These M&S boots?

[MrsHoneybadger]

https://www.marksandspencer.com/block-heel-square-toe-chelsea-boots/p/clp60189525?image=SD01T025935AY0XEC_90&color=BLACK&prevPage=srp

I can't decide if these are stylish or not? I am a pretty young looking 39 year old, and want something I can wear with skinny jeans and skirts for smart casual at work and at the weekend. I am specifically looking for non-leather boots so these got a tick.

I don’t think so, sorry. They look very safe and don’t really commit to a look if you know what I mean

They are pretty bland but most of us need plenty of bland things in our wardrobe. Not objectionable (although I personally do not like the heel one little bit). Wouldn’t even notice the heel if someone was wearing them though.

I think they are quite nice, would work well with skinny jeans, I'd not wear them with skirts though, Would be a bit frumpy.

I think the are quite 'fashionable' at the moment, asos is full of similar ones. But also they do look a bit frumpy but that's because frumpy and clunky is 'in' just now.

My mum has referred o a few people recently as 'a poor looking soul' not realising that they are on the cutting edge of trend, their clothes are band new and they have spent a lot to look to look that way!

Both classic and stylish although not with skirts.

Hmmmm... maybe I will keep looking!

I think they are quite frumpy looking but can't quite work out why, maybe the heel. I think you could find something similar but more stylish.

I'm torn. I think others are right it's the heel. Maybe something a little higher up the ankle. Mind you, go with what you like. Don't worry about what anyone else thinks

I am after black boots, preferably non-leather (I prefer the look and feel of leather but am trying to stay true to my vegan ethics), need to come in a 4.5 size, and comfortable enough to wear all day. I want to wear them with skinnies and knee length swing dresses and midi dresses. Not sure where to begin if anyone has any ideas I'm all ears!

How about these New Look ones? Not in a half size but I can use insoles if need be:

www.newlook.com/uk/womens/footwear/boots/black-leather-look-chunky-chelsea-boots-/p/630598101

Smart for work but sorry to say boring and bland for out of work. But then again I wear outlandish footwear so what do I know!!!

I've definitely discounted the M&S ones and am tempted by the chunkier New Look ones.

Tesco might be worth a look. I got some fab ones in there last year.

New look shoes are terrible quality in my experience.

I’m sorry but these are boring as hell. A safe choice but perhaps that what you want. If you want to wear with skirts though I’d consider something with more panache.

New Look ones are rotten. M&S ones are fine, perfectly functional and inoffensive for every day wear.

I got a pair of flat black suede boots in New Look last year and they were so comfy.

Try asos, I'm not overly keen on these, it's the toe bit and stitch down the front

Heavenly feet have some IMO cool boots, they are also vegan.

No.

I wear ordinary jodphur boots with everything. They are comfortable, go with dresses or jeans and I can ride a horse in them.

Win win.

My Mum in her 80s would wear the M&s ones , I just don't like the style ,some would say classic others would say frumpy . Sorry

No.

1. The heel is a bit splayed and ‘off’.
2. Boycott M&S because they have no respect for their core customers.

Umm if you like them what does anyone else’s opinion matter? Come on OP, you’re a big girl now, you can decide on your own style! (I like them by the way but that’s irrelevant)

The New Look ones are nicer. I’m boycotting M&S anyway and you were right to discard them. They’re not nice.

www.marksandspencer.com/block-heel-chelsea-ankle-boots/p/clp60275068?extid=ps_gglpla_Women&gclsrc=aw.ds&&gclid=Cj0KCQiAk7TuBRDQARIsAMRrfUajpmXimoUlRni7fl5LFxagM28zblKrXvEbWfaOm_Ukrg5f5jBdUD8aArUREALw_wcB

I got these for M&S the other week and they're really comfy. I've worn them casual and dressier. They're vegan friendly aswell