Which denim jacket is nicer?

[Bumblebeeyouandme]

Which one do you all think is nicer?

https://www.newlook.com/uk/womens/clothing/coats-jackets/blue-faded-denim-shacket/p/919548445

https://www.zara.com/uk/en/z1975-denim-jacket-with-pockets-p00108021.html?v1=428596162&v2=2417748&ts=1747296269817

I prefer the Zara one. But I'm not "trendy" so probably the other one is more "in" 😂

I don’t really like either tbh. I would miss handwarmer pockets with a coat that length.

I don't like either of them. But I'm not the target market for this companies.

Not keen on either, but the Zara one looks a bit better.

I prefer the NL one. The zara one seems more "fussy" with the back pleats and curved hem.
But it depends on what you're after as the styles are quite different to each other.

I don't like the curved hem on the Zara one, the NL one is nicer overall.

But they are both odd shapes, I would tend to prefer a classic denim jacket.

I like the Zara one : )

I prefer the New Look one.

Be careful with new look. I bought a size 14 jacket from them and when it arrived it would have fitted a size 20 easily. It was not marketed as an oversize garment. After similar incidents I don't buy from them online any more.

The Zara one in dark blue. The beigey one is nice too.
The light blue ones aren't nice.
The whitish one would look grubby most of the time.

I like them both - they're quite similar.

Zara one wins out for me - I think the colour is probably slightly greyer, which I like. And is it a smidge shorter? But also like the curved hem, which adds more interest and the brass toned buttons instead of silver.

I had one in the early 80's. I'm not a fan of either but I would say they New Look one is nicer,the Zara one has some weird stuff going on with the hem.

the Zara curved hem says shirt not jacket.

New look is better

I prefer the New Look one, the Zara one looks a bit of an awkward length.

I have the NL one, it just arrived this morning. I’m really happy with it

Oh and I only paid £29.99 for it!

Zara one has less poofy sleeves which I prefer.

I don't like the curved hem on the Zara one but that's just me. What it would really boil down to is the quality of the denim and how "blotchy" the fade is and that's notoriously difficult to tell online.

aren't they the same? - oh not quite, the Zara is shorter with a curvy hem. I'm not keen on that, mainly because I think denim isn't the fabric for flouncy shapes, so I'd probably go for the other.

(but I am 55 and still think it's the 80s)

I don't like that style at all either. I'm behind the times, but I don't mind because mine is a classic style that never really goes out of fashion.

I much prefer the Zara one - I think the NL one is too long.

I prefer the NL one, not sure why and it isn’t somewhere I usually shop

The NL one for me! I’m now tempted to order it and see it it will suit me! @TickleMyPickle is it true to size?

Honestly neither, I'm not a fan of the oversized, shapeless look but at a push, zara.

Thanks for saying 'nicer' rather than 'nicest'. 😀

<misses point>