I didn't like verticaloud, didn't mind the rose or the oud but it had a leathery quality that didn't work for me. I do like rose and oud in combo, my favourite being eldo nostos with MH scherzo a close second. I have a mizensir golden oud which despite the name is rose-oud, haven't tried it yet as it's on the 'to try' list tucked away in a drawer.
Byredo is quite a love hate house for me, and the house that got me into all this in the first place. I had just gone on to Mounjaro about october of last year and was into the beauty advent calendars, byredo was in everything and the mumbai noise dabber was in I think Harrods, and I fell in love with it and the rest is history. Since then I have sniffed and loved Mojave Ghost, Alto Astral and more recently was a fan of Animalique and Slow Dance. But Bal D'Afrique I find too sharp, and gypsy water is ok but extremely fleeting. Also not a fan of the super cedar or black saffron. I will continue to sniff away at the grand discovery set and report back!