Good idea Shrew! Maybe once a month we should all have a bit of a review, I must admit, I need to sit down and go back through the threads and re-do my wishlist, especially as I am also following Frugal's fantastic Korean thread too!
Here are the results from the Southern Italian jury 
Acid Toner- Olay cheap as chips 7 in 1 anti ageing. Has probably made the most difference to my skin of all the products. Love it. Am so carried away at how my skin seems somehow resurfaced that I am tempted to buy a posher more expensive one, but then think, why fix what isn't broken? I'll see....
Hydrating Toner- L'Occitane Immortelle Water. Got free sample in gift set. It's lovely. But I'd never pay that much for a toner. Will prob get rosewater next from supermarket. I used to use that.
Cleansers- LRP Physiological- bought this for dd on the back of Effaclar being so fab for her. It's boring. It's a bit meh. It's fine for dd's pre-teen face, but I won't use it again.
Elemis Pro Radiance neroli and bergamot. So bloody lovely. Thick creamy and smells divine. Will definitely repurchase but not at full price. Prob when QVC do their specials and then flog the Marine Cream on ebay as that does diddley for me.
Liz Earle CP, used to love it, no longer impressed. Won't buy again.
Boots Botanics balm- hated it at first because it was crunchy (it had crystallised) it's now my favourite, and the cheapest of all of them. Will definitely repurchase.
(I have almost finished the Botanics so am going to get a new balm cleanser, prob going to try the BS Chamomile)
Serums- Good old Boots Lift and Luminate. Day and night. Like them both, although I reckon the original Protect and Perfect is better. Very silicon-y though. Would repurchase for results and price.
NY Frankincense Intense. My biggest disappointment ever. Horrid horrid stuff. Still have 4 packets of it left. Cannot stand what it does to my face. Feel like someone has spread glue on it. Yuck.
(am going to go for a Vit C/hylamide type next, probably from ebay, possibly Korean- I am eyeing up the one which is supposed to replicate EL Advanced Night Repair.)
Moisturiser- L'Oreal anti wrinkle something or other. Another cheap as chips purchase. It's pretty good for the fiver I spent on it. Certainly better than Marine Cream which just pulled my skin off and felt like watery lotion.
Good old Astral on the neck and on the face when I feel particularly dry. Will always have a ginormous pot of it in the house. Always.
NY Rose Facial Oil- it's OK, but the NY Frankincense is better, richer for my ancient skin I feel. Will rebuy the Frank.
I started with RetinA but my skin broke out so I stopped.
Overall results: I am 50 in October and I know I don't look it. I am wearing only Boots botanics BB cream as foundation and no primer anymore. I feel my skin is now looking "my skin but better".
Term is finishing here, so will have lots more time to try out these fancy Korean masks and what have you, so will report back on those too.
Thanks again to everyone contributing to the quiche, am loving it! 