Are these really bad??

[Th1me]

me and my daughter disagree!!

Not keen sorry.

Hideous. Sorry, but they really are. Pantomime Dame shoes.

They are horrendous

Thanks - I said really bad, 16 year old dd loves them!

They remind me of Irish dancing shoes. Maybe the pose is also contributing to that!

I’m not keen either.

Is it 1840? Sorry unless you're a goth it's a no from me.

No self respecting goth would have been seen in these

Really not a fan!

Thanks - am definitely winning this one!

Theyre a bit steam punk? I quite like them

Child catcher shoes!

Not a fan, they don’t know what they are!

Awful like witches shoes

Not my cup of tea, and my similar age dd lives in Vans and wouldn't look twice at them, however your DD loves them and she's the one wearing them so that's that, really.

I really like them! I might need to have a word with myself based on the responses above.

She won’t have anything like Vans or trainers. Leads towards the goth look. We are looking for boots for her for Christmas and she has come up with these!!

Leads - leans

I think they’ll look great on a 16 year old who knows her own tastes!

are they a bit steam punk?

Love them.

For me as a 36yo mother - hideous.

For a 16 year old who loves them. Go for it!

Way too Mary Poppins for me!

Going against the grain, I love them
I would definitely wear them, And I am 46

Good for fancy costume (ONLY!}

Sorry I would definitely wear