SOTD Heeley Cardinal (my new samples arrived today, treat to myself!) I really like it, but it's surprisingly not as church-y as I anticipated? It's definitely fresher and there's something almost aniseed-y to it. I'm very fond of Phaedon Oliban but it makes me smell like an actual damp medieval church, so this is probably a bit more wearable.
I also have Le Liturgie Des Heures to test, so I might try that one tomorrow