Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

What you would like to see in MN Local?

126 replies

EmmaMumsnet · 08/02/2012 10:49

We are redesigning Local and want to hear what you think. What would you like to see on there? How could we make it better?

The plans are to make it easier to navigate and make your local talk threads visible when you use the main talk boards. We will also be adding lots more listings. There will be all the existing stuff, toddler groups, afterschool classes etc, but we're thinking of expanding. Would you be more comfortable buying a car from other MNers than from a second hand car dealer, for example?

Let us know all your thoughts on function and content.

Thanks,
MNHQ

OP posts:
SuePurblybilt · 08/02/2012 19:14

I've said this before to MNHQ so I promise I am not snarking, just adding it here for tidiness.

Devon is a big county. I think we have Exeter and Plymouth as local sites- my nearest board is Exeter. That's well over an hour's drive away and more like 2 and a half hours to those in North Devon. So the groups/meets/events don't mean anything to us.

Nobody uses the board to any real extent (I presume) because of this and so events from outside Exeter rarely really get posts. Vicious cycle, innit Grin.

So I would like a division, there are fairly clear council boundaries within Devon - boards based on them would work. Or at least a North Devon site so that those in the middle can choose.

notveryinventive · 08/02/2012 20:08

Same as Sue, but with my area of North Yorkshire. ATM I live in York which is fine, but Im moving soon and there is no board for where I am moving too. How about splitting it up into counties and into major towns and cities?

fluffywhitekittens · 08/02/2012 21:18

Have to agree that Netmums do local boards better :)

ashamednamechanger · 08/02/2012 22:03

Agree with Sue....my local board is nowhere near me either. We don't all live in the city centre.

fatcaaah · 08/02/2012 22:11

Another one who would say look at netmums local boards, I do go there for them and it makes me sad I have to do that!

Agree with all the above re local listings of events and groups (both for children and adults) and reviews of local businesses etc.

However the 'my dh is a plasterer/chippie/sparks so use him' posts get quite annoying over there so reviews rather than just posts would be better. Though not sure how you police that!

I've bought loads of crap i don't need useful stuff in their local boards too.

QED · 08/02/2012 22:13

I would like it if the events which have been put on York local which are running until 2024 supposedly (yes for another 12 years) could get edited so that they aren't at the top for ever. Events that are one day events get pushed down so you only see them if you go and look at the whole part rather than when you look on the bit on the right hand side, when in Active Conversations. Have reported them but nothing happens :(

fatcaaah · 08/02/2012 22:15

And don't make areas too wide, it's a pain trawling through posts finding stuff nearby when you live in a large 'local' area.

Making it easy to sign up for more areas and get updates from each of them would be much better, but more if a pain for you I imagine.

MissKittyMiddleton · 08/02/2012 22:18

I will be back with a long concise list tomorrow but I will say there is no point copying Nethuns. They do what they do well but MN must be different. Otherwise why bother?

ShagOBite · 08/02/2012 22:35

I would like to see a tripadvisor style local reviews page.

fatcaaah · 08/02/2012 23:26

Good point missKitty but MN will do it so much better once they get their fingers out. Wink

heliumballoon · 08/02/2012 23:38

I think the biggest problem is lack of traffic. Do most posters access Talk through Active Threads and if so, could a chosen local area's postings be shown in that list even if not active but (say) posted in the last 12 hrs.
Also many local threads get started on the main boards eg pg in Oxford. I don't think these tend to get linked to the local site?
I wonder whether London would be better divided into north, south, east, west etc rather than boroughs as many of us live onthe edge or are mobile/ happy to travel eg to a meetup.

UphillBothWays · 09/02/2012 00:22

Netmums advertises its local section really prominently and you get lots of emails about stuff happening in your local area - this is really necessary to get a thriving local section IMO, because you need a critical mass of people interacting and posting for people to bother looking at it.

LovesBeingWearingSkinnyJeans · 09/02/2012 06:08

I agree it needs to be in a local link rather than a delegate at tge back bit. Or even both? Having it like tge recipe section rather than a topic would help cause you could say if posting is an option or not. Nm do mostly local pick up rather than posting.

Needingsomeadvice · 09/02/2012 07:12

I was just thinking...I remember when Ciao was starting up (review site) they paid people 10p a review or something and it very quickly filled right up. Not saying you need to pay people, but there needs to be some incentive for putting up listings/info or you need to make sure that people will look at their local area board. As it is I have to really go find it, but it needs to be something I would have to see every day...to encourage posts?

gazzalw · 09/02/2012 07:18

Also, activities etc...that are going onlocally maybe that Mumsnetters flag up rather than people who pay for the privilege.....

For busy parents it's always good to have an up-to-date snapshot of what's going on if one hasn't had time to organise anything! Particularly during the hols....

Agree with all previous posts with good ideas! Whereas the main site bit thrives and is a wealth of empowered and interesting information the 'local' bit seems a bit of a poor relation add-on and yet potentially that is where we could discover invaluable information for day-to-day life!

DilysPrice · 09/02/2012 08:05

Competitions where you have to enter something on your local board would be a good way to get people visiting and posting reviews etc - but the local area also needs to be more prominent - I wouldn't even know And you should let people pick up to 3 boards that are their "local" are so you then see all postings/ads from all 3 areas on your personal "local" page

I don't use NM, because I have some standards, but I do sonetimes end up in a variety of standalone forums, including a couple of Clapham yummy mummy sites whose very existence is a sign that MN hasn't got it's act together in this issue.

Needingsomeadvice · 09/02/2012 08:11

Maybe as well as having local Tsarinas we need to have regular meetups arranged. Would love to be able to meet other mumsnetters more easily. I know you have this function but often people put things and forget to check (out of sight, out of mind?).

JiltedJohnsJulie · 09/02/2012 11:13

Agree with the others sorry MN, the Netmums Noticeboard beats MN local in so many ways.

HelenMumsnet · 09/02/2012 12:03

@TheJoyfulPuddlejumper

I would love to see a 'meet a local mum' section like Netmums has. I have met so many great people through that, it's the only thing that the huns do better than Mumsnet! As far as I can see, at the moment the only way on MN to find local mums who want to meet new friends is to start a thread.

Hello. We do have have Meet-ups section in Local already (if you go to your Local and look to the right of the Local Directory, you'll see it) but clearly we need to make that more obvious!

HelenMumsnet · 09/02/2012 12:05

@peggyblackett

A 'For Sale' section - would be great to be able to sell baby stuff locally.

There is a Nearly New/For Sale section on all Local pages, peggyblackett. (Again, we obviously need to flag that up more!)

kotuku · 09/02/2012 12:05

Meet a mum board would be good. And make it easier to arrange meetups.
For example people could register their interest in meetups in their area and and allow an organiser to send a bulk message to those interested.
I ran a NM meetup group and the problem was there was no easy way to contact everyone about a meetup, unless they had signed up for alerts or looked at the board regulary, I moved it over to FB in the end, easier to contact everyone, especially if there were last minute chanages due to the weather etc.

MissKittyMiddleton · 09/02/2012 12:06

Having thought quite carefully about this, I think the following are worth considering:

? It is too boring at the moment and to find anything you have to pick from a list of hundreds of classes/services and there might not even be anything in the section. It needs to look more interesting and be easier to use.

You must be different to Nethuns. No point reinventing the wheel. With that in mind I would suggest:

? Section to post volunteer opportunities. Many MNers are quite bright and would like the opportunity to do something on maternity leave or that is just for them as a SAHP.

? Section to post details of local support organisations. There are many local charities/social enterprises that do great work but nobody knows about them.

? Allow people to add pictures to listings to brighten it up.

? Cross-reference to different sections. Nethuns is very much stuff for mums and stuff for children. Some activities would sit well in both but it is not possible to load it once in multiple sections. Having a tick box to add the listing to multiple sections automatically be great and allow better searching (and an improvement on nethuns).

? Better search facility. Being able to search by date, location and type of activity would be good as would bring able to see results on a map or a list. Also being able to search by age of child, price and rating would be good, as would bring able to load abd search for pregnancy, new baby, toddler, preschooler, half-term etc etc. As would knowing how well dads rated or how well mums rated maybe. On Nethuns you have to go into each section to find stuff and it's really bitty. There's just too many sections really.

? weekend/half term/summer holiday specials/round ups. You could use local bloggers or write yourself using freelancers. You could mail these out and charge for advertising and promotional listings.

? Something for dads. Nethuns don't really cater for dads.

? Section to post meet ups. Lots of people organise meet ups so MN doesn't need to start doing this necessarily but just provide a space to share those meet ups so people can see what's on offer.

? A way to rate a local listing/service. Out of 5 stars say.

? Section for local MNers to post business details for free (Nethuns do this) but perhaps in addition to the usual childminders, cleaners and handy men make the most of the demographic and try to attract lawyers, accountants, architects and other professionals.

? More local competitions to encourage people to post events and updates.

? Better homepage for local (you can put your ads here to make some money!) with news, stories and a selections of top what's on listings. On Nethuns these listings are paid for. It would be nice if promoted listings made it on merit on MN. This would allow some of the free/low cost or charity options to get a look in.

? Redefine what an "event" is. At the moment people post course, classes and meet ups in "events" because they know it'll feature on the box on the Talk board. Realistically courses should disappear as soon as they cannot be joined any more. Sections for meet ups, support groups, classes and courses, fairs and fetes, baby/toddler groups etc would be better when coupled with better search facility.

? Instead of a link to events on the Talk board how about most recent activity? Then it moves a bit quicker and might encourage people to click into local more often.

? Make the local Tsarina job a proper, paid job with responsibilities for generating ad revenue and writing copy (or split it between ads and copy). You could do this using freelancers or employees but obviously the latter would take more admin and cost more in management time. S/he could also manage the local page to remove duplicate listings, listings with end dates months ahead and edit and move incorrect listings.

--

I'll do Richmond just for the chance to use the red button Grin

HelenMumsnet · 09/02/2012 12:07

@completenamechange

Also there is a lot of abuse of the local EVENTS section. This is quite a high profile listing as they are displayed when you are in the Talk section. Some groups list courses running for several weeks so they are displayed for ages, which means that individual events (like my Children in Need event last year) didn't get a look in.

Please do report this kind of stuff to us. We'll happily move courses, wrongly listed in Events, to the Listings Directory - where they should be.

HelenMumsnet · 09/02/2012 12:09

Thanks everyone for your suggestions and criticisms. All v v useful

Please keep 'em coming...

MissKittyMiddleton · 09/02/2012 12:13

You could respond a lot quicker to reports of dodgy listings (the report button was my suggestion btw ).

On average it takes about 2 reports and a week plus a thread in site stuff to get things done. You need more staff manning the local section.