Re cc - for me it depends on how long you leave them for. If it's only a few mins at a time I can't imagine it doing any harm. I think there's difference between cc and leaving a baby to cry it out, which I don't agree with.
My sis did cc with all four of hers when they hit 13-16 months (depending on the child) and none of them had to be left longer than 10 mins before it worked - except her DS, cc never worked with him and he was 4 before he slept through...
I guess when they're older they have the reasoning powers to understand you when you tell them you're not leaving them forever etc. whereas when they're babies there's a risk they think they've been abandoned (if left too long) and start to shut down their responses.
I think between 6 and 8 months is the best time to first try a little cc - after that the window closes for a bit (too much developmental stuff going on for them to learn another new skill ie sleeping...!)
Anyway, good luck NoSleep - I'll be interested to hear if it works!
DD doesn't usually cry (well, I have never left her long enough for her whimpering to develop into a cry) but I do leave her to whimper for a few mins if everything else has been tried and failed. Then I go back and try again... and again and usually she'll let me rock/cuddle/feed her to sleep after a few tries.
Never tried wake-to-sleep for naps or anything else. DD doesn't have enough of a real pattern for it to work at the mo!!
Last night wasn't too bad. DD was restless and woke quite a lot, but resettled with boob or dummy each time pretty quickly - until 05.45 when it took an hour to get her back down, whereupon she slept until 08.20.
My potential lie-in was sadly interrupted by a coughing fit, which I took out of the bedroom to avoid waking DD. Every time I tried to get back to bed, it threatened to start again until eventually I gave up. Ah well. As I said, up to then not TOO bad... (relatively speaking!!)