Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!

999 replies

Experiment627 · 07/09/2021 19:27

New thread!!!!

Sorry I did not see the other thread getting full!!! Really hope you guys will find this new thread!!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
119
FluffyWhiteBird · 01/12/2021 00:58

One empty. Garnier Organics Lavandin Night Cream. It's nice but I prefer Olay because that's richer for my dry skin.

CherryMargo · 01/12/2021 21:37

Hi all,

Below is a report on my annual once-a-year skincare & beauty haul.

In accordance with my last year’s decision, I gave myself only three weeks in October to do research on the products I was interested in, and to decide which of them I want to add to my wish list for November 📝

Having a comprehensive stash inventory at hand (I use Excel) and saving enough money in advance were two crucial steps that I took to prepare myself for a month-long shopping spree. Another significant source of data was my participation in the Project Pan for three consecutive years (2019 – 2021). Tracking of my product usage has helped me gather data on the average yearly consumption of every single product category in my stash, and it helped me plan my November shopping list.

As a result, in November 2021 I purchased 16 products (13 full-size and 3 minis), and received 8 deluxe samples and 7 foil sachets as GWP 🛒 I also bought 1 item for my tools and accessories stash.

Moving forward, I will stick to my three-week shopping list preparation in October, but will no longer participate in the Project Pan unless my skincare/hair/body/makeup routines change drastically resulting in a significant impact on my yearly product consumption level.

As for November empties, I only had two:

  1. Dr Dennis Gross Advanced Retinol + Ferulic Texture Renewal Serum (1.5 ml; GWP) – a transparent watery gel with an intense ferulic acid scent (i.e. it smells like hot dog water). I didn’t like the uncomfortable tightening sensation after application. The serum contains adenosine which is a central nervous system depressant, and is used in skincare products to reduce the depth of wrinkles. I usually avoid this ingredient in the skincare products, because prolonged use may result in overrelaxation and subsequent sagginess of skin. The RRP of this serum is £74 per 30 ml, and I doubt this product is worth it.

  2. Dr Barbara Sturm Enzyme Cleanser (1 g; GWP) – I must say I was wary about using this product due to talc being its main ingredient. However, the result blew me away, and I purchased a full-size product last week (it was on sale for 25% off). The cleanser is made of talc powder with a tiny amount of enzymes (subtilisin and lipase, to be precise) which you have to mix with water in the palm of your hand. It can be a bit messy before you figure out the right proportion of water and powder. The powder never fully dissolves either. What I liked about this cleanser though was that I saw the results on the very first day – it removed my dead skin cells better than any acid / scrub I had ever had before, my skin looked polished and became completely unclogged. But and this is a big ‘but’, it severely dehydrated my skin after four days of daily use, so I wouldn’t recommend using it more than two times a week even if your skin is very oily.

Experiment627 · 01/12/2021 22:00

@CherryMargo it sounds like you enjoy yoir October planning & get real JOY from the November spree 😍
I love the sound of the cleanser - must keep it in mind

OP posts:
Ponks · 01/12/2021 22:29

@CherryMargo that's amazing restraint to purchase only in November!

latedecember1963 · 02/12/2021 08:39

That's an impressive system, CherryMargo, and I bet it stops you spending money on impulse buys which has been my downfall over the years.
5 more items to ditch.
The lemongrass shower gel isn't as nice as the lavender version so I won't be repurchasing.
The face mask was a freebie from a BS consultant. It was pleasant enough but not something I'd buy.
The Nuxe oil and Abu Cleve products were from M and S and QVC beauty boxes. The Nuxe smelt lovely and I used it to soothe my cuticles but neither product are ones I would buy, especially as the Nuxe lasts ages and usually appears in M and S offerings.
The Fearne Cotton lotion had a really uplifting scent. I might repurchase after Christmas if it's in the Boots sale.

Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
Justilou1 · 03/12/2021 15:40

@CherryMargo - you’re going to think I only use Korean and Japanese skincare, (I MOSTLY do, but not exclusively, I promise!!!) You can buy much cheaper enzyme powder washes from them!!! I would say that anything Barbara Sturm sells lives up to her initials when you look at value for money.
Good examples:

www.skincity.com/uk/by-wishtrend/green-tea-and-enzyme-powder-wash-70-gram-1

www.dermstore.com/babor-cleansing-enzyme-cleanser-75g/11724025.html?AID=13716219&PID=4441350&URL=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dermstore.com%2Fproduct_Cleansing%2BCP%2BEnzyme%2BCleanser_52858.htm&affil=cj&utm_source=cj-

4441350&utmmedium=affiliate&cjevent=24f36b21544f11ec814601940a1c0e14&utmcampaign=CJ&pubname=rewardStyle&utm_content=rewardStyle&cjdata=MXxOfDB8WXww

Ponks · 03/12/2021 22:47

A few empties:

  • Ouai Detox shampoo, this is very good, does the job and smells lovely but is pricey. Would repurchase but not till I get the shampoo stash down a bit.
  • Prai neck cream, ah the old favourite although lately it's been pilling a bit. Will undoubtedly repurchase but for the next month or so I'm using up other moisturisers on my neck!
  • mini of Ultra Violette lean screen spf, they did a really good sample set of 4 different sunscreens for £20 earlier this year, each lasted for ages and the pack included a voucher for £10 off the next purchase, what a good deal. I think my favourite was the Supreme Screen (which I've just repurchased) but this one was a close second.

Just checked my bathroom cupboard and I have a ridiculous number of moisturisers, I really do need to go on a no buy month or two after Christmas.

CherryMargo · 03/12/2021 22:49

@Justilou1 I’ve never tried enzyme cleansers before, and I’ve never heard of the Skincity and Dermstore websites before either, so thank you for letting me know about these websites and products 🙏

It was shocking to see that the Babor cleanser’s ingredients are identical to the Barbara Sturm’s cleanser but it is 50% cheaper, so I will purchase it when I use the BS cleanser up. Until then I will try and take comfort from the fact that at least I paid £32.50 instead of £50 for the BS cleanser deep sigh

Experiment627 · 03/12/2021 23:50

I have been trying out an Enzyme cleanser recently.... from.... wait for it... Superdrug!!!! 🤣🤣🤣 I really do have a thing for budget beauty!

OP posts:
FluffyWhiteBird · 04/12/2021 14:00

One empty . No.7 concealer. Does the job. Lasted for 1000 years or something, long enough that I can't remember buying it and the labels/writing wore off ages ago. I remember using it when I house shared with a friend, that was 14yrs ago. I know, I'm disgusting.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 04/12/2021 14:57

So I've not been here for a while but I joined these threads at the start of the first lockdown and since then I've managed to work through so many things I'm down to just having a single draw of beauty products.

I've stopped saving things 'for best' after realising I had hoarded some Clarins products for 10 years and they were no longer any good!

I've stopped buying bits and bobs every time I'm in the shops, I still try new things but its a lot more conscious.

If something doesn't work for me, I give it away or chuck it. No point keeping it if its not useful.

Anyway I'm back as I have an advent calendar and a few boots purchases which have added to my stash. I've already found an amazing new product (EH cleansing balm) through the calendar so totally worth it, but I need you guys to keep me on the straight and narrow :)

Experiment627 · 04/12/2021 15:11

@LivingDeadGirlUK lovely to have you back! Wow! It sounds like you are nearly cured!!!

Two empties to report:

  • Sainsburys hydrating cream (hand cream): this was fine; cheap as chips but not a patch on the CeraVe and La Roche Posay ones I also have on the go
  • Loreal Preference 3 shine protect conditioner: last one of stash!!! And no more to come as I don't use this hair dye anymore. It is ok except for stench.
OP posts:
Justilou1 · 05/12/2021 00:17

@Experiment627 I honestly think that there is ALWAYS an equal or even or better drugstore alternative to the super-hyped or celebline products with matching prices. Despite what we are led to believe, there really are only so many actives out there, it’s just a matter of what works for you. What’s “new” these days is mostly packaging and scent. (Even the fragrances in skincare lines are samey these days too. People like what they like.)
Tbh, even some traditional drugstore lines are catching up in price. The reason I go for the J&K lines is A) simple, high-tech formulations that are not full of fragrance. B) 5-10x amount of product for same price. C) Prefer sunscreens from here. (Newer research - Australia seems to have become stuck in their ways since Govt owns interest in company that owns patents for most of the chemicals that are required in Aust. Safety standards. Also used in J&K sunscreens, but their newer ingredients “still under review for efficacy” here, despite having been passed for safety reviews in their own countries, Europe & USA, and other independent labs. I’m happy that they have been thoroughly tested.)

Babysharkdoodoodood · 05/12/2021 00:57

[quote CherryMargo]@Justilou1 I’ve never tried enzyme cleansers before, and I’ve never heard of the Skincity and Dermstore websites before either, so thank you for letting me know about these websites and products 🙏

It was shocking to see that the Babor cleanser’s ingredients are identical to the Barbara Sturm’s cleanser but it is 50% cheaper, so I will purchase it when I use the BS cleanser up. Until then I will try and take comfort from the fact that at least I paid £32.50 instead of £50 for the BS cleanser deep sigh[/quote]

Allbeauty has the Babor for £22.40

Experiment627 · 05/12/2021 02:19

@Justilou1 really good point about the actives. Also it is like with food - iften the very same factory is producing the reknown and cheapy lines. I recently started using the Superdrug B. Melting cleansing balm - which is a deadringeebfor the Clinique Take the day off... only its cost me around £4 rather than £24!

But I do mix it up - it is actually a question of what do I like/what "works". I gave recently being going for more "higher end" shampoos to help tackle my oily roots and have been pleasantly surprised by what I have found.

I got a few Liz Earle products in my first advent - the cleanser, a tonic and an eye thing. Any other ones I should try?

OP posts:
WellTidy · 05/12/2021 17:46

Also agree about the actives. A year or so ago I went back to my tried and tested Estée Lauder skincare products, which they’ve been making for years. I’d tarted myself across all the brands, bottom and top end, and realised that actually I like what I’ve always liked and just went back to it. Doesn’t stop me trying out different masks, and all the body stuff, but I’m largely not looking for new face products anymore. Stash still, ahem, plentiful, nonetheless!

LivingDeadGirlUK · 05/12/2021 18:09

I think I've said this before on a similar thread but my holy grail used to be Simple moisturiser but I spent a bit of time trying others and when I came back to it my god it felt so greasy and horrible. I'm a Pure convert now, which is more expensive but seems to work so much better for me.

Justilou1 · 05/12/2021 23:39

@WellTidy - given that I’m preaching “Do your research and buy the cheaper things!” You should see how huge my stash is! You can assume I haven’t saved much money, rather that I have used it as an excuse to buy more things. That’s gotta stop!

Ponks · 06/12/2021 08:40

Finished Murad Rapid Dark Spot Correcting Serum. This is really good, I have some pigmentation patches on my face and I'm positive this has lightened them. It's lasted ages too, over 5 months of almost daily use. Will repurchase in future but trying Paula's Choice serum now, which is much cheaper.

Also had to say goodbye to my Lumene curl mascara from last years advent calendar. This was a really good basic mascara, I would rebuy but can't find it online.

MidnightMeltdown · 06/12/2021 16:54

Forgot to post my empties update last week:

Eve Lom Gel Balm Cleanser - this is an excellent cleanser. Does a great job of removing makeup and skin feels very clean after. However, I'm not keen on the smell (or the price!), so probably wouldn't buy it.

Susanne Kaufmann Moisturising Mask - very nice face mask with lovely delicate scent. I don't feel that I need this product in addition to regular moisturiser though, and I haven't noticed any lasting effects so I probably wouldn't buy it. Might be good for someone with very dry skin.

Barefaced Anti Blemish Moisturiser - I bought this to use at certain times of the month when my skin can get congested, as it contains salicylic acid. It's excellent. Very moisturising, but doesn't clog pores, and it's inexpensive. I have a lot of moisturisers to get through atm, but will repurchase this at some point.

Noble Isle Rhubarb Rhubarb shower gel - lovely scent which lingers for quite a while. Enjoyed using it.

Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
MidnightMeltdown · 06/12/2021 18:26

I also agree re. the active ingredients. Most of the ingredients that go into beauty products are extremely cheap, and with higher end products you are often just paying for the advertising and the packaging. I've found a few fabulous high end HG products in beauty calendars and beauty boxes, but also many items that really aren't much better than far cheaper drugstore brands.

That said, I have read that some cheaper products that claim to have the same active ingredients as higher end products, only have the active ingredients in very small quantities, mixed with a lot of 'filler' substances.

I've never tried J & K but really want to as I've heard lots of good things. Need to use up some of the stash first though!!

PomRuns · 08/12/2021 12:37

Finally some empties, although I have a huge influx of products too..
with AC and a Liberty set.

Rituals - Jung shower oil. Not keen on the oiliness, not much fragrance wither.

Argan - 5 oil shampoo. Love this, feels very gentle.

Also binned a Margaret Dabbs cuticle cream and a Skin lip balm as they smelt a bit off - think 2-3 years old.

Will catch up on thread later - crazy busy. Hope all well and everyone enjoying Christmas build up.

latedecember1963 · 08/12/2021 19:46

Confession time for me. A while back there was an EL collection for £69 but the qualifying spend was quite a lot and the list of products to choose from were things I could live without so I didn't buy even though I liked the set of products.
This week I got an email from EL saying I could get the collection for £69 but with no extra spend needed. My mum always gives me birthday money so that's what I've spent it on.
It had arrived when I got in from work this evening and it's gorgeous and has several of my favourite EL products. So glad I resisted the Boots showstopper because I wouldn't have got the EL one if I had.

Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
PomRuns · 08/12/2021 20:07

Wowsers that’s looks brilliant @latedecember1963
Enjoy !

supadupapupascupa · 08/12/2021 20:57

I've saved quite a few for you!

Kiehls creme de corps
Smells nice but to be honest it was messy and i prefer a cream
*
Goldfaden md Bright eyes dark circle radiance *
I'm going to RP on this because I think this actually might work! Too small to know for sure and didn't take before and after photos

Origins ginzing serum
Defo RP! I loved this. Smelled amazing and I prefer the cream consistency over the oil in my previous fav vitc medik8 oil

Estée Lauder modern muse Edt
I love this so much I've already RP.

Estée Lauder beautiful magnolia edt
Meh. I've got better perfumes won't RP

Manson Matine not sure which this was
But it wasn't a favourite

Body shop tea tree body butter
Smelled off so I binned. I do like their body butters though.

Umberto giannini shampoo
Nope. Hair still doesn't like shampoo. Better washed in conditioner only.

Gallinee soothing cleansing cream fir scalp
Passing this on. I can't get anywhere near my scalp as my hair absorbs it before it gets there! Rubbish. For me anyway.

Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
Beauty addicts anonymous! A wonderful community of hoarders!
Swipe left for the next trending thread