What do you think of this jumper?

[Cherrypie098]

www.johnlewis.com/joules-vanna-kimono-sleeve-jumper/blue-marl/p4895260?searchTerm=Vanna%20kimono%20jumper

I would wear it with skinny jeans. What draws me to it is that I love the colour and it doesn’t contain wool, to which I’m allergic. My hesitation is that I’m 41, and at this age I wonder whether it would look ageing? On a woman in her 20s it would not, but at this age I’m not sure!

I think its lovely and suitable for a woman of any age

Definitely fine for any age. I love the colour and sleeves

Lovely colour and defo fine at any age!

Absolutely lovely!

It's gorgeous. I'm now wondering if I can afford the oat colour

Nice jumper!

Im 43 and i wouldnt wear that. Looks very frumpy imo sorry op

It does look to me a bit like a jumper you’d buy to hide your shape.

It's fine - I wouldn't wear it because roll-necks do nothing for me, but if it's your bag, go for it. Those oversized jumpers with voluminous sleeves are all over the high street at the moment.

I like the way it looks but wide sleeves are annoying IME.

25 and wouldn't wear it outside of the house.
It's frumpy and looks like it's for an old person. Sorry.

I think it is lovely and would buy it - I am your age, OP!

Only if you’re slim. If you’re wide round the bum / hips you’ll look massive (speaking from experience of similar sleeves!)

I like it

I think it's beautiful & suitable for any age.

Old person jumper , think I'll get it

Dull.

Love it!

The sleeves, neck and length are all ageing.

I really like it though it would not be warm enough for me - more of a thick top I think? Unless you wear another layer underneath? Not that you asked about that! I'm in my 40's and I'd wear it. I wonder if the people considering it old are actually a generation younger?

I really hate it. It looks like something for an overweight 70-year old trying to hide her lumps and bumps. There is absolutely no risk whatsoever that you'd see a 20-something in this.

It's dull and looks like something you'd get off a market for £3.99, not £60

Thank you so much for the replies, everyone! Very interesting to read the different opinions! If I wore it, I would wear a white long-sleeved top underneath in cooler weather.

(I’m size 8 and 5’7”, btw, if that makes any difference.)

If you’re size 8 and 5,7 you should be showing off that fab figure, not hiding it under a frumpy tent-like garment I totally agree with PP who say it’s dull/shapeless - you can do way better!

Aw, thanks! :)

The sleeves are a bit too wizardy for me.