Unless, there have been safeguarding problems, we don’t know about, I’d say it’s in breach of his human right to have a private family life.
I was invited to go to Westminster in 2022, to give a speech to MPs and peers on how the Covid regulations for care homes and hospitals were affecting DD1. I wasn’t the only one - although all the other carers there, were caring for an elderly relative. One elderly person had dementia herself. The stories were heartbreaking - the pettiness and cruelty by care home managers was breathtaking.
Ditto, when I was asked to be a witness in the Covid 19 enquiry Module 6 on care homes, by a firm of human rights lawyers. I had quite a few conversations with them on human rights and visitors to care homes. I heard the same stories of pettiness and cruelty at the Enquiry. One family was refused permission to spend time with their dying parent; but as soon as they were dead, the care home asked the family to disinfect the room within three days. They refused.
Impact witnesses like us couldn’t just put whatever we felt like in our witness statements - the lawyers repeated asked me, to supply evidence in writing to support my points such as emails, letters, newspaper articles, etc wherever possible. Some evidence obviously was hearsay.
It was also blatantly obvious that care homes don’t understand the law about human rights, best interests decisions, DOLs, videoing, etc either.
After all I heard, I would never assume the care home was being reasonable and the family carer wasn’t.