Didnt Karen thank the Bollywood choreographer though? The judges didn't criticise that as such, it was the fact that it wasn't what the dance was meant to be.
Ed just throws himself into it 100%. He is going to fall down with the slower dances as he does look a bit Dad Dancing when he does those parts but the more frenetic parts he is fun to watch. He's not bad in the same way as, say, Scott Mills or Judy Murray was. I said it last season, it doesn't matter how the lower dancers are picked off, the right ones end up in the final weeks regardless. Until then, he can stay as far as I'm concerned.