Are these nice or hideous?

[PinkPonyTail]

these

For wearing with dresses and winter clothes?

Clearly I’m not feeling decisive!

I think the zips are putting me off. Agree with PP that jeans would work better. Dresses need a bit more chunk in the sole to offset, or something smaller. These are a bit of a halfway house. In my opinion, anyway. They'd look weird on me coz I have big calves so I might be biased on that front.

I LOVE them. Might order some myself...

I like them!

Nasty old lady boots

No

Skirts / dresses no .....jeans yes

Just looked on the site and I love the Chelsea boots

I really like the general idea of them, just not keen on the zips for some reason

They are really terrible.

I like them

Nice

I like them

At a push they’re ok to wear with jeans for a walk in a functional sort of way but they’d look hideous with dresses.

Sorry OP, hideous!

They are awful - but there are some v nice boots elsewhere on the site. The cream doc martin-a-likes for instance.

My DM would love them, but she is almost 80. I don't like them at all.

I’d like with skinny or roll up jeans but not for skirts / dress

Not my taste at all, but I wouldn’t look twice if you were wearing them with casual trousers. They look pretty comfortable.

I can’t imagine them looking at all nice with a dress.

I'm all for comfort but everything about them is a bit wrong.

Some people could make them work. I couldn't. They do look comfortable.

No just no.

I like them too!

They could look ok with jeans, but definitely not a dress, and I wear flat boots with dresses. Only Chelsea boots though.

frumpy.... it would be a no from me but probably very comfy

I like the concept - flat hiker-style boots - but they look a strange shape somehow.

They're in the same vein as my Fly Malu boots here

Which I wear with rolled up jeans and also with dresses.