Loving all the appreciation for bitter green/earthy scents! A section of perfumes I don't often see getting a lot of attention. Don't have much to add to all the wonderful suggestions here, except:
- Clinique Aromatics Elixir (not strictly a green scent, but so complex and rich, and definitely has green facets, at least to me)
And for those who don't mind men's scents:
- Aramis Devin (Bitter green opening, spicy carnation/hyacinth/earthy heart, quite animalic at times)
- Original Dior Eau Sauvage edp (Lemony opening, herbal green middle - like a Neal's Yard shop!)
@Artdecolover Avon Timeless looks right up my street! (Amber? Chypre? Powder? Yes, please! 😁) I find powdery scents so comforting. Am on a strict no perfume buying month currently (except samples, they don't count, right?), but will definitely have to try this soon, especially as it's such good value. Mention anything Youth Dew (😍) and I always sit up straighter. I have many favourite fragrances, but this one holds a special place in my heart. It is what originally sent me down this wonderfully perfumed rabbit hole. Amber Nude looks amazing!
Your enthusiasm for 4160 shazam is infectious. I having been reading reviews on fragrantica and this does look wonderful.
@MissBattleaxe Thank you for all your wonderful suggestions. What an amazing list of things I now have to try, I've been eagerly googling all evening and we must have very similar taste. I already had my eye on Papillon because I've been meaning to get a sample of Bengale Rouge, I'll get a sample of Dryad too. Reviews mentioned the dry down of BR smelled like a mix of Shalimar and Opium, and after that I couldn't ignore it. I love any fragrance from Estée Lauder. (Seriously, they could bring out bathroom cleaner and I would happily wear it) Dana Tabu has long been a favourite, and you've prompted me get a bottle next time I'm in the chemist's. I have never smelled Dune, and after looking on fragrantica, I need to rectify this immediately! Will definitely sniff next time I pass a department store .
@Fferny1 Great minds think alike! 
Finally, can I just say this thread is the nicest place on the internet. I've found my happy place. ❤️
P. S. Sorry for the long post! I didn't realise until I pressed preview. 