My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

Step-parenting

I don't like my stepdaughter.

222 replies

Momof3girls3boys · 15/11/2014 23:54

Ok. Here it goes. First I want to say, I have two stepdaughters. I am raising the youngest in my home. She is in all aspects my child although I didn't give birth to her. I love her unconditionally as I do my biological children. My problem is my older stepdaughter. I have major concerns and problems with her. About a year and a half ago she accused my 7 yr old of touching her sexually. My step daughter was 8 at this time. These accusations are totally unfounded and completely untrue. Two different state child services found these claims (and others I will mention shortly) to be totally untrue. In addition due to her mother trying to revoke my husband's visitation rights a court has also concluded all the accusations to be unfounded. A year prior to this incident (so 2 1/2 yrs ago) she accused my 16 yr old of touching her inappropriately (unfounded and untrue). My stepdaughter, 2 1/2 yrs ago, told me of her kissing 2 boys and a girl at school. When asked she told me she kissed all of them with using tongues. She has also accused me (I want to let you know I am a certified teacher, I teach kindergarten) of abusing her 1 1/2 yrs ago. Now, I do believe in spanking, but with that being said, I rarely spank my children. And I would never lay a hand on someone else's child. I might give a total of one spanking a year to all my kids combined. At that time she accused her dad, my husband of holding a sword to her throat and threatening to cut her head off and that he shot her with BB guns. All of her accusations have been investigated by child protective services and my husband, myself and the children have all been found innocent of all of her accusations. My husband has decided up until this point that she would no longer come to our house, but now she will be coming for Christmas this year. I'm so nervous about her visit and really am not looking forward to it. I feel horrible about this. I am going to try to have a great Christmas with all our kids but I can't get myself to quit disliking my stepdaughter no matter how hard I try. I've defended her to my husband when this all first happened saying her mother probably put her up to saying this stuff and that she's just a child. But now that I'm faced with having her come again and possibly accuse someone of something else I feel the way my husband did at first. Please help me deal with my conflicting emotions. Tell me I'm a horrible person or whatever. I am trying to work through this and except her as my daughter.

OP posts:
Report
StardustBikini · 24/11/2014 16:51

Hopefully MNHQ won't take so long to stamp it out this time.

MNHQ -would you care to comment?

Have previous posters on the stepparenting board been "stamped out" for expressing their opinions, as is claimed?

I haven't been party to the previous private correspondence between MNHQ and various members who have received warnings and (apparently) others who have received notifications of posters being banned, so I honestly don't know if this is the official MNHQ party line or whether this claim is just another way of dissuading people not to post their opinions.

Are certain opinions "officially" unwelcome, here? Is there a MN-tone to this board that is maintained through MNHQ moderation?

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 16:53

Hahahahaha

< properly dies of irony>

Report
NickiFury · 24/11/2014 16:57

Not unwelcome as such, just many people are pretty disgusted by them and thankfully aren't too intimidated to say so now. It's been lovely actually Smile.

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 17:00

I think you probably need to send your queries to mnhq. I don't think they read every thread in case a poster throws out a random question.
Unless your question was posted here as a sort of passive aggressive device or you know the thread has already been reported.

Hths.

Can I just ask though, when you post are you doing an impression of Jeremy Paxman because I like to think of you in a swivel chair and an eyebrow lifted in quizzical imagined superiority. You could totally do university challenge. You would rock at that. Have you got a blazer with cord elbow patches? That would be great.

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 17:01

< hopeful>

Report
FlossyMoo · 24/11/2014 17:03

Pag you have tickled my funny bone today. I thank you Flowers

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 17:08

Thank you Flossy. But honestly if you can't laugh at the preposterous then what's the point in mn. Smile

On a serious note my DH went to see his friend yesterday. He's 42 and in a hospice trying to write goodbye letters to his two small children. The idea that a man who would give anything to be with his children, who is hanging on to life to squeeze every moment out with them, is losing his fight. And people on here are arguing about abandoning an 8 year old because she is troublesome and inconvenient .
The world is sometimes beyond wrong.

Report
FlossyMoo · 24/11/2014 17:10

Oh Pag I am so sorry for your friend.

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 17:12
Flowers
Report
NickiFury · 24/11/2014 17:16

I'm sorry to hear that Pag. Brings it all into perspective really.

Report
ArsenicSoup · 24/11/2014 17:21

Are certain opinions "officially" unwelcome, here? Is there a MN-tone to this board that is maintained through MNHQ moderation?

That's serious irony. Respeck.

On a serious note my DH went to see his friend yesterday. He's 42 and in a hospice trying to write goodbye letters to his two small children. The idea that a man who would give anything to be with his children, who is hanging on to life to squeeze every moment out with them, is losing his fight. And people on here are arguing about abandoning an 8 year old because she is troublesome and inconvenient

Sorry to hear that Pag. It's a good point.

Report
ArsenicSoup · 24/11/2014 17:44

MNHQ can you comment on whether StardustElbowPatches is available as a nickname?

Report
MistressDeeCee · 24/11/2014 19:12

Thats a sad story. I wish all fathers would hold onto their children in that way.

When I was 8 my dad adopted his cousin, he had issues.which was understandable as his own mother died - then his dad decided to let him know, he wasn't his real father at all. From the moment he entered our home, my & my sister's childhood was ruined, he was an abusive child 3 years older than me. Disruptive for my DBs too, they were forever fighting with him he was aggressive; also wouldn't accept my mother wanted to care for him. It was ok for my dad, he just put his hat on and went to work (did a lot of night shifts so left home early evening )whilst we had all the shit going on.

I eventually moved from east to south london to get away from my cousin, as he just got worse as he got older. Never really plucked up the courage to say much to my dad about it until a couple of years ago. His attitude was 'well its all in the past now' & I could tell as long as it didnt directly affect him, he didn't care. I will never, ever forgive my dad for not putting us 1st, because I can't get my childhood back. I don't speak to him at all now, and Im glad. My parents marriage eventually ended anyway, not surprised looking back at it. Ours was a resentful home.

I really can't stand it when men shirk their duties and it always comes back down to a woman getting the blame.

OP admitted she knew her feelings were wrong and looks to me as if she got defensive when some posters began to slate her. Yes some of what she said was wrong..but having grown up in a horrid atmosphere, as an adult now I can fully understand how she feels.

She'll still end up getting the blame tho and her DCs feelings will be swept under the carpet too. I guess the dear father will be just fine with everyone else picking up the slack

Report
MistressDeeCee · 24/11/2014 19:14

Didnt know you could get banned for not falling in with majority opinion. Really?! I live and learn

Report
NickiFury · 24/11/2014 19:20

Where does it say that? Confused

Report
FlossyMoo · 24/11/2014 19:38

Oh god I shall await my ban then Shock

Report
Pagwatch · 24/11/2014 20:56

Do you know I didn't post after relaying my 'story'
I was rather regretting that someone would rather horrendously use a very nice man dying to score a petty point.

What was I thinking. Surely no one would stoop that low?
Hmm

Report
MistressDeeCee · 24/11/2014 22:52

Im hoping my comment isn't viewed as pointscoring.. I can't see any reason to pointscore on here; Its an emotive thread with lots of cooments from different posters. There is a comment highlighted in bold regarding MNHQ bans..I scrolled up, saw it and commented on it. Thats all.

Report
SingingTunelessly · 24/11/2014 23:30

I have to say this forum is not good for SPs who are struggling. Sad but true. Op, I hope you haven't been scared off asking for help but maybe this isn't the right place.

Report
Momof3girls3boys · 25/11/2014 04:52

I want to say I've only read to the end of page 3 before stopping to respond.
First, my DH and I are very concerned for my DSD's health and safety. That is why we have spent several thousands of dollars in legal costs to try to protect her. And we will continue to fight for her till she is 18 and can make her own choices, but then we will still help her in any and all ways. My DH knowns I would NOT treat her any different then the DC. We are fully prepared (or to get the help We might need) to raise her if we could ever get domicilary custody of her.

She is only a child and my internal conflicting emotions are unknown to her or the other children and they will NEVER know them. I show her all the love and support I give the our other children when she's here and when she's not I do it by phone. She is deeply loved!

Last, we NEVER talk negatively about any of the DC parents with any of our DC and if something negative is said it is NEVER around any of the DC or any other children. My philosophy on that is my feelings toward the other parent should never affect my DC feelings for their parent. With this belief all our DC hear only good things about their other parent or nothing at all from myself or my DH!

OP posts:
Report
Momof3girls3boys · 25/11/2014 05:14

And it is possible to not like a person but still love them! I learned that lesson many years ago the hard way.

OP posts:
Report
Momof3girls3boys · 25/11/2014 05:20

Oh and one more thing, yes I have become defensive. I am being accused of being a cruel person, saying I don't care for my DS and not trying to help her. That's a load of poop. We continue to love and care for her. We continue to fight for her. I have taken time and money from our other children to fight for my DS!!

OP posts:
Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

theressomethingaboutmarie · 25/11/2014 10:02

I think that this poor little girl is crying out for help. As someone who was 'rescued' by my dad and his wife when I was approximately 5, I thank Christ that it happened. I was emotionally and physically abused, permanently hungry and neglected. I am sure that I wasn't an easy child to bring into my dad's new family as I was traumatised (by what I had been through but also by the fact that my mum disappeared one day with her bastard of a partner and I walked home from school to find the Social Services waiting for me) but they showed me love, affection and proper family life and I thank my lucky stars, every damn day, that it happened.

Report
HesNotAMessiah · 25/11/2014 11:37

From the MN talk Guidelines

"Please do bear in mind how difficult this parenting business can be, and if there's one thing all of us could do with, it's some moral support."

The OP has come back to defend herself against some of that moral support, which reflects those assertions and insinuations that have come from some posters.

Unfortunately, it seems to be the same group of people who like to take issue with any thread rather than offer any positive help, and then revel in their mutual self righteousness for criticising the OP.

SingingTunelessly has it spot on -

"I have to say this forum is not good for SPs who are struggling. Sad but true"

Report
ArsenicSoup · 25/11/2014 12:34

The school of thought that constantly advises step-parents to detach, step away, that it's natural to prioritize the needs of DBC over the needs of DSC, that fairness is impossible so don't bother trying.... that is advice designed to make DSPs lives hard.

There is a difference between struggling internally (which most of us do as stepmothers) and first resort advice to give in to the temptation to wash your hands and put your biological DC first.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.