Shrill, well done on the Black Opium! I could never see what the fuss was about in this one, until one day I “got” the coffee. Now I really love it and have worn it for years.
I’ve tried a few of the Penhaligons, through their sampling service. They are marmite fragrances, I find, and I think you definitely need to try before buying. I loved, and bought, a sale bottle of Vaara, which is a sweet and spicy feminine fragrance. I tested Opus and bought a bottle for DH. It is light, refined and gentlemanly and I get whiffs of it when we go for a walk 😊. I would happily wear this and do often have a quick spray.
Elisabethan Rose is a perfectly pleasant rose. It has a lot of fans but I think is a bit ordinary for the price. Bluebell is just a chemical mish-mash, to my nose.