Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Sleep

Join our Sleep forum for tips on creating a sleep routine for your baby or toddler. Need more advice on your childs development? Sign up to our Ages and Stages newsletter here.

Feeling horrifically guilty for leaving my baby to cry

142 replies

ItsNotLupus · 17/07/2025 15:26

Please be gentle with me, I'm feeling very very fragile today. I have a 6 week old baby who has become very very clingy in the past fortnight, having previously been what I would describe as easy (lucky me, I'd thought smugly in the first few weeks postpartum!). She will NOT settle for naps during the day. I think she's gone as long as 8 hours in a single day without sleeping at all, which just isn't healthy, though she will occasionally drop off after a feed (I'm EBF). If I succeed in getting her to sleep on the boob, the only way to guarantee she sleeps is to stay sitting still. This essentially means I can't eat, drink or go to the toilet in that time. I also can't "sleep when the baby sleeps" as I'm making sure she's safe as she sleeps on me.

The other, much bigger issue, though is that if she's awake and I'm not holding her and bouncing her round, she just cries hysterically. I went out for a coffee with friends and their babies yesterday and whilst they sat and enjoyed their coffee with their chilled babies, I literally didn't get to sit down and spent the entire occasion dancing manically around the cafe and singing to my baby whilst my drink went cold. It makes me want to not leave the house as I'm conscious of pissing people off in public with the noise if she cries. But then I'm home alone all day, and at home I can't put her on a mat or in her crib to give myself a minute to eat or use the loo. So the only two ways I can enjoy peace are to shove a nipple in her mouth or be constantly moving her round. And today I just reached the end of my tether with it. I just did not want to bounce around anymore. My legs hurt, and I have no energy for bouncing because all I've eaten today is a cereal bar 8 hours ago, before she woke up.

Long story short, after literally hours of alternating between screaming, feeding and bouncing, I put her in her crib and just left her to cry. Only for about 5 minutes, but she never stopped. It got more and more hysterical to the point it sounded like she could explode. I was advised to do this by my midwife if things ever got overwhelming; it's the first time I've done it, and it hasn't helped. I feel a million times worse than I did when I was just irritated by the incessant bouncing. I am firmly against 'cry it out' as a form of sleep training as I believe it can cause attachment issues (I come from a psychology background). Now I'm feeling awful that I've caused my baby trauma. I didn't even achieve anything by leaving her. I didn't use the time to get a drink or use the loo, I just cried as well.

I don't know if this is the onset of PND or if I'm just having a low moment after multiple days of the same situation with an irritable baby. I also don't really know what I'm looking for by posting, I guess I just wanted to vent.

Can anyone else with older babies offer any assurance that it gets better, or that I haven't now permanently damaged the bond with my baby?
Any tips for encouraging non-contact naps (she sleeps fine in her crib at night!)?
Or ideas to keep a baby chilled without constantly being on the move? FWIW I already have a mobile, a bouncer, visual stimuli cards, a play mat and a tummy time mat. They each keep her attention for a maximum of 10 minutes before the hysterics start...

If you've made it this far, thanks for reading!

OP posts:
legoplaybook · 17/07/2025 22:36

Millie90 · 17/07/2025 22:05

I went through this exact thing and literally everyone I know who breastfed has the same story. EBF babies just do not settle themselves and they don't sleep. It's ok to give them some formula to see if it fixes these problems and helps you to start enjoying your time together because honestly, being breastfed doesn't make the slightest bit of difference to their health at all and it's not worth this misery ❤️. Give yourself a break!

I had 3 ebf babies, two were very chill, settled and slept well, one was not at all chill (but did sleep through from 6 weeks) - it wasn't related to feeding.

Answeringaquestiontonight · 17/07/2025 22:42

contact naps can work if you make sure you go to the loo before the feed, have a drink and snacks to hand and have the tv remote or a book or something to hand.

the pram also used to work for mine. They didn’t love the pram, but if I timed it with a nap then they would nap in it.

also you could try a sling. I found it took a bit to get used to it and they mostly only like it when I was moving (so it didn’t really work in the house), but it helped getting out and about.

Allswellthatendswelll · 17/07/2025 23:23

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/07/2025 22:14

Ps if you also had a toddler the newborn would be waiting crying like this quite a few times a day so please don't feel bad!

I was going to say this and also lots of babies cry in the car. Mine cried for 20 mins today (had stopped once to try and settle her) and I didn't like hearing it but there wasn't much I could do. She won't be traumatised. There's a huge gulf between this and emotional depravation.

All the advice on here is good. Look after yourself. You need to eat and drink for breastfeeding.

Allswellthatendswelll · 17/07/2025 23:25

Millie90 · 17/07/2025 22:05

I went through this exact thing and literally everyone I know who breastfed has the same story. EBF babies just do not settle themselves and they don't sleep. It's ok to give them some formula to see if it fixes these problems and helps you to start enjoying your time together because honestly, being breastfed doesn't make the slightest bit of difference to their health at all and it's not worth this misery ❤️. Give yourself a break!

Er no. Both my ebf babies were content especially DD who is super chilled out. OP isn't struggling with feeding.

Luckyforsome23 · 17/07/2025 23:37

Get a nice stretchy sling. You can eat, drink and use the loo with baby strapped to you. It isn’t recommended but I also napped sitting up in an armchair with baby strapped to my chest sometimes. My velcro baby is now a lovely 8 year old. This phase ends.

Groundhogday2025 · 17/07/2025 23:37

Not sure if anyone has suggested this already or if you already use one but don’t be afraid to use a dummy if you need to. What you’ve described is exactly how my daughter was and I hadn’t been convinced on them at first but around this stage they were a god send. I imagine you have got BF well established so I wouldn’t worry about causing any confusion at this stage. The sucking is very soothing and might just get you those extra minutes to get showered or dressed, it may help her stay asleep a bit longer too.

MissScarletInTheBallroom · 17/07/2025 23:46

Oh dear, OP.

Six weeks old is still absolutely tiny. She's far from the only baby to just want to be held all the time at that stage.

First of all, you will definitely not have damaged your bond with her by leaving her to cry for five minutes.

Secondly, you can't spoil a six week old baby by holding or cuddling them too much, and they're too young for a routine. Do you have a baby carrier or a sling? If not, get one. You can cook, eat, and if necessary go to the toilet with your baby strapped against you like a baby kangaroo.

I left my first baby to cry it out for ages because people convinced me he needed sleep training. It didn't work. He slept through when he was ready. He's a great sleeper now and we have a wonderful bond.

Just take things one step at a time. Hold your baby as much as you like but also take the time to eat, go to the loo and shower.

Kerri44 · 18/07/2025 06:54

HoofleWoofle · 17/07/2025 16:27

Leaving her to cry for 10 minutes is preferable to doing anything disastrous like shaking the baby. It’s much more preferable to put the baby down somewhere safe. Have a drink of water and then go again.

Totally agree, I had to walk out on mine in the past, they were safe and at no risk, I needed to just breathe

Kerri44 · 18/07/2025 06:58

ItsNotLupus · 17/07/2025 19:36

Oh wow, thank you all (well, all bar 3 rude posters) for your kind words and advice. I've read through every single one and I'm truly grateful for the kind words and practical tips. Too many for me to respond to personally, and there was a lot of overlapping content, so I'll respond generally.

  1. I do have a partner. He's out the house 7-5, Monday to Friday for work and does some online evening and weekend meetings. When he's not working he is very hands on domestically, and the baby is happy to be soothed by him, unless it's food she's after.
  1. Lots of suggestions to use a sling. I do have one, but she really hates it currently. She's very much exploring kicking her little legs around so it may be that she finds it restrictive. I will keep persevering though.
  1. She does generally settle in the pram; I try to go walking where possible, particularly when she's not settling, but it rained all day today so it wasn't an option. Hopefully tomorrow will be brighter so we can get some fresh air.
  1. Reflux came up a few times - this has been an issue since she was 3 weeks old. It's not silent though, and we ended up in A&E one evening because she wasn't holding anything down at all. She was thoroughly checked and they were happy with her health overall and breastfeeding latch. I have been advised to hold her upright for 30 minutes after feeding. This is easier at night as she falls asleep over my shoulder, but hard in the daytime when she's awake and wriggling. I do think this is probably a major source of her discontent and the thing I need to work on.

As an aside note, I'm feeling much better than earlier. DH took over when he got home and I popped out for a dog walk on my own to clear my head. She did a giant poo in my absence so I think this is probably what's been bothering her all day - she's quite calm now.

Thank you again for the kind words. I'm going to ignore the judgemental comments which criticised me but offered no practical solutions.

Something to keep in your mind is cows milk protein allergy...my Son was exactly like your Daughter and had a CMPA

Policeofficerpanda · 18/07/2025 06:59

Is baby hungry? I had similar with mine at 3 months.turned out my supply had dropped massively and baby was starving.

FusionChefGeoff · 18/07/2025 07:06

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 17/07/2025 16:23

She's six weeks old - please please don't leave her to cry.

This is not helpful!!! Did you read the post??? She is at the end of her tether. A baby that is loved and looked after and has every need tended do at all other times can be left for 5-10 minutes whilst Mum gets food or has a speed shower or a wee for Gods sake.

Usernamenotav · 18/07/2025 13:14

Look, if you have to leave them for 5 minutes whilst you calm down then you did the safest thing for your baby. I hate the idea of babies being left to cry. It really isn't good for them as you know. But you did your best. Can you babywear? Get a good sling and just wear her all day if you need to. It doesn't last long. If she's crying constantly maybe something else is going on? Milk allergy maybe? Colic?

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:16

Usernamenotav · 18/07/2025 13:14

Look, if you have to leave them for 5 minutes whilst you calm down then you did the safest thing for your baby. I hate the idea of babies being left to cry. It really isn't good for them as you know. But you did your best. Can you babywear? Get a good sling and just wear her all day if you need to. It doesn't last long. If she's crying constantly maybe something else is going on? Milk allergy maybe? Colic?

@Usernamenotav

so sorry you don’t like the idea of it, but it won’t have done OP’s baby any harm whatsoever.

Gowlett · 18/07/2025 13:18

My baby was like this. I would do anything to comfort him.

Then, one day, during a crying episode, I just left the room.

Stared out the window, feeling like the worst mother ever…

And then, he just fell asleep. He was in his basket. Safe.

Usernamenotav · 18/07/2025 13:19

tripleginandtonic · 17/07/2025 16:01

I think you need to reframe crying. Babies cry to communicate, not because they're desperately sad or distraught. A lot of the crying will just be normal conversation, albeit you're still learning her language. You can safely ignore someone wittering on, so leaving a baby crying for a few minutes really won't do any harm. And with the greatest respect, if that's what you got from your psychology lessons, then you've not been paying full attention in class.

Its clear from her description that he baby wasn't just babbling to communicate. Babies shouldn't be left to cry as you've stated.
She clearly has been listening in her psychology lessons and is clearly a great mum because of it.
She did what she had to do and 5 minutes won't hurt. But repeatedly? Yes it would cause issues!

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:22

Usernamenotav · 18/07/2025 13:19

Its clear from her description that he baby wasn't just babbling to communicate. Babies shouldn't be left to cry as you've stated.
She clearly has been listening in her psychology lessons and is clearly a great mum because of it.
She did what she had to do and 5 minutes won't hurt. But repeatedly? Yes it would cause issues!

@Usernamenotav

right….well what do you want Op to do when she needs to shower or use the toilet or eat? Just keep holding the baby and not wash? Piss/shit herself? Starve?

Scottishgirl85 · 18/07/2025 13:23

OK don't panic. You haven't harmed your baby in any way. But the secret to an "easy baby" is them learning to self-settle. I never let my 3 sleep on me, ever! They were always in cot, buggy or car seat for sleeps. Can you get her to nap in buggy, and then attach a rock-it to keep buggy jiggling when you're home? Then slowly decrease dependence on rockers etc.

CommissarySushi · 18/07/2025 13:27

Millie90 · 17/07/2025 22:05

I went through this exact thing and literally everyone I know who breastfed has the same story. EBF babies just do not settle themselves and they don't sleep. It's ok to give them some formula to see if it fixes these problems and helps you to start enjoying your time together because honestly, being breastfed doesn't make the slightest bit of difference to their health at all and it's not worth this misery ❤️. Give yourself a break!

Absolute bollocks ❤️

FlyingHighFlyingLow · 18/07/2025 13:27

Fellow velcro baby mum here.

Sling is a good way to go. They do fuss while you're putting them into it but settle once in. Try go to local sling library to check the sling fits properly. Due to my body shape the ergobaby etc just didn't work for me. At 6 weeks mine went into a stretchy wrap. Loved it! I was able to go out for walks, meet friends in cafes etc and baby would snooze on my chest in the sling while I ate with my hands free. As baby got older I moved to a lillebaby as that had better straps for my body shape. That's why a sling library is good so you can try them on and see what fits you.

Give yourself a break, and prepare, prepare, prepare. DH would make my food for the day before he went to work. He would make it all up and put it in the fridge ready for me to grab when I could. Meant meals were quick and easy for me rather than trying to make food while the baby cried.

Lean into the contact naps. Get a drink, easy to eat with one hand snacks and have a chill on sofa with baby and watch some box sets, read a book, drink and food conveniently placed and on hand. Sling is good for this also as meant I could get up and pee 🤣.

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:29

CommissarySushi · 18/07/2025 13:27

Absolute bollocks ❤️

@CommissarySushi

is is isn’t worth a mum being miserable - what’s bollocks about that?

nicky2512 · 18/07/2025 13:31

I had a baby like that a long time ago! Screamed for about 12 weeks. I will never forget the noise. We tried everything but sometimes she just had to be left to scream for a while. She is now 23 and has turned out perfectly fine!
Don’t be too hard on yourself.

CommissarySushi · 18/07/2025 13:32

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:29

@CommissarySushi

is is isn’t worth a mum being miserable - what’s bollocks about that?

It's just factually wrong. The op hasn't mentioned feeding issues at all so there's no reason to suggest formula either.

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:37

CommissarySushi · 18/07/2025 13:32

It's just factually wrong. The op hasn't mentioned feeding issues at all so there's no reason to suggest formula either.

@CommissarySushi

youve not answered my question..is breast feeding worth a mum being miserable??

CommissarySushi · 18/07/2025 13:39

Cherrytree86 · 18/07/2025 13:37

@CommissarySushi

youve not answered my question..is breast feeding worth a mum being miserable??

No, of course not. But the op hasn't said breastfeeding is making her miserable.

And it isn't true that formula fed babies sleep better.

SouthLondonMum22 · 18/07/2025 13:40

Usernamenotav · 18/07/2025 13:19

Its clear from her description that he baby wasn't just babbling to communicate. Babies shouldn't be left to cry as you've stated.
She clearly has been listening in her psychology lessons and is clearly a great mum because of it.
She did what she had to do and 5 minutes won't hurt. But repeatedly? Yes it would cause issues!

How do parents of multiple children get things done then?

I have twins. If they were never left to cry for 5 minutes or so on yes, multiple occasions then the other baby would always be hungry or in a dirty nappy.

Sometimes babies have to cry for a bit and of course they are fine.

Swipe left for the next trending thread