Are these Mum boots? Pic attached

[DoubleDeClutchMuch]

just that really - can you give your opinion on them?
Thanks!

This is still the only place I have ever known "mum boots" to be discussed

Eurgh!

I couldn't wear them myself, because I have fat feet and they look quite narrow/ pointy toe boots always pinche me, but I think they're grand. Can't go far wrong with black leather and a basic silver zip? And heel looks like it would be easy to walk in.

I'm 23, so maybe it's when women hit a certain age they worry about "mum boots"?

Why Eurgh? What's wrong with them? Genuinely

I really think it depends what you plan to wear them with!

i wouldnt call them mum boots. they would look nice with skinny jeans and a nice shirt/blouse.

to me, yes! My mum would definitely wear them (she's pretty stylish for 65 though!)

What about skinny jeans, a brightly coloured top and black leather jacket?

Yes. Sorry :)

Depends on how you wear them. They'll look pretty good with black skinnies cuffed above the boot.

Yes.

I dunno, I think the pointy toe might just take them from mum boot territory.

I think so. Sorry.

The Kinks used to wear boots like that.

I think they'd look fine with the right outfit.

I'm not sure. The heel might make them a bit mum boot, but the zip and pointy toe might take them away from mum boot territory. I wouldn't say they were frumpy.

What's the opinion on these. Are they mum boots?

Compared to the ones at the top, yes. The pointy toe and block heel make the top ones look a bit more "now" the Carvela ones are a bit more classic.

They're pretty ugly to be honest

I don't think either of them are mum boots Worn with the right outfit, they would both look fine.

thanks for feedback. I am 50 and wear them with black skinnies and long layered tops

yes I thought the pointy toe was the saving grace!

can anyone link to a pair of definitely NOT mumboots? does such a thing exist

The first ones look fine to me. They'd be mum boots worn with bootlegs and a fleece but put them with something trendier and they'd look good.

The mum boot thing is less about the boot and more about how you wear them.

I have yet to see a single pair of boots on here that someone, somewhere doesn't think are mum boots.

I'm a mum and I wear boots. Ugg boots

I have a pair like this, wouldn't say they were mum boots?

m.newlook.com/shop/shoe-gallery/view-all-boots/black-suedette-lace-up-wedge-ankle-boots-_366038601?productFind=search

The mum boot thing is less about the boot and more about how you wear them.

aha! I think this is the secret.

wickedlazy those are not mum boots definitely not, but I wouldn't wear them personally. My DD would though (stylish 19 yr old)