Help! Which Chelsea boots shall I send back?

[postingfortraffichere]

I already have black dr martens so I guess I bought these Chelsea boots to wear for work in very cold winter days and also for evenings and shopping trips when you want to look casual but with a hint of smart.

I love both - but feel silly keeping both as they're very similar. The one with brown stripe I feel adds a more casual vibe - but I like the tall length of the dune ones I think maybe they're more on trend?

Which do you prefer?

Number 1 (dune)

Or number 2 (from schuh)

@Lovemusic33 I have (stupidly) decided to keep both! The brown stripe ones will be for work - the chunky ones for play (until the go out of fashion 🤣)

1