 14yo girls, peculiar. My cousin who's 10 watches it. It's on a family channel in the US so pretty age appropriate for most 😊

apeculiar hmmm...well I'd be fine with my VERY mature 9yo watching it, but I think it's geared towards mid teens maybe? Oh...and us lot 😆

I'm still wondering who really killed Ian.

I forgot about Melissa!

Wait did we find out about Saras hands? I think she might be very involved even though no one likes shower Harvey

Superbeagle Marlene stated in a q&a session that Ian topped himself, but Mona faked thebsuicide note.

spongebob spot on, exactly why I don't waste much time trying to figure out who it will be.

peculiar the DVD's are rated at 12 which surprised me to be honest, I'd have thought they were a 15.

Ok she's just 12 so maybe I shall relax a bit then. It's just we have an awful lot of "everybody else is allowed to" at the moment!

Ahomy Emily punched Sara when shebwas revealed as the other Redcoat. She fell into an explodey thing and burnt them.

Pop call me a skeptic but I'm not buying it. What would his motivation be to do that and why wouldn't it be addressed in the show? I'm gonna start throwing flames at Marlene bloody King

I'm actually in the middle of designing a graph for a pll-inspired crochet blanket!

Pop That's awesome!!

Superbeagle it never crossed my mind that she would be lying! In that case, I'm going to disregard everything I've read about what she's said...including it not being one of the "five", and A being around since the beginning!

This is a whole new ballgame.

And I SERIOUSLY need a life...😀😀😀

FMR how gullible do I sound? 😆

Oh yeah Pop I forgot about the punch. Im stopping myself from watching them all again for the 3rd 11th time

So I just watched the season 7B promo and it looks like a girl taking down the hood...with dark hair. So Melissa??

She's made up so much stuff Pop She said that Cece's A would be someone there from the start and she said once that she wouldn't go for the trans thing. Lieeeees.

So I say anything goes

(I only know about Marlene's discrepancies bc I obsessively follow a couple of PLL tumblr accounts hahaha)

Superbeagle me too! It makes me giggle when I see posts about the third or fourth season, and how far off the theories were.

I know! Haha. At this point I've suspected just about everyone, including my own postman, of being A

How do we know it isn't really you? You may searxh the internet hourly to make sure that none of us are onto you...😆